Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Met Audience Tips Its Hat to FEDORA on New Year's Eve

Yoncheva, Beczala and Feola Lead New McVicar Production of Rarely Seen Giordano Work, Conducted by Armiliato

Review: Met Audience Tips Its Hat to FEDORA on New Year's Eve
Beczala and Yoncheva. Photo: Ken Howard/Met Opera

Musicologist Joseph Kerman is probably most widely remembered for calling Puccini's TOSCA "a shabby little shocker." I wonder whether he'd have something similar to say about Giordano's FEDORA, which brought the Met audience to its feet on New Year's Eve?

The two works are based on source material provided by French playwright Victorien Sardou (a favorite of Sarah Bernhardt), though TOSCA had a little more meat on its bones, with a little more wit and style. TOSCA's also much easier to follow, despite, perhaps, a lack of connective tissue from act to act.

The paucity of cohesion didn't seem to matter much to the audience on Saturday night's gala premiere of the 1898 work that had its debut in Milan, conducted by the composer, who also has ANDREA CHENIER to his credit.

Review: Met Audience Tips Its Hat to FEDORA on New Year's Eve
Yoncheva. Photo: Ken Howard/Met Opera

Soprano Sonya Yoncheva in the title role (Princess Fedora Romazoff) and tenor Piotr Beczala as Loris Ipanov, who killed the princess's fiancée but nonetheless becomes her lover, were in fine form, sounding forceful and full voiced and perfectly at home with the material. The soprano, in particular, seemed more at home in the title role than in any other recent performance I've heard from her at the Met.

They were ably assisted by soprano Rosa Feola, as Fedora's cousin Countess Olga, who, for me at least, was shown to better effect than she was in her heralded turn as Gilda in the debut of the current production of RIGOLETTO, showing personality and verve, as well as a lovely voice. Others in the cast were Richard Bernstein (Boroff), Scott Scully (Rouvel) and Lucas Meacham (De Sireix).

The result: The opera seemed to supply the audience with a helluva good time, despite a plot that even left the creators of the production scratching their heads, as detailed in a New York Times feature a couple of days earlier, and enough melodrama for a half-dozen silent movies. (It made me long for the days before subtitles came to the Met.) The production's creators made much of the difficulties those involved seemed to have making sense of Colautti's libretto

Review: Met Audience Tips Its Hat to FEDORA on New Year's Eve
Yonchev and Beczala. Photo: Ken Howard/Met Opera

When the overture began, with the Met orchestra in fine fettle under Marco Armiliato, I thought we were in for a Puccini wannabe--not the worst way to pass an evening. Later, however, Giordano seemed to forget where he was heading and the orchestra sounded like it had taken a detour to the Highlands and I half-expected the curtain to reveal the choristers (ably led, as always, by Donald Palumbo) dressed in kilts as a Scottish Guard.

David McVicar's production had an ornate but generic set by Charles Edwards that could have served up a TRAVIATA on an off night, with lighting by Adam Silverman, and gorgeous, over-the-top costumes by Brigitte Reiffenstuel (particularly for Yoncheva).

Review: Met Audience Tips Its Hat to FEDORA on New Year's Eve
Feola and Meacham. Photo: Ken Howard/Met Opera

It seemed a fitting farewell to the good old days. I wonder how many more we'll see like this (even the upcoming DON GIOVANNI has a stark, brutalist look to it), now that the Met's planning to skew its productions toward contemporary works like THE HOURS, FIRE SHUT UP IN MY BONES and opening night next season, DEAD MAN WALKING. (And, perhaps, how long it'll take to see an about-face...?)



Hungarian State Opera Presents THE WOODEN PRINCE Photo
On 11 February 2023, the Hungarian State Opera presents a Bartók double bill featuring two of his pieces that enjoyed their world premieres at the Budapest Opera House over a hundred years ago. The Wooden Prince is staged with a new choreography by László Velekei, whereas Bluebeard’s Castle can be seen in the 2018 production by the Danish star director Kasper Holten.

Houston Grand Opera Joins Forces with Houston Ebony Opera Guild, Prairie View A&M, And Photo
On Friday, February 24, 2023, Houston Grand Opera (HGO) will stage the fourth annual Giving Voice concert in partnership with Wheeler Avenue Baptist Church, the Houston Ebony Opera Guild, Prairie View A&M University, and Texas Southern University. The fourth annual concert will be presented outside the Wortham Theater Center for the first time, at the new Cathedral of the historic Wheeler Avenue Baptist Church in the Third Ward, in celebration of Black History Month.

Edmonton Opera Announces 60th Season Featuring CARMEN, DON GIOVANNI & More Photo
Audiences are invited to Edmonton Opera’s Diamond Anniversary Season, celebrating a proud history of 60 years of opera in Edmonton.

Opera Columbus Announce First Spanish Tango Opera Performed In Columbus: MARIA DE BUENOS A Photo
The sensual rhythms of tango combine with operatic passions in Maria de Buenos Aires is bringing heat to the Ohio February Air.  Astor Piazzolla's revolutionary nuevo tango score and Horacio Ferrer's mesmerizing poetry unite the ghostly realm with the physical world to portray the spiritual journey of the opera's heroine.   


From This Author - Richard Sasanow

Richard Sasanow has been BroadwayWorld.com's Opera Editor for many years, with interests covering contemporary works, standard repertoire and true rarities from every era. He is an intervi... (read more about this author)


Review: Exquisitely Subtle CARMELITES Makes Another of Its Brief Stops at the MetReview: Exquisitely Subtle CARMELITES Makes Another of Its Brief Stops at the Met
January 20, 2023

I’ve heard the opera a number of times at the Met over the years and this year’s run holds up with the most breathtaking of them. Despite the number of star performances among the magnificent ensemble currently being heard at the Met, the star of the show doesn’t have a single word to say or note to sing. It's the John Dexter production that does it.

Review: At the Met, All You Need is Love, When L'ELISIR is in the Right HandsReview: At the Met, All You Need is Love, When L'ELISIR is in the Right Hands
January 12, 2023

Donizetti wrote more than six dozen operas in the course of around 30 years, so it must have been hard for him not to steal from himself. Still, it always strikes me during the overture to his great comedy L’ELISIR D’AMORE, whose run at the Met opened the other night, when I hear echoes of the oh-so-dramatic LUCIA DI LAMMERMOOR, which would come just a few years later. Yet, the similar music somehow works in both operas.

Review: O'Halloran Double-Bill Brings Complex Emotions to the Surface at PROTOTYPEReview: O'Halloran Double-Bill Brings Complex Emotions to the Surface at PROTOTYPE
January 10, 2023

A powerful double bill by Irish composer Emma O’Halloran, to libretti by her playwright uncle, Mark O’Halloran, deals with disappointment, connection and heartbreak--and what makes people tick. You know, 'the usual.'

Review: 10th Anniversary PROTOTYPE Festival in NY Blasts Off with Du Yun's IN OUR DAUGHTER'S EYESReview: 10th Anniversary PROTOTYPE Festival in NY Blasts Off with Du Yun's IN OUR DAUGHTER'S EYES
January 6, 2023

There’s more contemporary opera in New York these days than there used to be and I’ll drink to that. But there’s nothing else that does it with the panache of the PROTOTYPE Festival, the brainchild of Beth Morrison Projects and HERE.

Review: Met Audience Tips Its Hat to FEDORA on New Year's EveReview: Met Audience Tips Its Hat to FEDORA on New Year's Eve
January 1, 2023

Musicologist Joseph Kerman is probably most widely remembered for calling Puccini’s TOSCA “a shabby little shocker.” I wonder whether he’d have something similar to say about Giordano’s FEDORA, which brought the Met audience to its feet on New Year’s Eve?