Exclusive: HAMILTON, WICKED, & More Are Spotify's Most-Streamed Cast Albums of 2025

The 2025 Spotify Wrapped is here, and we have exclusive data from the most-streamed musical theater albums from stage and screen this past year. The annual streaming tradition examines top streaming trends and provides personalized data for each Spotify user, detailing their year in listening. 

According to information shared with BroadwayWorld, the most-streamed cast recording in 2025 was Broadway's Hamilton. This coincides with the tenth anniversary of the hit musical, which celebrated the occasion with multiple events throughout the year. Across all cast recordings (with film soundtracks omitted), top-streamed musical theater songs were also from the album, with “Wait for It," “Satisfied," and “Non-Stop” coming in the top three. 

Other top-streamed stage musical theater albums in 2025 were the world premiere cast recording of Heathers: The Musical and the original Broadway cast recordings of Hadestown, Wicked, and Dear Evan Hanson. Heathers is currently playing an off-Broadway revival at New World Stages, while Hadestown continues to be a favorite among Broadway fans. With the success of the two-part Wicked movie, it is no surprise that listeners are also flocking to the original cast album.

With data from movie musicals included, the soundtracks for The Greatest Showman, Wicked, Grease, and Mamma Mia! came in behind Hamilton as musical theater favorites. Take a look at the data below, which includes all the top-streamed musical albums and songs from the past year.

2025 Top Musical Theater Albums and Songs (Movie Soundtracks Omitted)

2025’s Top Musical Theater Albums on Spotify:

1. Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Lin-Manuel Miranda

1. Heathers: The Musical (World Premiere Cast Recording) by Various Artists

2. Hadestown (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Original Broadway Cast of Hadestown

3. Wicked by Various Artists

4. Dear Evan Hansen (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Various Artists

2025’s Top Musical Theater Songs on Spotify:

1. “Wait for It” by Leslie Odom Jr.

2. “Satisfied” by Renée Elise Goldberry

3. “Non-Stop” by Leslie Odom Jr. 

4. “Alexander Hamilton” by Leslie Odom Jr.

5. “The Schuyler Sisters” by Renée Elise Goldberry

2025’s Top Musical Theater Albums Amongst Gen Z Listeners on Spotify:

1. Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Lin-Manuel Miranda

2. Heathers: The Musical (World Premiere Cast Recording) by Various Artists

3. Hadestown (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Original Broadway Cast of Hadestown

4. Dear Evan Hansen (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Various Artists

5. Wicked by Various Artists

2025’s Top Musical Theater Songs Amongst Gen Z Listeners on Spotify:

1. “Wait for It” by Leslie Odom Jr.

2. “Non-Stop” by Leslie Odom Jr. 

3. “Satisfied” by Renée Elise Goldberry

4. “Burn” by Phillipa Soo

5. “The Schuyler Sisters” by Renée Elise Goldberry

2025 Top Musical Theater Albums and Songs (Movie Soundtracks Included)

2025’s Top Musical Theater Albums on Spotify:

1. Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Lin-Manuel Miranda

2. The Greatest Showman (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) by Various Artists 

3. Wicked: The Soundtrack by Wicked Movie Cast

4. Grease (The Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) by Various Artists

5. Mamma Mia! The Movie Soundtrack by Cast of Mamma Mia! The Movie 

2025’s Top Musical Theater Songs on Spotify:

1. “You’re The One That I Want - From ‘Grease” by John Travolta & Olivia Newton-John

2. “Rewrite The Stars” by Zac Efron & Zendaya

3. “Defying Gravity” by Cynthia Erivo & Ariana Grande

4. “What Is This Feeling?” by Ariana Grande & Cynthia Erivo

5. “Popular” by Ariana Grande

2025’s Top Musical Theater Albums Amongst Gen Z Listeners on Spotify:

1. Hamilton (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Lin-Manuel Miranda

2. The Greatest Showman (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) by Various Artists 

3. Mamma Mia! The Movie Soundtrack by Cast of Mamma Mia! The Movie 

4. Wicked: The Soundtrack by Wicked Movie Cast

5. Grease (The Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) by Various Artists

2025’s Top Musical Theater Songs Amongst Gen Z Listeners on Spotify:

1. “Rewrite The Stars” by Zac Efron & Zendaya

2. “Would You Fall in Love with Me Again” by Jorge Rivera-Herrans

3. “Defying Gravity” by Cynthia Erivo & Ariana Grande

4. “Wait for It” by Leslie Odom Jr.

5. “Non-Stop” by Leslie Odom Jr.

Photo Credit: Disney