Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: WAITRESS at Skylight Music Theatre

The production runs through October 27

By:
Review: WAITRESS at Skylight Music Theatre

Just as the main ingredients of pie are – sugar, butter and flour. The main ingredients of “Waitress” – currently kicking off Skylight Music Theater’s 65th season – are imperfection, love and female solidarity. Topped with a sprinkle of naughtiness.

“Waitress” started its shift in 2007 as a movie and was transformed into a musical play in 2015 with music by Sara Bareilles

Jenna, a baker and waitress in a diner, is in an abusive relationship with her husband, She unexpectedly becomes pregnant and begins an affair with her doctor - who's as different from her husband as two men could be. Baking pies has long been her refuge and may be also be her escape.

Jenna, played Julia Levinson, is both the heart and voice of the story, but the supporting characters all have their moments to shine.

Levinson voice blends perfectly with that of Matthew Kacergis as the sweet, hapless Dr. Pomatter. Together their duets soar.

But the real love story is between Jenna and her two best friends – also waitresses at the diner. Raven Monique Dockery is all warmth and strength as Becky. Alex Merkel provides a balancing dose of delicate, whimsical energy as Dawn.

Dawn and Becky also find unexpected love - as the objects of their affection, Brade Bradshaw and Andrew Varela more than hold their own in the female-centric world of "Waitress."

The blending to the three voices is a musical celebration of the power of female friendship.

It’s Levinson’s solo of “She Used to be Mine,” that’s the showstopper, however. Longtime fans of this musical as well as those experiencing it for the first time will be blown away by Levinson’s powerful, poignant rendition.  

There is occasionally too much of a good thing – the orchestra and an early voiceover sometimes fought with the actors’ voices for dominance – the good news is the actors ultimately win.

In the end, a great server always deserves a good tip.  Here it is: Don’t miss “Waitress” at the Skylight Theatre

Click Here to Get Tickets

Reader Reviews

Need more Milwaukee, WI Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


The Play That Goes Wrong in Milwaukee, WI The Play That Goes Wrong
Racine Theatre Guild (9/11-9/27)
Dad's Season Tickets in Milwaukee, WI Dad's Season Tickets
Racine Theatre Guild (7/17-7/26)
A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder in Milwaukee, WI A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder
Skylight Music Theatre (3/12-3/28)
"A Christmas Carol" in Milwaukee, WI "A Christmas Carol"
Pabst Theater (12/02-12/24)
The Good One in Milwaukee, WI The Good One
Sixth Street Theatre (7/24-8/02)
Trayf in Milwaukee, WI Trayf
Next Act Theatre (9/16-10/04)
SIX (Boleyn Tour) in Milwaukee, WI SIX (Boleyn Tour)
Uihlein Hall at Marcus Center For The Performing Arts (2/02-2/07)
Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra: Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secrets In Concert in Milwaukee, WI Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra: Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secrets In Concert
Riverside Theater (12/05-12/05)
Churchill in Milwaukee, WI Churchill
Wilson Theater at Vogel Hall (10/01-10/01)
"JP Coletta’s Rock ‘N’ Roll Piano Man" in Milwaukee, WI "JP Coletta’s Rock ‘N’ Roll Piano Man"
Stackner Cabaret, Associate Bank Theater Center (11/06-1/03)