My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: THE MIRACLE WORKER at Pine Island Playhouse

The production runs through March 19, 2023.

By:
Review: THE MIRACLE WORKER at Pine Island Playhouse

The Pine Island Playhouse kicks off its tenth season with The Miracle Worker. After the hurricane devastation of Pine Island, producing a play is in itself a miracle. The organization has long flown under the radar but deserves more attention from the theater community.

The group is a perfect example of what community theater can be. The auditions are open to all; no experience needed. The casts are locals of all ages. They operate on a donation model-no set admission fee. Because they use the facilities of the Pine Island United Methodist Church, shows are family friendly.

I was curious to see who was cast as Helen Keller, and I wasn't disappointed. Keatly Holloway never breaks character and is a force to be reckoned with. Her nemesis and teacher Annie Sullivan is played by Mo Vida with indomitable will mixed with poignancy. Their fight scenes are so realistic that the director Tonya Player felt the need to assure the audience before the performance, "No child was injured in the making of this play."

Theater founder and president Nichole Pichon is sympathetic as Helen's mother Kate who desperately wants help for her child but struggles with the concept of tough love espoused by Sullivan. Nicely balancing her warmth is Cody Allen as Helen's grumpy father. At first bewildered and resistant to Sullivan's measures, he shows there is a loving man under the bluster.

This play by William Gibson was a good choice for post-Ian Pine Island. It demonstrates that progress is possible with enough belief and hard work.

The Miracle Worker runs Fridays and Saturdays at 7 pm and Sundays at 2pm through March 19 at 5701 Pine Island Road NW in Bokeelia, just west of the intersection of Pine Island Road and Stringfellow Road. Seating is limited, so get there early.

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Lead Performer in a Musical - Top 3
1. LJ Benet - The Lost Boys, A New Musical
16.8% of votes
2. Joshua Henry - Ragtime
16.4% of votes
3. Nicholas Christopher - Chess
8.9% of votes

Don't Miss a Ft. Myers/Naples News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Murder On The Orient Express in Ft. Myers/Naples Murder On The Orient Express
The Naples Players (1/13-2/14)
Hello, Dolly! in Ft. Myers/Naples Hello, Dolly!
The Naples Players (3/10-4/11)
Over the River & Through the Woods in Ft. Myers/Naples Over the River & Through the Woods
The Naples Players (10/07-10/25)
Comedian Lil Duval Live In Naples, Florida! in Ft. Myers/Naples Comedian Lil Duval Live In Naples, Florida!
Off The Hook Comedy Club (6/25-6/27)
The Glass Menagerie in Ft. Myers/Naples The Glass Menagerie
The Naples Players (2/03-3/07)
The Book of Will in Ft. Myers/Naples The Book of Will
The Naples Players (5/05-5/23)
Say Goodnight, Gracie in Ft. Myers/Naples Say Goodnight, Gracie
Players Circle Theater (6/25-7/05)
Les Miserables in Ft. Myers/Naples Les Miserables
The Naples Players (7/24-8/26)
Love Letters in Ft. Myers/Naples Love Letters
Players Circle Theater (6/12-6/14)
Rocket Man in Ft. Myers/Naples Rocket Man
The Naples Players (10/21-11/22)