Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: TAMMY FAYE, Almeida Theatre

Review: TAMMY FAYE, Almeida Theatre

A new musical premiere by Elton John, Jake Shears, and James Graham.

Review: TAMMY FAYE, Almeida Theatre There's been a sudden resurgence in Tammy Faye Bakker's popularity this past year. The American televangelist won Jessica Chastain an Academy Award for The Eyes of Tammy Faye and is now the subject of a brand new musical penned by Elton John, Scissor Sisters' own Jake Shears, and James Graham. On paper, it looks like quite the assorted trio with the global superstar curating the music, Graham the book, and Shears the lyrics.

Rupert Goold directs a sanitised tale of faith, love, and financial fraud with a cast led by Andrew Rannells and Katie Brayben as the Bakkers - the couple who changed the face of American Christianity by broadcasting "24 hours per day, seven days a week until the second coming" in the 70s and 80s. It's a camp production, clearly pre-packaged for the West End, that's too abridged in its retelling of the story to hit the mark.

A general, glitzy pop score that inevitably slips into a gospel revival and mildly exciting lyrics that mostly only do the job are followed by an outstanding book by Graham. He is just as unafraid of bringing politics to the pews as he is irreverent and profane in his humour. He underscores Tammy and Jim's story with a subtext that's rich in its commentary, but the satire in his text reaches deaf ears on the musical side of things. From the changes in presidential leadership received with acquiescence or condemnation to the echos of the conservative values that scarily resemble those uttered these days, Tammy Faye is surprisingly political.

Alongside the book, it's the performances that save the show from utter doom. Brayben brings the house down and reconfirms herself as a superstar in the musical theatre firmament. She grows progressively more heartbreaking while Jim confesses his affairs and the rape of a secretary before they lose everything. Her rise to fame and swift fall from grace is punctuated by duets with Rannells, but it's safe to say this is the Katie Brayben show, crowned by the rare five-star number "If You Came To See Me Cry".

Rannells offers a bumbling, quirky Reverend who anxiously struggles with the cameras at the start and compares himself to his self-assured wife with nerves of steel and gargantuan ambition. Those who saw his performance in The Book of Mormon all those years ago could say they've seen him in Tammy Faye, he doesn't provide anything too remarkable, but is a great foil to Brayben. The pair is surrounded by a collection of excellent portrayals, with Zubin Varla leading the charge as the sullen, slow-spoken, villainous Reverend Jerry Falwell.

Like any good antagonist, he has a cracking tune in "Satellite of God", where he bemoans the lack of a satellite to broadcast his own preachings worldwide (in real life, this didn't stop him from eventually founding a megachurch in Virginia). Clever casting allows the ensemble to go from Tammy's detractors to her chorus boys seamlessly in an amusing move by Goold. His vision is clear and specific as he directs a big showy show that's begging to be transferred but ultimately doesn't deserve it.

Lynne Page's choreography is cheesy, but maintains the over-the-top, ditzy tone of the project - which is in line with the essence of Tammy Faye. It's a shame that the piece mostly plays for laughs, trying not to take itself too seriously when it definitely should. This production presents the public perception of the Bakkers, PTL Network, and Heritage USA (the brainchild of Jim, a Christian residential complex with a theme park and other attractions) quite well, but there's very little introspection in the exploration of what made them so attractive to their audience.

The sensationalisation of faith and the monetisation of viewership are underplayed and the fascination with the power of universal televisual reach is under-exploited, as is the covert narcissism disguised as altruism and goodwill of most televangelists. They gloss over many aspects of Tammy Faye and Jim's lives, like her eventual severe addiction and the ramifications of his sexual misconduct. All in all, while the team behind the musical is outstanding, their offering, sadly, is merely mediocre as a whole.

Tammy Faye runs at the Almeida Theatre until 3 December.

Photo Credit: Marc Brenner

Related Stories
Video: Neil Diamond To Open up About Parkinsons & More on CBS Photo
Watch a preview of Neil Diamond's emotional interview with Anthony Mason for CBS SUNDAY MORNING.

Photos: Local Students to Attend SIX on Broadway Through TDF Program Photo
Check out photos of local students attending Six on Broadway through TDF's Introduction to Theatre Program!

Photos: Lin-Manuel Miranda Visits FAT HAM on Broadway Photo
See photos of Lin-Manuel Miranda visiting the cast of Fat Ham on Broadway!

Attend The Tony Awards Ceremony Through Charity Sweepstakes Photo
You now have the opportunity to win a behind-the-scenes Tony Awards experience. See details, and learn how to enter the sweepstakes!

From This Author - Cindy Marcolina

Italian export. Member of the Critics' Circle (Drama). Also a script reader and huge supporter of new work. Twitter: @Cindy_Marcolina

... (read more about this author)

Review: BERLUSCONI - A NEW MUSICAL, Southwark Playhouse ElephantReview: BERLUSCONI - A NEW MUSICAL, Southwark Playhouse Elephant
March 30, 2023

Silvio Berlusconi. Il Cavaliere, the knight. Entrepreneur, television mogul, right-wing leader. Famous for his scandals, fraudulent deals, chummy attitudes with despots and other questionable figures. Cruise ship singer. Laughing stock and controversial political powerhouse. Does he deserve a musical that glamorises his exploits and explains his side of history even though we’ve heard nothing but? He doesn’t, but you can leave it to the English to try and fail to spin a tale of power misuse and faded grandeur into a feminist elegy. The award-winning producing team behind Fleabag want to paint the Italian tycoon from the eyes of the women he abused. Written by Ricky Simmonds and Simon Vaughan from an original idea by Alan Hayling, it’s unnecessary and so lacking in politics that you come out of it having learnt very little about the protagonist except that he gets away with it.

Review: GONE TOO FAR!, Theatre Royal Stratford EastReview: GONE TOO FAR!, Theatre Royal Stratford East
March 29, 2023

Set on a housing estate in South London, the piece sees two brothers being sent out to the shops by their mother. Yemi was born and raised in England while Ikudayisi has just moved from Nigeria. The cultural clash is striking and, while the text has been slightly modernised with coups like the addition of face masks, 15 years are a long time and the racial discourse has somewhat become more sophisticated since then.

Review: MARJORIE PRIME, Menier Chocolate FactoryReview: MARJORIE PRIME, Menier Chocolate Factory
March 26, 2023

Jordan Harrison’s 2015 Pulitzer Prize finalist is a reflection on mortality that doesn’t dare to go into the depths of the matter. It ends up being rather stagnant philosophically and anthropologically, but Dominic Dromgoole’s latest production is a delicate take. Running at 85 minutes on paper but around 70 in reality, the piece’s greatly sophisticated performances and sleek look save it from its redundant nature.

Review: WASTED, Lyric HammersmithReview: WASTED, Lyric Hammersmith
March 25, 2023

Running at around 50 minutes, it’s snappy and positively Gen-Z in pace and subject. Fernandes crafts a script that wanders from deliciously colloquial to slightly expository, but remains solid throughout.

Review: CONTEMPT, VAULT FestivalReview: CONTEMPT, VAULT Festival
March 19, 2023

While the writing is gripping and Gabrielle Nellis-Pain’s performance is excellent, there’s something missing. Catherine’s colleagues are ancient ghosts through the hallowed corridors as she puts on a sleazy, raspy voice to portray them against her well-spoken main character.