Review: SENSE & SENSIBILITY at Hutt Repertory Theatre

Sense and Sensibility is Jane Austen's classic novel, first published anonymously in 1811. Set within the social constraints of Regency England, it follows the fortunes and romantic entanglements of sisters Elinor and Marianne Dashwood. Through their contrasting temperaments, Austen explores the tension between reason and emotion, while offering a sharp commentary on class, reputation, and the pursuit of happiness.

This stage adaptation by New Zealand's Penny Ashton successfully condenses the much-loved novel while retaining its wit, charm, and keen observations of human nature. The production is particularly notable for its ambitious casting, with ten women portraying 24 characters between them. It is a challenging undertaking that requires performers to switch rapidly between roles while maintaining clarity for the audience.

The result is a production that walks a fine line between comedy and drama. While the humorous elements are often at the forefront, the emotional moments are given sufficient space to resonate, ensuring that the story's heart remains intact.

Amy Bradshaw, who portrays a number of the male characters throughout the evening, gives a strong and convincing performance. Her portrayals are largely understated, allowing each character to emerge as distinct individuals rather than caricatures. Scarlett Rumble and Katie Jane, as Marianne and Elinor Dashwood respectively, are both very well cast. Rumble captures Marianne's passion and impulsiveness, while Jane brings warmth, intelligence, and quiet strength to Elinor. Together they provide the emotional backbone of the production.

Christine Bartlett clearly relishes her role as Mrs Jennings, embracing the character's larger-than-life personality and delightfully intrusive nature. Her comic timing is excellent, and many of the evening's biggest laughs stem from her enthusiastic gossiping and sharply delivered observations. Erin Howell is also impressive across multiple roles, changing mannerisms and characterisations with apparent ease. Maddy Reid and Victoria Nelson both contribute strong performances, and the remainder of the cast work hard to create a cohesive ensemble.

Austen's dialogue remains as witty as ever, and much of the humour lands successfully. However, the production faces the challenge of accommodating a large number of locations and scenes. While the transitions are handled efficiently, the frequency of scene changes occasionally interrupts the narrative flow and can make it difficult for momentum to build.

The set design is clever and functional. The use of rolling trucks that can be separated and reconfigured quickly provides a versatile representation of the various homes and locations. For the most part, these elements worked well and supported the storytelling, although there were one or two occasions on opening night when the units appeared reluctant to cooperate.

Direction is another strength of the production. The movement feels natural and unforced, allowing the actors to inhabit the space comfortably while maintaining the pace of the story. The staging is clear, and relationships between characters are generally well defined.

Costuming is, on the whole, effective and appropriate to the period. One noticeable distraction was what appeared to be a tear in John Dashwood's jacket, which was visible from the audience. Presumably this was an unfortunate opening-night mishap and can be easily addressed for future performances.

The lighting design complements the action well and helps establish the various moods and locations without drawing undue attention to itself.

As with many opening nights, there were a handful of minor mishaps throughout the performance. To the cast's credit, none significantly detracted from the audience's enjoyment, and most were handled professionally.

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Need more New Zealand Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...

Get New Zealand Emails & Offers

Get the latest news, discounts & more