I have been a member of AE for many years, and although I know they had some bad press a while ago, I have always found the selection pretty good. Their service is also pretty good. I've never had a problem in all these years. They have never messed up an order at the Box Office. Is Play by Play better?
I've been a PlayByPlay member since it started and find it to be the best $100 I spend each year - the $100 gets you 2 tickets to any event they offer for only $4 service fee per ticket- occasionally they will allow you to purchase more than 2 - I do wish they offered more Broadway shows but you can't go wrong with it
They offer pretty much the same set of shows. Main difference is in Gold, show disappears from the list once it sells out. So unless you were logged in at the right time, you would never know that they ever offered it.