It recouped but only ran for 2 years? It also didn't get much Tony Award love. Also, did they use all the original choreography? I ask because I just started watching Every little step.
If it recouped then yes, it was a hit. The hit or flop label is based solely on money, if it closes without recouping it is a flop, otherwise it's a hit. You will find some people who may push against qualifying shows that way, but money is really the only objective way to make that distinction. Everything else is open to interpretation and debate and could ultimately never have a 100% consensus reached.
This production of A Chorus Line paid off quickly, within a few months of the NY opening.
It was wisely booked into a tryout run in San Francisco in a much larger theatre than the Schoenfeld where it sold out for six weeks generating a large amount of pure profit. Probably half of the capitalization was paid back or about to be by the NY premiere.
"If my life weren't funny, it would just be true. And that would be unacceptable."
--Carrie Fisher
"Okay money aside, would you say it resonated how it should have with audiences?"
I never "got" what was so great about Jason Tam. In the documentary, everyone is weeping at his audition like he's just turned in the greatest Oedipus performance ever. I didn't think he was that great with Paul's monologue.
If anyone ever tells you that you put too much Parmesan cheese on your pasta, stop talking to them. You don't need that kind of negativity in your life.
As someone who saw the original cast in '75, and 2 or 3 succeeding Broadway casts over the years, I loved the '06 revival and found it the closest to the youth and excitement of the OBC. I was so delighted that my husband could watch the '06 company and get some inkling of what was so electric about the production in '75. For my eyes it seemed like the choreography was a carbon copy of the original, but I'm not a dancer so could easily have missed any subtle changes. It was a great disappointment to hear it closed as soon as it did.