Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: BROKEN LAD, Arcola Theatre

Robin Hooper's new play examines toxic masculinity and its causes but fails to convince with its sketchy characters

Review: BROKEN LAD, Arcola Theatre Review: BROKEN LAD, Arcola Theatre Phil has been on the slide for a while. His stand-up act has gone out of fashion, his womanising is catching up with him and the medics don't like what they see on the scans. There's one chance of a return - a gig in a grotty pub with a big time agent in the crowd, friends and family to support and a lucky teddy bear for company. Upstairs, in an even grottier makeshift dressing room, things start to unravel.

Robin Hooper's new play goes into territory previously covered by Martin Scorsese's, The King of Comedy, but we never approach that movie's satirical bite nor its darkest humour. That's primarily because the characters, presented with the sketchiest of backstories, lack credibility - without real people to care about, we can't rouse ourselves sufficiently to care.

Patrick Brennan is entitled, opinionated and obnoxious as Phil, but there's no charm bubbling below the surface to convince us of his glory days, no sharpness in his observations and, most disappointingly of all, no laughs from the few jokes we hear from him, which are Christmas cracker stuff. Ria, his son's on-off girlfriend (and the least likely City banker I've seen) with whom he has had an affair, claims that all the girls in her school fancied him, but he's hardly Rob Newman or Tony Slattery in looks nor vulnerability. We hear that Phil was a hit on the Saturday night shows, but they are not identified, nor are any real comedians name-checked, so we can't place him with Ben Elton or Paul Merton or Jimmy Carr.

It's hard to know exactly what purpose Ned (Adrian McLoughlin) serves as his gay friend and superfan and Carolyn Backhouse does what she can with a stereotypical successful and (hence) divorced wife, but one can pretty much predict what she says before we hear it.

The dramatic thrust behind the play concerns the relationship between Phil and his son, Josh, who hero-worships his flawed father and wants to follow in his footsteps, supplanting him as lover and comedian. Dave Perry acts well, but he's described in the programme as early twenties when he looks at least ten years older than that (older than Ria too) and that does change the dynamic. Josh also bounces between hating (and even wanting to kill) his father and behaving as if things were back to normal, without much being said or done to heal the rifts that open and close so quickly.

It is important to show a huge demographic of the British public (fifty-something white men, but not those running things) on the stage and we get a glimpse of their ugly self-pity and the loneliness that provokes it, but the play needs more detail, more subtlety and, most of all, more credibility in its characters if it is to deliver on its considerable promise.

Broken Lad is at the Arcola Theatre until 6 November

Photo David Monteith

Vote Now for the 2022 BroadwayWorld UK / West End Awards
voting ends in

BACK TO THE FUTURE the Musical Will Play its First Relaxed Performance in March Photo
BACK TO THE FUTURE The Musical will play its first ever relaxed performance at the Adelphi Theatre on Sunday 12 March 2023.

Little Angel Theatre Announces Spring/Summer Season 2023 Photo
Little Angel Theatre has announced its upcoming Spring / Summer season. Learn more about the full lineup of performances here!

Cheryl and More Cast in 2:22 - A GHOST STORY Transfer at the Lyric Theatre Photo
Casting has been announced for the fourth West End  transfer of Danny Robins’ edge-of-your-seat, supernatural thriller 2:22 - A Ghost Story.

Roxana Silbert to Step Down as Artistic Director of Hampstead Theatre Photo
Hampstead Theatre has announced that, in the light of the 100% cut in its Arts Council grant of £766,455, the theatre will need to change direction and can no longer continue solely as a new writing theatre.  As a consequence, very sadly, Roxana Silbert has decided to step down as Artistic Director. 

From This Author - Gary Naylor

Gary Naylor is chief London reviewer for BroadwayWorld ( and feels privileged to... (read more about this author)

Review: MAKE MINE A DOUBLE - TUNNELS and PRESS, Park TheatreReview: MAKE MINE A DOUBLE - TUNNELS and PRESS, Park Theatre
December 1, 2022

A dystopian past and dystopian future form the backdrop to two plays that never quite escape their specificities and, consequently, remain a little distant

Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE, London ColiseumReview: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE, London Coliseum
November 27, 2022

Opera based on much loved 1946 film offers a vision of a town without music, without joy, without love and, in doing so, compels us to value what we have - a moral shared by everyone in the house, but not outside it.

November 25, 2022

Super fun for 7 year-olds to 77 year-olds with all that stage magic up there on the screen

Review: A SHERLOCK CAROL, Marylebone TheatreReview: A SHERLOCK CAROL, Marylebone Theatre
November 24, 2022

Super fun for Christmas with two of the world's most loved Victorian characters together at last

Review: DINNER WITH GROUCHO, Arcola TheatreReview: DINNER WITH GROUCHO, Arcola Theatre
November 22, 2022

Frank McGuinness's new play puts two giants of 20th century culture together but fails to ignite a spark between them