Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Nevermore Off-Broadway Original Cast

  1. Off-Broadway Shows
  2.   › 
  3. Nevermore

Beautiful and bizarre, playful and perverse, NEVERMORE- The Imaginary Life and Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan Poe is a whimsical and chilling musical play about the enigmatic writer who has fascinated the world for more than a century. A literary rock star in his day, Poe struggled with tragedy and addiction, poverty and loss, yet produced some of the world's most original, visionary and enduring literature before dying in mysterious circumstances at the age of 40. Full synopsis

Original

Original Cast

Henry Poe

Gaelan Beatty made his Off-Broadway debut in "Nevermore" as Henry Poe and Ensemble, bringing with him a diverse background in theater with roles such as Bobby in "Crazy For You" and Claudio in "Much Ado About Nothing," as well as TV appearances on shows like "The 100" and "Arrow." more...
Elmira Royster

**Shannon Blanchet** (Elmira Royster, Ensemble) - Shannon, a graduate of the Professional Actor Training program at The University of Alberta, brought her talent to the role of Elmira Royster in *Nevermore*, a production that has since become a cherished part of her diverse acting portfolio. **Beth Graham** (Rosalie Poe, Fanny Allan, Sissy Clemm, Ensemble) - Beth, known for her work with Catalyst Theatre, portrayed multiple characters in *Nevermore*, a show she had previously performed in alongside her other notable works like *Hunchback* and *The Blue Orphan*. **Ryan Parker** (Rufus Griswold, Ensemble) - Ryan, who has been with *Nevermore* since its first incarnation in 2008, celebrated the show's Off-Broadway premiere, marking a significant milestone in his career as both an actor and photographer. **Garett Ross** (David Poe, Jock Allan, Ensemble) - Garett, a dedicated member of the *Nevermore* cast since its inception, expressed his excitement about the show's Off-Broadway debut, reflecting his long-standing commitment to the production. **Scott Shpeley** (Edgar Allan Poe) - Scott, a multi-instrumentalist and original cast member of *Nevermore* since 2008, played the titular role of Edgar Allan Poe, showcasing his versatile talents in this hauntingly memorable production. **Lindsie VanWinkle** (Eliza Poe, Louise Gabriella, Muddy Clemm, Ensemble) - Lindsie, with an impressive array of regional and Off-Broadway credits, added depth to her roles in *Nevermore*, a show that highlighted her dynamic range as a performer. **Jennifer Byrne** (Understudy All Female Parts) - Jennifer, thrilled to join the cast of *Nevermore*, brought her extensive musical theatre experience to the production, ensuring a captivating performance in every role she understudied. **Stephen Cerf** (Understudy David Poe, Jock Allan; Understudy Henry Poe) - Making his Off-Broadway debut with *Nevermore*, Stephen's diverse performance background, including notable shows like *Jersey Boys* and *Spamalot*, enriched his contributions to the production. **Rob Morrison** (Understudy Edgar Allan Poe; Understudy Rufus Griswold; Understudy Henry Poe) - Rob, with a rich history of stage and screen performances, lent his versatile skills to *Nevermore*, underscoring the production with his extensive experience in both acting and music composition. more...
Performer (u/s)
(Understudy)
Jennifer Byrne, who served as the understudy for all female parts in Nevermore, has an impressive background including roles in Evil Dead The Musical and It’s Karate, Kid the Musical!, showcasing her versatility and dedication to the stage. more...
David Poe, Jock Allan, Henry Poe (u/s)
(Understudy)
Stephen Cerf, who made his Off-Broadway debut in "Nevermore" as the understudy for David Poe, Jock Allan, and Henry Poe, has an impressive performance background with roles in "Jersey Boys," "Spamalot," and "Les Mis." more...
Fanny Allan
Rosalie Poe
Sissy Clemm

Beth Graham, who played multiple roles including Rosalie Poe, Fanny Allan, and Sissy Clemm in Nevermore, has also showcased her talent in Catalyst Theatre's productions of Hunchback and The Blue Orphan. more...
Edgar Allan Poe, Rufus Griswold, Henry Poe (u/s)
(Understudy)
Rob Morrison, who performed in the past Off-Broadway production of Nevermore, is also known for his roles in Avenue Q, Frankenstein, and his work as a voice actor on several children's television series. more...
Rufus Griswold

Ryan Parker, who played Rufus Griswold in the ensemble, has been a dedicated member of Nevermore since its inception in 2008 and was thrilled to participate in its Off-Broadway premiere. more...
David Poe
Jock Allan

Garett Ross, a graduate of the University of Alberta and MacEwan University, brought his talents to the roles of David Poe, Jock Allan, and the Ensemble in Nevermore, having been with the production since its inception and eagerly participating in its Off-Broadway premiere. more...
Edgar Allan Poe

Scott Shpeley, a multi-instrumentalist and graduate of the University of Alberta's professional actor training program, has portrayed Edgar Allan Poe in Nevermore since its inception in 2008. more...
Eliza Poe
Louise Gabriella
Muddy Clemm

Lindsie VanWinkle, who portrayed multiple roles including Eliza Poe and Louise Gabriella in Nevermore, has an impressive Off-Broadway and regional theater resume, featuring standout performances such as Mary Magdalene in The Magdalene and Eva Peron in EVITA. more...

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71