My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: AMÉLIE at New Athenaeum Theatre

It's giving quirky, jolie, magnifique

By:
Review: AMÉLIE at New Athenaeum Theatre
Review: AMÉLIE at New Athenaeum Theatre ImageThe Royal Conservatoire of Scotland embraces playfulness in this quirky production of Amélie based on the 2001 French film by Jean-Pierre Jeunet. The piece follows shy, imaginative Parisian woman Amélie (Aida Valentine), who secretly orchestrates acts of kindness to improve the lives of others... while slowly building the courage to pursue her own love story with the eccentric Nino (William Collier).

The production is delightful and distinctive, with eighteen students performing as actor-musician-dancers, clearly showcasing their talents by playing instruments live onstage. Tom Cooper’s vision highlights Amélie and Nino’s atypical differences, bringing beauty to the tender ways they connect. Collier and Valentine's chemistry was beautiful, heart-warming and wholly believable.

Letago Makola is magnetic as the restaurant owner Suzanne, bringing warmth and presence to every moment. Nathaniel Attard and Cerys Devine are hilariously prude as Amélie’s parents. The set left a lot to be desired. It felt a little basic for such a richly whimsical world... functional, but lacking the visual spark the story needs. Nevertheless this was redeemed by the gorgeous use of puppetry, bringing a playful other-worldliness to the piece. There were many to admire, but my favourite is a puppet of young Amélie interacting with her parents, while the present-day Amélie looks on. 

There are musical highlights, particularly ‘Goodbye Amélie’, with Gilli Jones delivering an amusing Elton John-inspired turn. However many songs feel like fillers, causing the piece to drag at points. This is especially noticeable in the middle, where momentum dips and the charm has to work harder to sustain engagement.

Overall, it is an ambitious and welcome production, showcasing the immense talent of Royal Conservatoire students. I left charmed by its warmth and creativity, even if it doesn’t always sustain its magic throughout.

Amélie was at the New Athenaeum Theatre until the 20th of March.

Photo: Hope Holmes

More on New Athenaeum Theatre

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best New Musical - Top 3
1. The Lost Boys
36.4% of votes
2. Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
24.3% of votes
3. Schmigadoon!
22.9% of votes

Need more Scotland Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Big Stuff in Scotland Big Stuff
Assembly (Roxy Boxy) (5/05-5/30)
Tale of the Firebird in Scotland Tale of the Firebird
Assembly Roxy (Central) (8/06-8/30)
Glass Child in Scotland Glass Child
Summerhall (Old Lab) (8/06-8/16)
Couplet: Folk Marry Kill in Scotland Couplet: Folk Marry Kill
Assembly George Square Studios - Studio 5 (8/05-8/30)
Mythos: Ragnarök in Scotland Mythos: Ragnarök
Assembly Rooms (Music Hall) (8/06-8/29)
Count Arthur Strong - And It’s Goodnight From Me! in Scotland Count Arthur Strong - And It’s Goodnight From Me!
EICC (5/30-5/30)
Sapphire McIntosh: Squeaky Bum Time in Scotland Sapphire McIntosh: Squeaky Bum Time
Unerbelly Bristo Square - Daisy Room (8/05-8/30)
Sitting (In Silence) in Scotland Sitting (In Silence)
Summerhall (Anatomy Lecture Theatre) (8/06-8/31)
Mark Thomas: 40 In Stand Up Years in Scotland Mark Thomas: 40 In Stand Up Years
The Stand 1 (8/05-8/30)
How Not to Make it in America in Scotland How Not to Make it in America
Summerhall (Former Gent’s Locker Room) (8/06-8/31)