Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: A GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER at Solvang Festival Theatre

Review: A GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO LOVE AND MURDER at Solvang Festival Theatre
Emily Trask as Sibella Halward
George Walker as Monty Navarro
Skye Privat as Phoebe D'Ysquith

A friend remarked to British actor, Edmund Gwenn, on his deathbed "This must be very hard," to which Gwenn replied, "It is. But not as hard as farce." PCPA's production of A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder met the challenge of the dangerously delicate timing demanded of a musical farce. Set in England in the Edwardian period, lowly office clerk, Monty Navarro (George Walker), discovers that, through his mother's line, he is connected to the aristocracy as a member of the D'Ysquith family. With eight D'Ysquiths standing between him and an Earldom, he makes his way through his family tree by what Lady Macbeth referred to as "the nearest way," discreetly murdering his way to the top.

The musical delivers its material in a heightened and mannered style, which has the effect of making all the D'Ysquith deaths thoroughly comic. The songs are reminiscent of the quick and witty patter of Gilbert and Sullivan and have the catchy appeal of the saucy songs of the British music hall. For example, in "Why Are All the D'Ysquiths Dying," the chorus ponders the curious deaths of the D'Ysquiths:

Why are all the D'Ysquiths dying?

When truth to tell so many others should.


Privately it was said

They should all drop dead,

No one thought

They ever really would.

All the dying D'Ysquiths are portrayed by PCPA resident artist, Andrew Philpot, who handles the roles with breathtaking virtuosity, precise comic timing and inventiveness. As the foppish young Henry D'Ysquith, for example, Philpot concentrates the offensive superciliousness of the D'Ysquith's by reclining his head as he casually writes Monty off with a tip of his straw boater hat. Henry's sneering manner is all the audience needs to root for Monty's murders. As played by George Walker, Monty has an appealing charm that wins our sympathy.

While the "murder" side of A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder is greatly entertaining, the love plots, are more peripheral. In the source material, Monty's married lover, Sibella (Emily Trask), directly reverses the plot. Here, the more removed love story makes way for the essential pairing of Monty and each murder victim. Keeping focus on imaginative visual story-telling and comic timing. For example, when Monty visits his distant cousin, the elderly, inebriated Reverend Lord Ezekial D'Ysquith, in his church, George Walker and Andrew Philpot transform the stairway up to the third and fourth level of the set into a perilously narrow and slippery church tower by treating it as such physically and emotionally. The comic tension escalates as the drunken clergyman ascends to the top of the roof while Monty meditates on his moral quandries over murder. The result is fully farcically fun. The scenes that follow match the comedy of this early one, making for a hilarious evening's entertainment.

Review: EMMA at Marian Theater Photo
What did our critic think of EMMA at Marian Theater? A confectionary morsel of Regency romance!

The Wayward Artist Presents the West Coast Premiere of IN THE GREEN Next Month Photo
The Wayward Artist has announced the West Coast Premiere of In The Green by Grace McClean. Performances start April 14, 2023 and will continue through April 30th at the Grand Central Art Center in Santa Ana.   

Santa Barbara Symphony Presents John Williams Tribute Concert in March Photo
Get swept away by the magic of movie music! The Santa Barbara Symphony presents John Williams: A Cinematic Celebration on Saturday, March 18 at 7:30 p.m., and Sunday, March 19 at 3:00 p.m. Guest conductor Rei Hotoda takes the podium to lead the Symphony in a tribute concert where powerful cinematic moments will come to life through live orchestral accompaniment.

UCSB Department of Theater/Dance Presents NIGHT NIGHT, ROGER ROGER Next Month Photo
What happens when the clock strikes midnight? What worlds and creatures emerge under the comfort of night? What do vampires, onions, peaches, and roller skating grandma’s have in common? The answer to all of these, increasingly ridiculous questions, can be found at the UCSB Studio Theater during our next production, Night Night, Roger Roger by UCSB undergraduate student Roni Ragone, directed by Julie Fishell. 

From This Author - Anna Jensen

Review: EMMA at Marian TheaterReview: EMMA at Marian Theater
March 11, 2023

What did our critic think of EMMA at Marian Theater? A confectionary morsel of Regency romance!

Previews: THE DROWSY CHAPERONE at Marjorie LukePreviews: THE DROWSY CHAPERONE at Marjorie Luke
January 25, 2023

The chaperone has hit the bottle pretty hard and is 'napping.' The young lady she's meant to watch over has cold (or are they itchy?) feet about her impending nuptials. What could go wrong? Everything--in the most musical and zany way possible, of course. The screwball Broadway hit, The Drowsy Chaperone opens at the Marjorie Luke's stage this weekend.

Feature: THE REALISTIC JONESES at Rubicon Theatre CompanyFeature: THE REALISTIC JONESES at Rubicon Theatre Company
January 23, 2023

In an unnamed mountain town, two neighboring couples share the last name, 'Jones.' As they become better acquainted with one another, they discover further commonalities, both comic and poignant.

Review: CINDERELLA at PCPA's Marian TheaterReview: CINDERELLA at PCPA's Marian Theater
November 17, 2022

What did our critic think of CINDERELLA at PCPA's Marian Theater?

Feature: MISS YOU LIKE HELL at Out Of The Box Theatre At Center StageFeature: MISS YOU LIKE HELL at Out Of The Box Theatre At Center Stage
October 25, 2022

Miss You Like Hell plays November 4-13, 2022 (Friday - Sunday) at Center Stage Theater in Santa Barbara, CA.