Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Downstate Broadway Reviews

About the Show

Winner of the New York Drama Critics’ Circle Award for Best Play, Bruce Norris’s profane, disruptive, and heartbreaking Downstate finally arrives on Broadway in a strictly limited 12-week engagement, directed... (more info)

Theatre Booth Theatre
Previews Oct 19, 2026
Opened Nov 15, 2026
Critics' Rating
8.62 Positive
12 Positive
1 Mixed
0 Negative
Readers' Rating
No ratings yet
Rate This Show
Select a score 1–10
Write a Review

Critics' Reviews

8
Thumbs Up

‘Downstate’ Review: How Much Should Sex Offenders Be Punished?

From: New York Times  |  By: Helen Shaw  |  Date: 11/15/2026

Freeman, giving the performance of a lifetime as Dee, dominates “Downstate.” Whatever Dee has done (and believes about underage consent), he is the play’s conscience, and, in a way, its accountant and litigator. He knows when to tell Felix to a...

8
Thumbs Up

Downstate Broadway Review

From: New York Theatre  |  By: Jonathan Mandell  |  Date: 11/15/2026

Detractors of “Downstate” understandably focus on the tendentious way the playwright tackles the issue of justice and empathy for sex offenders and their victims. What is harder to take issue with is his skills as a dramatist – his ability to ...

10
Thumbs Up

Broadway review: Downstate brings monsters to life

From: TimeOut New York  |  By: Adam Feldman  |  Date: 11/15/2026

In this context, it is difficult to talk about what Downstate is doing without risking adding fuel to the pyre. (Senator Ted Cruz cited a positive review of the play in the Washington Post as proof that “the corporate media is praising pedophilia.�...

7
Thumbs Sideways

Review: Downstate at the Booth Theatre

From: ExeuntNYC  |  By: Lane Williamson  |  Date: 11/15/2026

All in all, Downstate remains a play worth seeing (there isn’t another one like it) and Mantello’s production is finely calibrated. If you saw it off-Broadway, you might, like I did, feel the power’s turned down a little, but if you didn’t, i...

Playwright Norris (he wrote the excellent Clybourne Park) builds the tension and momentum of Downstate almost entirely through character interaction – it’s only in retrospect that we realize there hasn’t been much by way of plot, or at least ac...

Obviously, this is a rave review. But there are caveats. “Downstate” was better, even more disturbing under the direction of Pam Mackinnon in its 2022 Off Broadway incarnation. Joe Mantello now directs, and fortunately he has kept Freeman and Gui...

8
Thumbs Up

Review: Downstate Is the Most Dangerous Play on Broadway

From: TheaterMania  |  By: Zachary Stewart  |  Date: 11/15/2026

The cast is mostly new, with Guinan and Freeman reprising their off-Broadway performances. Guinan bracingly, and often hilariously, depicts a man whose habitual cheer is a defense mechanism to ward off the darkness (we also feel why Andy finds it so ...

8
Thumbs Up

Controversial ‘Downstate’ is the best new play on Broadway

From: New York Post  |  By: Johnny Oleksinski  |  Date: 11/15/2026

All of the acting, especially from Freeman and Sadoski, is as muscular and vigorous as Norris’ brilliant writing. And Joe Mantello, fresh off “Death of a Salesman,” directs each scene as a cage match with not a single wasted second. It’s a ve...

10
Thumbs Up

Downstate: The Disturbing Humanity of the Inhuman

From: NY Stage Review  |  By: Roma Torre  |  Date: 11/15/2026

Downstate is not an easy play to watch. But it is a stunning achievement, meticulously constructed and emotionally devastating. Norris isn’t out to change minds. Instead he casts an unflinching light on one of society’s darkest scourges, challeng...

10
Thumbs Up

Downstate: Real Life Realism

From: NY Stage Review  |  By: Michael Sommers  |  Date: 11/15/2026

The dialogue usually is quick, terse, frank, at times dryly humorous, especially when uttered with point and precision by the superb acting ensemble directed with typical sensitivity by Joe Mantello. The artists dig deeply into their characters, and ...

10
Thumbs Up

Downstate

From: Cititour  |  By: Brian Scott Lipton  |  Date: 11/15/2026

Despite its troubling subject matter, I beg you not to avoid this remarkable work and production, which is currently the finest (and finest acted) show on Broadway!

8
Thumbs Up

'Downstate' Broadway review — where does horridness end and humanity begin?

From: New York Theatre Guide  |  By: Gillian Russo  |  Date: 11/15/2026

It's not for the faint of heart and is likely to be emotionally disturbing no matter your experience with Norris's subject matter. And yet, although it's a show I don't particularly want to see again, Downstate is the kind of show at which repeat vie...

Downstate is a blistering examination of what being treated as scum does to a person’s psyche. As the play reaches its crescendo, the man from the opening scene (Thomas Sadoski) returns in the hope of closure for his “assault by a serial predator...

Audience Reviews

No audience reviews yet.

Add Your Review

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67