Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

BWW Reviews: Superb Direction, Strong Ensemble Make TWELFTH NIGHT a Must-See, at Post5

Sometimes we make fools of ourselves, and sometimes we make fools of one another, but love makes fools of us all. And there's plenty of foolishness to go around in Post5 Theatre's production of Shakespeare's TWELFTH NIGHT. This production, exquisitely directed by Cassandra Boice, is fresh and funny, and full of compassion for the follies and foibles that make us all human, especially when we're in love.

TWELFTH NIGHT has a complex plot befitting the best of Shakespearean comedies. The play begins with a shipwreck in which identical twins Viola and Sebastian are separated. Viola finds herself in Illyria, which in this production is an island that seems to sit outside of time, and for safety she disguises herself as a boy and takes the name Cesario. Cesario soon becomes the favorite of Duke Orsino and is charged with helping him get Countess Olivia to fall in love with him, which Olivia has plainly announced she will have none of. Along the way, Viola falls in love with Orsino and Olivia falls in love with Viola-as-Cesario, creating a somewhat strange love triangle. There are also subplots, mostly involving Olivia's other suitors and her cousin (and first-class drunk) Sir Toby Belch. When Sebastian shows up alive, things get briefly more complicated before they all work out for (almost) everyone.

TWELFTH NIGHT has the potential to be little more than a wildly entertaining play, one from which you leave the theatre satisfied with having had a good laugh, but not necessarily moved. That is not true of this production. You will still split your sides laughing, but Boice's directorial choices, especially her casting of a man (Chip Sherman) in the role of Olivia and her treatment of Olivia's ill-fated steward and would-be suitor Malvolio, bring this production to a new level - one that will cause you to perhaps think differently about the nature of love and about people, and especially about people who deserve our compassion. In her "Letter from the Director," Boice wrote that her challenge was "to make this play - not fresh, not modern - but relevant." And by all counts, she has succeeded.

It is difficult to pick out the best performances from such a strong ensemble. Chip Sherman is fantastic as Olivia - in addition to bringing a new depth to the character, he is just plain funny. I can't find the right words to describe how perfect Ty Boice is as Malvolio. Let's just say that the scene in which he attempts to smile is worth the price of the ticket plus an extra $20 in the collection basket. I also loved Jeff Gorham as the hard-done-by, and constantly soused, Sir Toby.

It doesn't matter if you've never seen TWELFTH NIGHT before or it you've seen it 100 times, this production will surprise and delight you. Definitely a must-see.

TWELFTH NIGHT runs through May 16 at Post5 Theatre. For tickets, visit

Photo Credit: Russell J. Young

Related Stories

From This Author - Krista Garver

Review: HADESTOWN at Keller Auditorium
July 21, 2022

What did our critic think of HADESTOWN at Keller Auditorium?HADESTOWN, Anaïs Mitchell’s terrific Tony- and Grammy-winning musical now on national tour, urges us to have hope that if we can imagine a better world, we can create one…even if the odds (and the gods) are against us. 

Review: THE CHERRY ORCHARD at Portland Experimental Theatre Ensemble
July 1, 2022

Funny, poignant, weird – Portland Experimental Theatre Ensemble’s new take on THE CHERRY ORCHARD, translated by Štĕpán Šimek, is a vehicle to showcase what both Chekhov and PETE do best.

Review: KISSING THE WITCH at Corrib Theatre
June 21, 2022

Corrib’s production, directed by Tracy Cameron Francis, uses movement and visual effects to bring the magical, mystical nature of fairy tales to the forefront, while also reinforcing that these are real people dealing with real issues.

Review: RENT at Portland Center Stage
June 16, 2022

Director Chip Miller delivers a vibrant and touching production of musical theatre's most iconic shows.

BWW Review: BELLA: AN AMERICAN TALL TALE at Portland Playhouse
May 20, 2022

Kirsten Childs’ 2016 musical, now running at Portland Playhouse, offers a new take on American folklore, featuring a new tall tale hero: Bella Patterson, “a woman of mythic proportions and heroic appeal.”