Review: Arizona Broadway Theatre Presents WEST SIDE STORY

As many times as I've seen WEST SIDE STORY, so many are the angles from which I've discovered some aspect that I'd not seen or appreciated before.

Yes, what remains consistent is the historic aggregation of genius that defines this classic's soul and contours: Arthur Laurents' book, Jerome Robbins' choreography, Leonard Bernstein's music, and Stephen Sondheim's lyrics.

And yes, the distinctiveness of one performance from another obviously lies in the execution.

And yes, Arizona Broadway Theatre honors and stays true to the magnum opus in its current well-executed staging of WEST SIDE STORY, directed by Kiel Klaphake. But, this time around, something new and special came to my attention. It is that, while the centerpiece of the drama is the rivalry of the Jets and the Sharks and the ill-fated romance of Maria (Brittany Santos) and Tony (Jesse Michels), another story, Anita's story, looms large, equally compelling and brought to the fore by the electric performance of Melissa Rapelje.

Ms. Rapelje dominates the stage as a complex mix of bravado and vulnerability. As the sweetheart of Maria's brother, Bernardo (Pasqualino Beltempo). As Maria's wise and protective counsel. As the prideful new American. As a vengeful messenger. In each instance and throughout the production, Anita is the indispensable thread that ties the plot together and frames the tragic ending ~ and Rapelje's performance on all counts is electrifying and compelling.

Beyond the mellifluous voices of Santos and Michels, Sarah Powell's rendition of Somewhere stands out as a singular spellbinding moment of vocal beauty and authenticity.

The territorial and ethnic rivalry between the two gangs ~ the template for a majestic critique of youthful rebellion, the challenges of assimilation, and an America in transition ~ is enlivened by the robust fusion of James May's powerful musical direction; Kurtis Overby's fidelity to the choreography ~ executed with precision, muscularity, and grace by the ensemble; and Jim Hunter's sophisticated lighting and set design.

Arizona Broadway Theatre's WEST SIDE STORY is a marvellous tribute to its creators. The show continues its run through November 15th.

Photo credit to Arizona Broadway Theatre

2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats

Best Orchestrations - Top 3

1. Ethan Popp, The Rescues - The Lost Boys

24.5% of votes

2. Anders Eljas, Brian Usifer - Chess

12.9% of votes

3. William David Brohn - Ragtime

12.7% of votes

Vote Now! View Live Stats