Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Photo Flash: CHARLIE AND ALGERNON at Feinstein's/54 Below

Last evening, the 1980 musical based on the beloved novel Flowers For Algernon came to life again for one night only at Feinstein's/54 Below.

As previously announced, the show's original star, P.J. Benjamin (Wicked, Chicago, Sophisticated Ladies and more), reprised several of the songs he originated on Broadway 46 years ago this September. He was joined by his wife Louisa Flaningam (Guys and Dolls, The Most Happy Fella, The Magic Show). The night was also their anniversary, making for quite a special celebration!

CHARLIE AND ALGERNON features a score by Charles Strouse, the Tony Award-winning composer of Annie, Applause, Rags and Bye, Bye, Birdie with a book and lyrics by David Rogers. The short-lived musical opened on Broadway at The Helen Hayes Theatre on September 14th, 1980 and closed on September 28th, only 17 performances later. It traces the mental and emotional development of Charlie Gordon, a disabled young man who becomes the first human test-subject for an ambitious experiment. Through his friendship with a white mouse named Algernon, we watch Charlie tackle the highs and lows of life.

The evening was produced and directed by Steven Carl McCasland, with Musical Direction by James Horan, the team that brought back Onward Victoria earlier this summer. The two will return to Feinstein's/54 Below in January with a concert of Eating Raoul, starring The Skivvies, Lesli Margherita and Matt Saldivar.

Over the course of the performance, four different actors played the title role, charting his progression and regression. In addition to P.J. Benjamin, Adam Kantor, Lucas Schultz and 2-time MAC Award-nominee Stearns Matthews will take turns as Charlie. Additional cast members include Jeanine Robinson as Lita, Vanessa Spica as Alice Kinnian, Kristen Gehling as Mrs. Donner, Paul Thomas Ryan as Dr. Strauss, Thia Stephan as Charlie's Mom, Bruce Ward as Charlie's Dad, Daniel Walstad as Dr. Nemur and Shawn Verrier as Frank. The show's original Alice, Sandy Faison (also the original Grace Farrell in Broadway's Annie), narrated the one-night-only concert.

Here are some photos from last night's starry concert:



Ma-Yi Theater Company Names New Members of MA-YI WRITERS LAB, Largest Collective of AAPI P Photo
Ma-Yi Theater Company has announced the newest members of the Ma-Yi Writers Lab, which is the largest collective of AAPI playwrights in the country.

MONETS GARDEN THE IMMERSIVE EXPERIENCE Extends Through Late March Photo
Monet’s Garden The Immersive Experience U.S. premiere in New York City has announced another extension by popular demand through March 26, 2023.

New Off-Broadway-Bound Musical MADDIE Will Receive Developmental Reading This March Photo
Bennett Theatricals has announced a developmental reading for its new Off-Broadway bound musical, Maddie, which will have one afternoon presentation at Pearl Studios on Friday, March 10th at 2:00PM. Maddie played an acclaimed run at The Lyric Theatre in the West End and is based on the Jack Finney novel 'Marion's Wall' (adapted as the film 'Maxie’).

50th Anniversary Exhibition of Jamaican Artists Inspired By THE HARDER THEY COME to be Fea Photo
Beginning on Thursday, February 16, theatergoers will be able to visit Wheel and Come Again: The 50th Anniversary Art Exhibition of The Harder They Come on The Public Theater’s Levin Mezzanine, an exhibition of art inspired by the original film.


More Hot Stories For You


FRIGID New York & Manattan Theatre Source To Present 2023 EstroGenius Festival: BAN(NED) TOGETHERFRIGID New York & Manattan Theatre Source To Present 2023 EstroGenius Festival: BAN(NED) TOGETHER
February 3, 2023

FRIGID New York and Manhattan Theatre Source will present the 2023 EstroGenius Festival: BAN(NED) TOGETHER, a festival celebrating femme artists, March 15 - April 2. 

MONET'S GARDEN THE IMMERSIVE EXPERIENCE Extends Through Late MarchMONET'S GARDEN THE IMMERSIVE EXPERIENCE Extends Through Late March
February 3, 2023

Monet’s Garden The Immersive Experience U.S. premiere in New York City has announced another extension by popular demand through March 26, 2023.

New Off-Broadway-Bound Musical MADDIE Will Receive Developmental Reading This MarchNew Off-Broadway-Bound Musical MADDIE Will Receive Developmental Reading This March
February 3, 2023

Bennett Theatricals has announced a developmental reading for its new Off-Broadway bound musical, Maddie, which will have one afternoon presentation at Pearl Studios on Friday, March 10th at 2:00PM. Maddie played an acclaimed run at The Lyric Theatre in the West End and is based on the Jack Finney novel 'Marion's Wall' (adapted as the film 'Maxie’).

50th Anniversary Exhibition of Jamaican Artists Inspired By THE HARDER THEY COME to be Featured at The Public Theater50th Anniversary Exhibition of Jamaican Artists Inspired By THE HARDER THEY COME to be Featured at The Public Theater
February 2, 2023

Beginning on Thursday, February 16, theatergoers will be able to visit Wheel and Come Again: The 50th Anniversary Art Exhibition of The Harder They Come on The Public Theater’s Levin Mezzanine, an exhibition of art inspired by the original film.

THE VILLAGE! A DISCO DAYDREAM Reopens Tonight at Dixon PlaceTHE VILLAGE! A DISCO DAYDREAM Reopens Tonight at Dixon Place
February 2, 2023

The Village! A Disco Daydream returns to Dixon Place after a sold-out premiere run last fall. The encore engagement will be performed for four weekends opening tonight – Thursday, February 2 at 7:30 PM – and running through Friday, February 24.