BWW Reviews: DISASTER!: Hope Floats

Seth Rudetsky and Jack Plotnick's DISASTER! a 70s Disaster Movie Musical is a laugh-out-loud musical spoof of 70s disaster flicks, featuring repurposed hits from the decade.

It's 1979 and the opening night of Manhattan's first floating casino/discotheque. Tons of people crowd their way in for gambling and dancing, little knowing that the owner has skimped on the safety measures, and that the whole place is going down, thanks to an impending earthquake. On hand is Ted (Seth Rudetsky), a disaster expert, whose warnings, Cassandra-like, are heeded too late.

Co-writers Rudetsky and Plotnick follow the basic formula of every disaster movie: get to know the characters, and then kill some of them off in various ways. The show takes the disaster movie framework and uses it to showcase various tunes from the 1970s in ways that are usually unexpected, funny, or groan-inducing (if a character mentions a bit of trivia or other non-sequiteur, it's probably a set-up for a great pun). It's more about comedy than the music (though the talented cast and live band led by Larry Pressgrove can't help but sound great); some gag songs wisely cut out when the joke has outworn its welcome.

Who will live and who will die is always the question in such disaster flicks, and Plotnick has assembled a starry cast of hilarious musical theatre actors to embody the possibly-doomed. Matt Farcher and Robb Sapp play Chad and Scott, two buddies who take on jobs catering for the casino, though Chad is more interested in chasing tail- until he runs into Marianne (Haven Burton), his ex who left him at the altar in order to be a reporter, who is there to report on the unsafe conditions, grilling owner Tony (John Tracy Eagan), who is more interested in his love affair with lounge singer Jackie (Michele Ragusa), who has brought along her twin son and daughter Ben and Lisa (both played by Jonah Verdon). Meanwhile, Shirley (Mary Testa) and Maury (Tom Riis Farrell) a zany married couple, convince Sister (Jennifer Simard) that instead of protesting gambling outside, she could do better inside, not knowing of her gambling addiction. And of course, there's Levora (Charity Dawson), a once-popular disco queen who's down on her luck, hoping to make it big in the casino. Dropping in as several other various roles as the plot demands are Saum Eskandani, Sherz Aletaha, and Maggie McDowell.

The entire cast is great and very funny. Jennifer Simard knocks the role of Sister out of the park, starting off glum, then revealing some impressive vocals. Mary Testa is her usual brassy perfection. Rudetsky's deadpan dire warnings don't keep him from hitting his laugh lines. Farcher and Burton are charming lovebirds. Dawson lives up to the diva her character requires. Eagan is perfectly sleazy. Sapp plays the nerd to the hilt. Verdon is remarkable, as a child actor who can sing, be funny, and play two roles. Scenic and Lighting design by Josh Iacovelli is great. Costume design by Brian Hemesath must have been a dream to work on, everyone looks amazingly appropriate. Plotnick's direction is great, keeping everything moving and never missing a chance for a comic beat.

If you have a taste for campy theatre, disaster movies, or just one of the flat-out funniest casts you'll see anywhere, go check out Disaster!

DISASTER! will be performed Off-Broadway at the St. Luke's Theatre (308 W. 46th Street) beginning Monday October 14th. The schedule is Mondays at 7:30 PM, Tuesdays at 7:30 PM, Wednesdays at 2:30 PM, and Fridays at 8:00 PM. Opening night is Monday, November 4th.

Tickets for DISASTER!, which are priced from $39.50 - $69.50, are on sale now via Telecharge. Call 212-239-6200 (800-447-7400 outside of NYC) or visit to purchase tickets online.

For more info, visit

Pictured: Mary Testa (center) with the cast of DISASTER!
Photo: Jeremy Daniel


Guest Artists Announced For MAESTROS MAGICAL MUSIC BOX LIVE! With FRIGID New York At The K Photo
Guest Artists Announced For MAESTRO'S MAGICAL MUSIC BOX LIVE! With FRIGID New York At The Kraine Theater

FRIGID New York in association with Dream Sweet Films have announced the special guest artists who will appear as part of Maestro's Magical Music Box Live!, an educational children's show for kids 3-10 years performed in English and ASL based on the popular YouTube series, June 3-25 at The Kraine Theater (85 E 4th St, New York, NY 10003), with performances on Saturday and Sunday at 12pm.

Kevin Aviance, Linda Simpson & More to be Featured in LA MAMAS SQUIRTS Photo
Kevin Aviance, Linda Simpson & More to be Featured in LA MAMA'S SQUIRTS

Each year, La MaMa’s Squirts gathers the most exciting voices from New York City’s queer performance world across the generations. This year, confronting the nationwide legislative assault on trans people and drag performance, Squirts puts a heavy concentration into NYC’s drag and nightlife scenes from the 90s to today. 

JULIUS CAESAR Uncut to be Presented At The American Theatre Of Actors This Summer Photo
JULIUS CAESAR Uncut to be Presented At The American Theatre Of Actors This Summer

JULIUS CAESAR will run June 21 - July 2 at American Theatre of Actors. Learn how to purchase tickets!

Pan Asian Repertory Theatre to Present NuWORKS 2023 Featuring New Work by Asian-American A Photo
Pan Asian Repertory Theatre to Present NuWORKS 2023 Featuring New Work by Asian-American Artists

Pan Asian Repertory Theatre will present NuWorks 2023, the annual experimental series of self-created work from innovative and diverse artists exploring an eclectic range of genres and techniques using poetry, text, dance, and music.

From This Author - Duncan Pflaster


#repshow# in[i]# The Shylock and the Shakespeareans
New Ohio Theatre (6/01-6/17)

Recommended For You