Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: MAMMA MIA! Is A Joy-Fest At SKYLIGHT MUSIC THEATRE

A jukebox musical with all of the pleasure and none of the guilt

By:
Review: MAMMA MIA! Is A Joy-Fest At SKYLIGHT MUSIC THEATRE

Here we go again. After the Broadway run, countless touring companies and two movies, does the world need another production of "Mamma Mia!"? Yes. Yes, it does. And Skylight Music Theatre is delivering the exuberant '70s joy-fest through Oct. 16.

"Mamma Mia!" wasn't the first jukebox musical, but it may be the most popular, and it is distinct from other successful examples ("Jersey Boys" "Beautiful -- The Carole King Musical") in that it weaves Abba's greatest hits (written primarily by Benny Anderson, Bjorn Ulvaeus) into an original story rather than an artist biography.

Because of this, some of the songs make more sense in the plot than others. Many, like "Dancing Queen" and "Money, Money, Money" are on point. Others are more of a stretch.

Luckily, the Skylight cast, lead by Lisa Estridge and Camara Stampley, is very limber. What the story occasionally lacks in logic, it more than makes up in an energy that's impossible to resist if the opening night audience is any indication.

Director and choreographer Monica Kapoor, who was in the Broadway production for seven years, leads the entire talented cast in an unabashed embrace of the show's inherent silliness and good humor.

Estridge plays Donna, an independent single mom who runs a hotel in the Greek islands. She is preparing for her daughter's wedding with the help of two friends/former bandmates from 20 years past. Her daughter, played by the incandescent Stampley, secretly invites three men from her mother's past in the hopes (based on a clandestine reading of her mom's diary) that one is her father.

Kelly Britt and Amanda Satchell as the former partners in disco crime, are both given her own opportunity to shine and each grabs them with both hands. While "Mamma Mia" is all about girl power, the men (Ben Broughton as the groom-to-be and Ben George, Jake Horstmeyer and Victor Wallace as the potential dads) more than hold their own.

Wallace, in particular, wows with his powerful vocals. That power, and a richness born of experience, is more than matched by Estridge's amazing voice, while Stampley's is all youthful joy and longing.

"Mamma Mia" is equal parts heart, sparkle and spandex -- the latter two thanks to Costume designer Jason Orlenko.

I heard someone once refer to the "Mamma Mia" movies (Meryl Streep, Peirce Brosnan and (gulp) Cher) as guilty pleasures. Skylight's giddy "Mamma" is all of the pleasure with none of the guilt.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on SKYLIGHT MUSIC THEATRE
Upcoming Shows
Gypsy
9/25 - 10/18/2026
Recent Articles
Skylight Music Theatre to Host Tony Awards Watch Party in Milwaukee
Skylight Music Theatre to Host Tony Awards Watch Party in Milwaukee
5/27/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Milwaukee, WI News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


"Instructions for a Séance" in Milwaukee, WI "Instructions for a Séance"
Milwaukee Repertory Theater (10/06-11/08)
Weird Al Yankovic at Fiserv Forum in Milwaukee, WI Weird Al Yankovic at Fiserv Forum
Fiserv Forum (10/17-10/17)
Churchill in Milwaukee, WI Churchill
Wilson Theater at Vogel Hall (10/01-10/01)
The Play That Goes Wrong in Milwaukee, WI The Play That Goes Wrong
Racine Theatre Guild (9/11-9/27)
Dad's Season Tickets in Milwaukee, WI Dad's Season Tickets
Racine Theatre Guild (7/17-7/26)
A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder in Milwaukee, WI A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder
Skylight Music Theatre (3/12-3/28)
"JP Coletta’s Rock ‘N’ Roll Piano Man" in Milwaukee, WI "JP Coletta’s Rock ‘N’ Roll Piano Man"
Stackner Cabaret, Associate Bank Theater Center (11/06-1/03)
"The World Goes ‘Round: The Songs of Kander & Ebb" in Milwaukee, WI "The World Goes ‘Round: The Songs of Kander & Ebb"
Milwaukee Repertory Theater (9/11-11/01)
The Good One in Milwaukee, WI The Good One
Sixth Street Theatre (7/24-8/02)
SIX (Boleyn Tour) in Milwaukee, WI SIX (Boleyn Tour)
Uihlein Hall at Marcus Center For The Performing Arts (2/02-2/07)