Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Bay Street's THE GREAT GATSBY

Review: Bay Street's THE GREAT GATSBY

It is always such a treat to attend a show at the Bay Street Theater and to see what they do for the community outside their busy main stage season which is in the Summer. This includes investing heavily in their educational programming which contains their annual Literature Live! production. To quote Bay Street, "Literature Live! is a BOCES-approved Arts-in-Education program. Plays chosen are from the standards-based literature and are supported with teacher-developed lesson plans and reference materials. All performances are 90 minutes and weekday shows are followed by a question and answer session. Bay Street Theater is committed to supporting students who have little or no access to the performing arts in schools. Now in its 10th season, the program has successfully served over 60 schools and nearly 30,000 students and their educators. The production is performed free for student groups and their teachers from across Long Island. Literature Live! is currently being supported by a Matching Grant of $100,000, with $27,550 currently raised to date. School groups can reserve free tickets for their group by contacting mary@baystreet.org"

This year the Sag Harbor venue has mounted a superb showing of the classic jazz era play The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald adapted for the stage by Simon Levy.

Running through November 25th, Bay Street vet Joe Minutillo directs the boffo incarnation boasting a wonderful ensemble cast. The titular character, Jay Gatsby, is strongly portrayed by Charlie Westfal. Gatsby is a mysterious, very well-to-do man who has long been enamored with Daisy, a young Louisville debutante endearingly portrayed by Sara Carolynn Kennedy. They previously met when Gatsby was in World War I and haven't seen each other in years. However, Nick, Daisy's cousin portrayed charmingly by John Kroft, has just moved into town and arranges for them to meet. Of course, Daisy is currently married unfortunately to a despicable man, Tom portrayed by Dan Fenaughty. In truth, I could really go on and on about the cast as they are all terrific.

For the record, this is not a funny tale or any sort comedy; the storylines are intense, dark, and the cast is top-notch delivering. The story, set on Long Island in 1922, depicts and explores human emotions and actions like ambition, love, and lust among others. Primarily, it seems to go into the struggles of that time of class and the American Dream.

On Mr. Minutillo's creative team, Mike Billings' set is smart and lovely with mostly rolling pieces for the intimate stage making for seamless scene changes. This is stunningly enhanced with Mr. Billings' lighting design and Melanie Clifton-Harvey's beautiful costumes. It is always fun to see men in suits and the women's flapper dresses are dazzling. If there is a minor qualm, there seems to be some fleeting moments of the choreography that seem slightly awkward, but chalk that up to big, fun jazz choreography with limited overall space.

And so, The Great Gatsby is indeed another hit for the adorable Bay Street Theater. Be sure to catch this powerful, visually stunning production. A classic tale and a fabulous cast make for a thrilling night of theatre.


The Great Gatsby is presented by the Bay Street Theater of Sag Harbor, Long Island. For more information and to purchase tickets please dial (631) 725-9500 or visit www.baystreet.org

By F. Scott Fitzgerald's, adapted for the stage by Simon Levy, directed by Joe Minutillo (Literature Live! productions of The Diary of Anne Frank, To Kill A Mockingbird, Of Mice and Men, The Scarlett Letter, Death of a Salesman), Choreography by Stephanie Vertichio, Original Music by Michael Holland, Fight Direction by Rick Sordelet, Set and Lighting Design by Mike Billings, Projection Design by Brian Staton, Costumes by Melanie Clifton-Harvey, Hair & Make-up by Meg Murphy, Stage Management by Taylor Alyssa Marun, and Melisa Zorer (Assistant Stage Manager).

Starring Charlie Westfal (Guild Hall: Romeo & Juliet; Columbia University: The Cherry Orchard, Mother Courage), John Kroft (Bay Street's The Tempest; Regional: Bram Stoker's Dracula; New York: Dan Cody's Yacht), Sara Carolynn Kennedy (New York: Hindle Wakes, For All My Girls; Regional: Shout!, The Mod Musical), Alexandra Kopko (Regional: It's A Wonderful Life, Uncle Vanya, Dark and Stormy), Dan Fenaughty (National Tours: The 39 Steps, Miracle On 34th Street, Cabaret), Chauncy Thomas (Bay Street's To Kill a Mockingbird, Of Mice and Men, Bay Street's New Works: The Prompter), Amanda Kristin Nichols (Bay Street's The Last Night of Ballyhoo, Bay Street's The Tempest, Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet), Scott T. Hinson (Bay Street's: To Kill a Mockingbird, Men's Lives, Death of a Salesman), and Stephanie Turci (New York: '68: A New American Musical; Regional: Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, The Wiz)

Photo by Lenny Stucker/lennystucker.com



Review: GRUMPY OLD MEN: THE MUSICAL at Elmont Library Theatre Photo
What did our critic think of GRUMPY OLD MEN: THE MUSICAL at Elmont Library Theatre?

FIRESIDE SESSIONS WITH NANCY ATLAS to Return toBay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center  Photo
The popular concert series, Fireside Sessions with Nancy Atlas, is returning to Bay Street Theater in January, with four live concerts at the theater starting Saturday, January 7, at 8 p.m. Performances continue every Saturday through January at 8 p.m.

Review: THE WIZARD OF OZ at CM Performing Arts Center Photo
What did our critic think of THE WIZARD OF OZ at CM Performing Arts Center? As soon as CM Performing Arts Center's live orchestra struck up the first few chords of 'The Wizard of Oz's' iconic overture, a wave of nostalgia hummed throughout the Noel S Ruiz Theatre. Multiple generations filled the house at the opening weekend matinee. Children, parents, grandparents, and children at heart visibly delighted in the stellar stagecraft, vibrant costumery, and charming performances featured in CM's Season 49 finale.

Review: A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater Photo
What did our critic think of A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater?


From This Author - Melissa Giordano

Melissa has been covering theatre for BroadwayWorld for the past eight years and has loved every second of it. She is consistently inspired by the talent of the artists of her beloved Long Island a... (read more about this author)


Review: A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman TheaterReview: A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater
November 24, 2022

What did our critic think of A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater?

Review: CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre ThreeReview: CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three
November 17, 2022

What did our critic think of CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three?

Review: ALL THINGS EQUAL: THE LIFE AND TRIALS OF RUTH BADER GINSBURG at Bay Street TheaterReview: ALL THINGS EQUAL: THE LIFE AND TRIALS OF RUTH BADER GINSBURG at Bay Street Theater
November 10, 2022

What did our critic think of ALL THINGS EQUAL: THE LIFE AND TRIALS OF RUTH BADER GINSBURG at Bay Street Theater?

Review: OVER THE RIVER AND THROUGH THE WOODS at Hampton Theatre CompanyReview: OVER THE RIVER AND THROUGH THE WOODS at Hampton Theatre Company
November 3, 2022

What did our critic think of OVER THE RIVER AND THROUGH THE WOODS at Hampton Theatre Company?

Review: MATILDA at the Noel S. Ruiz Theatre at CM Performing Arts CenterReview: MATILDA at the Noel S. Ruiz Theatre at CM Performing Arts Center
October 20, 2022

What did our critic think of MATILDA at The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre At CM Performing Arts Center?