A raging storm, a sudden blackout, and a house full of eccentric guests — what could possibly go wrong? In Jack Sharkey’s madcap mystery farce While the Lights Were Out, a simple evening spirals into chaos when a murder is discovered in the dark. Packed with quirky characters, witty banter, and nonstop twists, this play keeps the laughs coming while everyone tries to solve the crime. Onstage: September 19-27, 2025 with matinee (2pm) and evening (7:30pm) performances.
Cast and Creative team for While the Lights Were Out at The Belle Theatre
Cast
Paola Cifuentes
LADY MONICA WICKENHAM
Parrish Danesh
LORD CLIVE WICKENHAM/TOM GROGGINS
Dea Boozer
BIBI CAVENDISH
Justin Price
PIERRE POURRI
Cara Bolin
JASMINE PERDOO
DeVaughn Parris
MIMOSA
Tara Wharton-Price
NANCY STAFFORD
Aidan Tatro
RODERICK REMLEY
Kieran Strosser
FREDONIA CUSTARDINE
Grace Koltz
CHLOE CUSTARDINE
Ethan MacKay
ALGERNON WICKENHAM
Joey Bostic
BENJAMIN BRADDOCK
Peyton McCarthy
ALMA THREEDLE
Beckie Gould
UNIDENTIFIED BLONDE
Creative Team
Tyler Young
Director
Gaege Hock
Lighting
Nyelle Love
Sound
Tyler Young
Set Design
Kieran Strosser
Costume Design
SUBMIT UPDATES
The Belle Theatre Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Always A Bridesmaid (2/6/26-2/14/26)
9 to 5: The Musical (2/27/26-3/14/26)
The Belle Theatre is at 2708 Santa Barbara Blvd Suite 135, Cape Coral, FL.
I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change (1/16/26-1/24/26)
Disney's Frozen (12/18/25-12/28/25)
Young Frankenstein (10/17/25-10/31/25)
Standing O! A Modern Broadway Revue (9/5/25-9/13/25)
Cabaret (8/1/25-8/16/25)
In Pieces: A New Musical (6/19/25-6/22/25)
Videos
 |
Million Dollar Quartet
Music & Arts Community Center (1/28 - 2/14) | |
|
& Juliet
Barbara B. Mann Performing Arts Center (2/3 - 2/8) | |
|
Comedian Andrew Dice Clay Live in Naples, Florida!
Off The Hook Comedy Club (2/2 - 2/3) | |
|
Always A Bridesmaid
The Belle Theatre (2/6 - 2/14) | |
|
Chicago the Musical
Hayes Hall (2/10 - 2/15) | |
|
Comedian Duncan Trussell Live in Naples, Florida!
Off The Hook Comedy Club (2/19 - 2/21) | |
|
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
Gulfshore Playhouse (4/26 - 5/31) | |
|
You've Got Hate Mail
Arts Center Theatre (4/9 - 4/26) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Ft. Myers/Naples's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Ft. Myers/Naples & beyond.
