Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: THE ADDAMS FAMILY at Broadway Palm

Runs through May 25

By:
Review: THE ADDAMS FAMILY at Broadway Palm

I expected The Addams Family, now playing at Broadway Palm, to be a dark comedy. And it was. What I didn’t expect was an evening of love stories. Of course, given it was the Addams family after all, the love stores were deliciously off-kilter.

The show gave us the gamut in love: young lovers, older lovers rediscovering their young love, long married lovers rekindling their relationship, and older characters who hadn’t yet given up on love.

Each character had at least one opportunity to shine, and boy, did they. The voices are uniformly good and the timing excellent.

Jordan Bunshaft as Uncle Fester was a comic gem acting as sort of an emcee for an outrageous dinner party to introduce the Addams clan to the parents of their daughter’s love interest. Daughter Wednesday was played with over-the-top glee by Lindsay Hoffpauir.

Matthew Harper Stevenson as her buttoned-up boyfriend Lucas Beineke and his equally uptight parents Lauren Foutch and Steffen Whorton all loosened up eventually, particularly Foutch who transformed from a rhyme spouting matron to a tigress before our eyes. Her body language was highly entertaining.

Caleb Aguilar as Gomez and Liv Pelton as Morticia were fun to watch as they replicated their TV counterparts. I was tickled to see him kissing his way up her arm, just as I remember. I also enjoyed her mincing glide across the stage.

Even Randy Kessenich as the incoherent Lurch got a moment. Who knew there was a melodious bass singing voice under there?

Kudos to Make-up Designer Theresa Walker Smith, Wig Designer Brandon T. Miller, and Costume Designer John P. White. The visuals added a lot to the overall effect of the show.  I loved the all-white appearance of the Addams dead ancestors in contrast to the all-black costumes of the living.

If you enjoy macabre humor, this is definitely the show for you. The production runs through May 25. For tickets, call 239.278.4422.

More on Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre
Upcoming Shows
The Wizard of Oz
The Wizard of Oz
6/26 - 8/8/2026
Murder on Broadway
Murder on Broadway
7/8 - 8/8/2026
Recent Articles
MURDER ON BROADWAY to Open at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre in Fort Myers
MURDER ON BROADWAY to Open at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre in Fort Myers
7/8/2026
Photos: WIZARD OF OZ to Open at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre in Fort Myers
Photos: WIZARD OF OZ to Open at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre in Fort Myers
6/30/2026

Reader Reviews

Need more Ft. Myers/Naples Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Little Bear Ridge Road by Samuel D Hunter in Ft. Myers/Naples Little Bear Ridge Road by Samuel D Hunter
The Studio Players (3/05-3/21)
Tom Briscoe’s “It’s Not Mansplaining, It’s Old Mansplaining” in Ft. Myers/Naples Tom Briscoe’s “It’s Not Mansplaining, It’s Old Mansplaining”
Arts Center Theatre (9/27-9/27)
Come From Away in Ft. Myers/Naples Come From Away
The Naples Players (11/18-12/20)
Dancing Lessons  in Ft. Myers/Naples Dancing Lessons
Theatre Conspiracy at Off-Broadway Palm (7/17-8/02)
SIX (Boleyn Tour) in Ft. Myers/Naples SIX (Boleyn Tour)
Barbara B. Mann Performing Arts Center (3/05-3/07)
Death Trap by Ira Levin in Ft. Myers/Naples Death Trap by Ira Levin
Arts Center Theatre (1/07-1/24)
Stage 2 Improv in Ft. Myers/Naples Stage 2 Improv
Arts Center Theatre (8/15-8/15)
Guys & Dolls in Ft. Myers/Naples Guys & Dolls
Gulfshore Playhouse (3/03-4/11)
Murder On The Orient Express in Ft. Myers/Naples Murder On The Orient Express
The Naples Players (1/13-2/14)
Chameleüns in Ft. Myers/Naples Chameleüns
Arts Center Theatre (10/02-10/04)