Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Sing Along With GREASE at Toby's In Columbia

Review: Sing Along With GREASE at Toby's In Columbia

...still familiar to me, sends a thrill right through me...

Ready for some young energy at Toby's Dinner Theatre in Columbia? Here's a whole high school musical of less-frequently featured faces, with the regular lions filling out the ensemble and making themselves useful in "adult" roles. The youthful company, including a remarkable newcomer, holds the piece together bedecked in rolled denim jeans, wiggle skirts, saddle shoes, Chuck Taylor sneakers, product-heavy hair and pink satin jackets- in short, just what you expect of GREASE.

I represent a certain target demographic. Once upon a time, I had the entirety of the Grease vinyl record memorized, the Olivia Newton-John Travolta version from 1978, as did many of my chronological peers: the album was the second-best-selling record of '78, behind Saturday Night Fever. GREASE the stage musical written by Jim Jacobs and Warren Casey, however, originally was produced with grit and obscenity in 1971, as Chicago-specific, objectionable, and no place for wholesome Olivia Newton-John.

Beginning with its pre-Broadway tuneup, the show has been diluted repeatedly until there's little left of the gang rivalries, socioeconomic snobbery, ethnic division and shock-value swearing that originally were intrinsic to the show's appeal as a teenage rebellion fable. What's left is an American anthem to high-school pettiness and the transformative power of negative peer pressure, along with some catchy songs that don't have much to do with one another. Call it a guilty pleasure.

Toby's Dinner Theatre features family-friendly material on a regular basis, and, like PHANTOM OF THE OPERA, GREASE is popular with audiences despite desperately dated and mournfully misogynistic overarching themes. Even so, because do-wop, rama lama and shooby doop have such wide appeal, many will smile fondly at the songs from GREASE, ignore the script, and enjoy a family outing to see a live performance. So, though you can mark me down as "not a fan" of the foundational material, it's a perky little night out and Toby's does have great fun with the production.

Director and Choreographer Mark Minnick deploys his usual deft hand at group number arrangements from the outset. In a digression from the original, the flashback is not from a reunion, but graduation, which is much more plausible and also more easily managed. The dance moves are snappy and well-executed, and though the Rydell anthem officially opens the show, the fun really begins with "Summer Lovin,'" ("Grease Is The Word," the disco hit written by Barry Gibb and recorded by Frankie Valli specifically for the '78 movie, is happily absent from this production), with counterpoint alternating vocals. Minnick's choreography gets more interesting as the show progresses, and the inclusive, body-positive cast looks confident and enthusiastic executing it. As Doody, who leads "Those Magic Changes," Taylor Witt is charming, though his guitar lip-synchs the number while orchestra guitarist Daniel Lewis does the heavy lifting.

"Freddie My Love," the featured song for lovely Nia Savoy, playing Marty, is the mercenary treat I remember, and "Greased Lightnin'" looks good, sounds good, but has some ...hmm... unfamiliar lyrics. "Mooning" a duet between Roger and Jan, engagingly played by Toby's regular Justin Calhoun and the wonderful new addition Kalen Robinson, respectively, is adorable in every way. It's followed by the less-than-heartwarming "Look At Me, I'm Sandra Dee" dropped with sass and pizzaz by Maggie Dransfield as Rizzo before "We Go Together" marks the end of Act I. A twenty-ish minute intermission follows, and our darling server Rachel delivers delicious Pink Lady Milkshakes, Toby's signature drink for the show. I recommend them.

Ross Scott Rawlings, Musical Director, delivers the harmonies we hope for, with some interesting variations. He and choreographer Minnick really shine in Act II's sock hop scene, where Jeffrey Shankle plays an appropriately slimy Vince Fontaine and Helen Hayes Award winner DeCarlo Raspberry really rocks his Johnny Casino. Our darling server Rachel Kemp nails her portrayal of Cha-Cha Di Gregorio, though another character calling Cha-Cha a gorilla only makes sense if you recall that GREASE was originally packed with slurs and stereotypes about people of both Italian and Polish descent.

I love the liberties taken with "Beauty School Dropout" and Crystal Freeman's take on Teen Angel chiding Allie O'Donnell's Frenchy. Naturally, Olivia Newton-John needed her own solo for the film, but the inclusion of "Hopelessly Devoted" as an alternate to "Raining On Prom Night" in live productions is discretionary, and often skipped, possibly due to its anti-feminist sensibility. It's performed well, though, by an extraordinarily earnest Nicki Elledge as Sandy Dumbrowski. Mark Minnick wisely envisions Danny Zuko, played by cheerful and cheeky Matt Hirsh, as very nearly Sandy's equal in innocence, and the drive-in sequence contains some very funny pantomime comedy. "Alone At the Drive-In Movie" is his solo (in the movie it was replaced by "Sandy") and Hirsh has a pleasing voice and expressive face.

"There Are Worse Things I Could Do," a powerfully sung solo ballad for Dransfield, who plays Betty Rizzo, is possibly the best-written song in the show, and it's a pity it's not as well known as some of the others. Maggie Dransfield herself has a remarkable range, and I hope will reprise her role as Sophie in MAMMA MIA!, which follows GREASE in this summer's lineup at Toby's.

"You're The One That I Want," written for the movie, is a fun, playful number in an unabashedly '70s-pop way, and the cast is clearly having a great time performing it.

In two generally undersung roles of GREASE are the impressive Louisa Tringali as Patty Simcox and Catholic U graduate Shiloh Orr as Eugene Florczyk. Louisa's secret to looking perpetually seventeen years old should be patented and sold for jillions of dollars, and her versatility in roles from supporting character Dainty June in GYPSY, ensemble performer in MAMMA MIA! to sultry lead Inga in YOUNG FRANKENSEIN is superlatively remarkable. Shiloh physically commits to Eugene's nerdy aesthetic 100%, and looks just swell in Danny's jacket.

In a featured role which I fully endorse, but which receives no credit in the programme or anywhere, is an adorably bedecked little buggy as Greased Lightnin,' the beater that Paul Roeckell, as Kenecki, intends to soup up and deck out. Whether the nod goes to Scenic Designer David Hopkins or Properties and Set Dresser Amy Kaplan, Tech Director Emily Thompson or another figure in the shadows, kudos and applause. It's super cute and I love it.

GREASE plays at Toby's through July 28th, to be followed starting August 1 by MAMMA MIA!

Toby's Dinner Theatre of Columbia,

5900 Symphony Woods Road, Columbia MD 21044

Purchase tickets through the Box Office: (410) 730-8311; (301) 596-6161; (410) 995-1969 or online. Visit Toby's website for more information about the show or the menu.

Photo: Allie O'Donnell (L) and Crystal Freeman (R) as Frenchy and Teen Angel

Photo Credit: Jeri Tidwell Photography

From This Author - Cybele Pomeroy

Review: THE SPONGEBOB MUSICAL at Toby's Dinner TheaterReview: THE SPONGEBOB MUSICAL at Toby's Dinner Theater
June 28, 2022

What did our critic think?If you don't have cable, watch SpongeBob Squarepants nor any clue why SpongeBob should be a Broadway musical, no worries. Everything is made clear for those entering Bikini Bottom for the first time. It's packed with family theater elements: bright colors, important themes, messages of friendship, catchy tunes and slapstick comedy. Best day ever!

BWW Review: ROCKY at Toby's Thinks Outside The BoxingBWW Review: ROCKY at Toby's Thinks Outside The Boxing
April 14, 2022

New talent joins Toby's regulars to present ROCKY THE MUSICAL at Toby's in Columbia. Inspired by an actual 1974 boxing match, the unknown Rocky Balboa 'goes the distance' against superstar Apollo Creed, proving to himself, his lady love and all of Philly that an underdog can have teeth. Music and lyrics by Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens.

BWW Review: SPAMALOT! Sizzles at Toby's In ColumbiaBWW Review: SPAMALOT! Sizzles at Toby's In Columbia
January 23, 2022

The members of Monty Python's Flying Circus are expert practitioners of this alternative therapy, producing ridiculosities that have spanned five decades so far. SPAMALOT! which originally was scheduled to play at Toby's in the summer of 2020, assures that the Python iconic silliness will continue amusing live audiences for many additional decades.

November 16, 2021

In the tradition of ‘40s musicals, WHITE CHRISTMAS tugs heartstrings and brightens spirits. The timeless music of Irving Berlin combined with the dedication and talent of Toby’s yields a family-friendly show sure to give you cocoa-and-fireplace feelings no matter the weather

BWW Review: GODSPELL Speaks to Contemporary Audiences At Toby's In ColumbiaBWW Review: GODSPELL Speaks to Contemporary Audiences At Toby's In Columbia
September 5, 2021

Are you in the mood for an ensemble romp, some familiar stories, an ethics-heavy main character, beautiful harmonies and a good meal? In GODSPELL at Toby’s, a cast of stalwart Toby’s regulars create beautiful moments individually and in groups. Directors Mark Minnik and David James update the storytelling to include contemporary iconography.