| Lifetime Achievement Award | Lynne Meadow | |
| Oustanding Play | Jon Robin Baitz | Other Desert Cities |
| Outstanding Alternative Theatrical Experience | | GatzThe Public Theater |
| Outstanding Choreographer | Danny Mefford | Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson |
| Outstanding Choreographer | Gail Pennington Crutchfield | Freckleface Strawberry |
| Outstanding Choreographer | Annie-B Parson | Orlando |
| Outstanding Choreographer | Steven Hoggett | Peter and the Starcatcher |
| Outstanding Choreographer | Tracy Bersley | The Witch of Edmonton |
|
| Outstanding Costume Design | Jennifer Caprio | In Transit |
| Outstanding Costume Design | David Zinn | Other Desert Cities |
|
| Outstanding Costume Design | Gabriel Berry | The Coward |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Cait O'Connor | The Witch of Edmonton |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Emily Rebholz | This Wide Night |
| Outstanding Director | John Collins | Gatz |
| Outstanding Director | Leigh Silverman | In the Wake |
| Outstanding Director | Joe Mantello | Other Desert Cities |
|
|
| Outstanding Director | Joe Mantello | The Other Place |
| Outstanding Director | Anne Kauffman | This Wide Night |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | David Margulies | After the Revolution |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | Michael Chernus | In the Wake |
|
| Outstanding Featured Actor | Thomas Sadoski | Other Desert Cities |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | Noah Galvin | The Burnt Part Boys |
| Outstanding Featured Actor | David Patrick Kelly | When I Come to Die |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Lois Smith | After the Revolution |
|
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Deirdre O'Connell | In the Wake |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Laura Heisler | Kin |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Linda Lavin | Other Desert Citites |
| Outstanding Featured Actress | Kristen Schaal | The Coward |
| Outstanding Lead Actor | The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Deity | Desmin Borges |
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Michael Shannon | Mistakes Were Made |
|
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Christian Borle | Peter and the Starcatcher |
| Outstanding Lead Actor | Jeremy Strong | The Coward |
|
|
| Outstanding Lead Actor | André Braugher | The Whipping Man |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Michele Pawk | A Small Fire |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Tracee Chimo | Bachelorette |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Elizabeth Marvel | The Little Foxes |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Laurie Metcalf | The Other Place |
| Outstanding Lead Actress | Edie Falco | This Wide Night |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Mark Barton | Gatz |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Jesse Klug | The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Deity |
|
|
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Ben Stanton | The Whipping Man |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Matt Frey | This Wide Night |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Betsy Adams | When I Come to Die |
| Outstanding Musical | Alex Timbers, Michael Friedman | Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson |
| Outstanding Musical | Kristen Anderson-Lopez, James-Allen Ford, Russ Kaplan, Sara Wordsworth | In Transit |
| Outstanding Musical | Mariana Elder, Chris Miller, Nathan Tysen | The Burnt Part Boys |
| Outstanding Musical | Andy Monroe, Jack Lechner, Michael Zam | The Kid |
| Outstanding Musical | Mark Weiner, Joe Iconis, Brad Alexander, Kevin Del Aguila, Eli Bolin, Sam Forman, Tommy Newman, Ryan Scott Oliver, Adam Overett, Erik Weiner, Jordan Allen-Dutton | We the People: America Rocks! |
|
|
| Outstanding Play | Lisa Kron | In the Wake |
| Outstanding Play | Rick Elice | Peter and the Starcatcher |
|
| Outstanding Play | Nick Jones | The Coward |
| Outstanding Play | Kristoffer Diaz | The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Deity |
| Outstanding Revival | Tony Kushner | Angels in America: Millennium ApproachesSignature Theatre Company |
| Outstanding Revival | Tony Kushner | Angels in America: PerestroikaSignature Theatre Company |
| Outstanding Revival | Harold Pinter | The Collection & A Kind of AlaskaAtlantic Theater Company |
| Outstanding Revival | Lillian Hellman | The Little FoxesNew York Theatre Workshop |
|
| Outstanding Revival | Molière | The MisanthropeThe Pearl Theatre Company |
| Outstanding Revival | Anton Chekhov | Three SistersClassic Stage Company |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Donyale Werle | Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Anna Louizos | In Transit |
|
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Donyale Werle | Peter and the Starcatcher |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Jan Versweyveld | The Little Foxes |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Rachel Hauck | This Wide Night |
| Outstanding Solo Show | Mike Birbiglia | Mike Birbiglia's My Girlfriend's Boyfriend |
|
|
| Outstanding Solo Show | Daniel Beaty | Through the Night |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Ben Williams | Gatz |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Jon Weston | In Transit |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Mic Pool | The 39 Steps |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Mikhail Fiksel | The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Deity |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Fitz Patton | The Other Place |
|
| Service to Off-Broadway Award | Gary Glaser | |
