| Outstanding Actor - Musical | Jonathan Pryce | Miss Saigon |
| Outstanding Actor - Musical | Mandy Patinkin | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Actor - Musical | Keith Carradine | The Will Rogers Follies |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Kevin Kline | Hamlet |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Tom McGowan | La Bete |
| Outstanding Actor - Play | Ron Rifkin | The Substance of Fire |
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Lea Salonga | Miss Saigon |
| Outstanding Actress - Musical | Donna Murphy | Song of Singapore |
|
| Outstanding Actress - Play | Mercedes Ruehl | Lost in Yonkers |
| Outstanding Actress - Play | Angela Goethals | The Good Times are Killing Me |
|
| Outstanding Book of a Musical | Marsha Norman | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Choreography | Richard Hudson | La Bete |
| Outstanding Choreography | Santo Loquasto | Lost in Yonkers |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Florence Klotz | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Santo Loquasto | Grand Hotel |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Jennifer Arnold, Robert Locke | The Lady in Question |
|
|
| Outstanding Director - Musical | Scott Ellis | A Little Night Music / The World Goes Round |
| Outstanding Director - Musical | Susan H. Schulman | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Patrick Mason | Dancing at Lughnasa |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Dancing at Lughnasa | Dancing at Lughnasa |
|
| Outstanding Director - Play | Kevin Kline | Hamlet |
| Outstanding Director - Play | Richard Jones | La Bete |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Musical | John Remme | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Musical | John Cameron | The Secret Garden |
|
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Dylan Baker | La Bete |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | LaLand Gantt | Let Me Live |
| Outstanding Featured Actor - Play | Kevin Spacey | Lost in Yonkers |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Musical | Alison Frase, Rebecca Luker | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Musical | Karen Ziemba | The World Goes Round |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Musical | Regina Resnik | A Little Night Music |
|
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Jane Adams | I Hate Hamlet |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Irene Worth | Lost in Yonkers |
|
|
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Tracey Ellis | Our Country's Goods |
| Outstanding Featured Actress - Play | Julie Halston | Red Scare on Sunset |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Trevor Dawson | Dancing at Lughnasa |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | David Hersey | Miss Saigon |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Tharon Musser | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Robert Hipkins, Erik Frandsen, Michael Garin, Paula Lockheart | Song of Singapore |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Marsha Norman | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Music | Erik Frandsen, Michael Garin, Paul Lockheart, Robert Hipkins | Song of Singapore |
|
|
| Outstanding Music | Lucy Simon | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Music | Cy Coleman | The Will Rogers Follies |
| Outstanding Musical | The Secret Garden | The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Musical | The Will Rogers Follies | The Will Rogers Follies |
| Outstanding Musical Revue | And the World Goes Round | And the World Goes Round |
| Outstanding New Play | Brian Friel | Dancing at Lughnasa |
| Outstanding New Play | Neil Simon | Lost in Yonkers |
| Outstanding New Play | David Hirson | La Bete |
|
|
| Outstanding One Person Show | Eileen Atkins | A Room of One's Own |
| Outstanding One Person Show | Jeffrey Essmann | Artificial Reality |
|
| Outstanding One Person Show | Kevin Kling | Home and Away |
| Outstanding One Person Show | Spalding Grey | Monster in a Box |
| Outstanding One Person Show | Tracey Ullman | The Big Love |
| Outstanding Orchestration | William Brohn | Miss Saigon / The Secret Garden |
| Outstanding Orchestration | John Carlini | Song of Singapore |
| Outstanding Orchestration | Billy Byers | The Will Rogers Follies |
|
| Outstanding Orchestration | David Krane | The World Goes Round |
| Outstanding Orchestration | Mboni Ngema | Towship Fever |
| Outstanding Revival | A Little Night Music | A Little Night Music |
| Outstanding Revival | Machinal | Machinal |
|
| Outstanding Set Design | Joe Vanek | Dancing at Lughnasa |
| Outstanding Set Design | Richard Hudson | La Bete |
| Outstanding Set Design | Andrew Jackness | The Road to Nirvana |
| Outstanding Set Design | Heidi Handesman | The Secret Garden |
|
|
| Outstanding Sound Design - Play | Aural Fixation | Red Scare on Sunset |
| Outstanding Sound Design - Play | Janet Kalas | The Good Times are Killing Me |
| Outstanding Sound Design - Play | Olu Dara | Let Me Live |
| Special Awards | The Brooklyn Academy of Music, Harold Rome, James McMullan, New York Dramatists | The Brooklyn Academy of Music |
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Blue Man Group in Tubes | Blue Man Group in Tubes |
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Cirque du Soleil | Cirque du Soleil |
|
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Lypsinka! A Day in the Life | Lypsinka! A Day in the Life |
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Pageant | Pageant |
|
