| Awards | Category | Nominee | Show |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Musical | Harry Groener | Crazy for You Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Musical | Nathan Lane | Guys and Dolls Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Musical | Spiro Malas | The Most Happy Fella Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Musical | Keith Carradine | The Will Rogers Follies Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Play | Judd Hirsch | Conversations with My Father Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Play | Alan Alda | Jake's Women Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Play | Brian Bedford | Two Shakespearean Actors Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor - Play | Roscoe Lee Browne | Two Trains Running Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Musical | Faith Prince | Guys and Dolls Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Musical | Faith Prince | Nick & Nora Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Musical | Donna Murphy | Song of Singapore Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Musical | Sophie Hayden | The Most Happy Fella Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Play | Jessica Lange | A Streetcar Named Desire Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Play | Pauline Flanagan | Grandchild of Kings Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Play | Laura Esterman | Marvin's Room Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Actress - Play | Jane Alexander | The Visit Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Musical | 0 | Crazy for You Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Musical | 0 | Five Guys Named Moe Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Musical | 0 | The High Rollers Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Musical | 0 | The Will Rogers Follies Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Play | 0 | Conversations with My Father Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Play | 0 | Dancing at Lughnasa Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Play | 0 | Two Shakespearean Actors Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Broadway Play | 0 | Two Trains Running Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Choreography | Christopher Chadman | Guys and Dolls Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Choreography | Susan Stroman | Crazy for You Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Choreography | Lisa Gennaro | The Most Fella Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Choreography | Tommy Tune | The Will Rogers Follies Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Comedy | 0 | Beau Jest Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Comedy | 0 | Breaking Legs Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Comedy | 0 | Catskills on Broadway Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Comedy | 0 | Julie Halston's Lifetime of Comedy Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Tom Hewitt | Beau Jest Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Griffin Dunne | Search and Destroy Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Laurence Fishburne | Two Trains Running Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Amy Madigan | A Streetcar Named Desire Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Sue Giosa | Breaking Legs Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Cathy Foy | Song of Singapore Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Joe Mantello | The Baltimore Waltz Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Debut Performance | Cynthia Martells | Two Trains Running Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Director | Daniel Sullivan - | Conversations with My Father Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Director | Patrick Mason | Dancing at Lughnasa Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Director | Harold Prince - | Grandchild of Kings Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Director | David Petrarea | Marvin's Room Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Director | Lloyd Richards - | Two Trains Running Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Book, Music and Lyrics | 0 | Opal Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Book, Music and Lyrics | 0 | Pageant Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Book, Music and Lyrics | 0 | Return to the Forbidden Planet Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Book, Music and Lyrics | 0 | Song of Singapore Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Musical | 0 | Opal Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Musical | 0 | Pageant Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Musical | 0 | Return to the Forbidden Planet Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Musical | 0 | Song of Singapore Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Play | 0 | Grandchild of Kings Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Play | 0 | Lips Together Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Play | 0 | Marvin's Room Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Play | 0 | Sight Unseen Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Off Broadway Play | 0 | Teeth Apart Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Musical | 0 | Guys and Dolls Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Musical | 0 | Man of La Mancha Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Musical | 0 | Rags Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Musical | 0 | The Most Happy Fella Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Play | 0 | A Streetcar Named Desire Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Play | 0 | Boesman and Lena Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Play | 0 | The Crucible Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Revival - Play | 0 | The Visit Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Set, Costume and Lighting Design | Robin Wagner (Set), | Crazy for You Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Set, Costume and Lighting Design | Joe Vanck | Dancing at Lughnasa Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Set, Costume and Lighting Design | Joe Vanck | Dancing at Lughnasa Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Set, Costume and Lighting Design | Richard Pilbrow | Four Baboons Adoring the Sun Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Best Set, Costume and Lighting Design | John Lee Beatty | Song of Singapore Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Death and the Maiden | Glenn Close | Death and the Maiden Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | John Gassner Playwriting Award | Endesha Ida Mae Holland | From the Mississippi Delta Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | John Gassner Playwriting Award | Scott McPherson | Marvin's Room Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | John Gassner Playwriting Award | Donald Margulies | Sight Unseen Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | John Gassner Playwriting Award | Lynda Barry | The Good Times Are Killing Me Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Special Awards | Tony Randall | 0 Season 1991-1992 |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | Special Awards | Ellen Stewart | La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club Season 1991-1992 |
