Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: VERDICT at Oyster Mill Playhouse

This story of relationships and choices is on stage through January 29th

By:
Review: VERDICT at Oyster Mill Playhouse

By Sandra Harberger

"Verdict" is an original play written by the famous British author, Agatha Christie. It's one of very few that she wrote not based on a book. The show premiered in 1958, and it is now at Oyster Mill Playhouse January 13th - 29th under the direction of Aliza Bardfield. It is considered unique because it's not a traditional murder mystery since it delves more into the complicated relationships between the characters in the story.

You are first introduced to Lester Cole, played by Ricardo Graham in his debut performance at Oyster Mill Playhouse. Lester is a student of the kind professor Karl Hendryk. Matthew Golden demonstrates strength and emotion in his portrayal of Karl Hendryk. His wife, Anya, is confined to a wheelchair with a progressive illness. Skylar Gunning played Anya and was able to capture the pain and anguish of having lost so much in life. Sarah Pinter played Lisa Koletzky, Anya's cousin and main care-giver. Sarah's performance was moving in this heart-wrenching story.

Karen McLaughlin played the nosy housecleaner, Mrs. Roper, with excellent comedic timing in an otherwise serious show. The understanding doctor, Dr. Stoner, was played by Gordon Einhorn. Sam Speraw nailed the spoiled, entitled debutante, Hellen Rollander. Her father, Sir William Rollander, is played by Murray J. Week.

No murder story is complete without law enforcement. Joel Persing plays Detective Inspector Ogden. Ricardo Graham changes characters to play Police Sergeant Pearce. Members of the production staff include Colleen Barno, Michael Holler, Rick Ansel, Bo Sidney, Mikayla Kitchen, Kristen Borgersen, and Stephen Jahn. Many members of the cast also took part in the production of the show. The production photographer is Nicole Dube.

This is a moving story of love, choices, and pain. Right and wrong are sometimes not so black and white. Many times people are blind to the effect their choices in life have on others. I can see why this is one of Agatha Christie's favorite plays that she wrote. I highly recommend seeing this classic while showing at Oyster Mill Playhouse this month.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Oyster Mill Playhouse
Recent Articles
Review: LETTICE AND LOVAGE at Oyster Mill Playhouse
Review: LETTICE AND LOVAGE at Oyster Mill Playhouse
7/12/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Central Pennsylvania News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Golden Girls The Laughs Continue in Central Pennsylvania Golden Girls The Laughs Continue
Mishler Theatre (11/17-11/17)
South Pacific in Central Pennsylvania South Pacific
Totem Pole Playhouse (7/31-8/16)
THE SHARK IS BROKEN in Central Pennsylvania THE SHARK IS BROKEN
Little Theatre of Mechanicsburg (3/19-4/04)
Golden Girls: The Laughs Continue in Central Pennsylvania Golden Girls: The Laughs Continue
Hershey Theatre (11/24-11/24)
THE DROWSY CHAPERONE in Central Pennsylvania THE DROWSY CHAPERONE
Little Theatre of Mechanicsburg (5/14-5/30)
Golden Girls The Laughs Continue in Central Pennsylvania Golden Girls The Laughs Continue
Hershey Theatre (11/24-11/24)
Disney Princess - the Concert - Venue Premium Tickets in Central Pennsylvania Disney Princess - the Concert - Venue Premium Tickets
York Barbican (4/09-4/09)
Trainspotting The Musical in Central Pennsylvania Trainspotting The Musical
Grand Opera House, York (11/09-11/14)
Clybourne Park in Central Pennsylvania Clybourne Park
DreamWrights Center for Community Arts (10/16-10/24)
SIX (Boleyn Tour) in Central Pennsylvania SIX (Boleyn Tour)
Hershey Theatre (6/18-6/20)