My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: ALL SHOOK UP at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre

Running through May 16! Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre’s production of ALL SHOOK UP delivers exactly what audiences want from an Elvis jukebox musical.

By:
Review: ALL SHOOK UP at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre

Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre’s production of ALL SHOOK UP delivers exactly what audiences want from an Elvis jukebox musical: energetic dance numbers, familiar hits, and a cast that throws itself fully into the fun. As Broadway Palm describes, "It’s Footloose, Grease and Happy Days all rolled into one zany story." While the show itself, to me, isn’t one of the stronger jukebox musicals structurally, this production succeeds because of the commitment and charisma of its performers.

The standout performance of the evening came from Ross Coughlin as Dennis. Coughlin brings excellent comedic timing, heart, and sincerity to the role, making Dennis one of the most genuinely lovable characters onstage. His scenes consistently landed with the audience and gave the show some of its strongest emotional moments.

Review: ALL SHOOK UP at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre Image

Another highlight was Zyana Cola as Lorraine, whose vocals and Stage Presence brought warmth and confidence to every scene. Her chemistry with Chris Graham as Dean Hyde was especially charming, and together they created one of the production’s most engaging storylines. Graham gave Dean an appealing sweetness that made his transformation throughout the show enjoyable to watch.

Leading the production are Darcy Reimler as Natalie, the town mechanic, and Austin Wicke as Chad, a new rebellious guy who has just rolled into town. Natalie instantly falls for Chad, but Chad has eyes for Miss Sandra (Ellie O'Hara). Reimler handles Natalie’s journey well and delivers strong vocals throughout the evening, while Wicke fully embraces Chad’s swagger and rock-and-roll energy. Their performances keep the production moving smoothly through some of the show’s thinner plot points.

Director and choreographer Amy Marie McCleary, alongside associate director/choreographer Jelani Bell, keeps the production lively and visually entertaining. The choreography is easily one of the strongest elements of the show, capturing the playful spirit and nonstop momentum that an Elvis-inspired musical needs. The ensemble remains energetic throughout and helps maintain the production’s upbeat atmosphere.

At the end of the day, ALL SHOOK UP may not have the strongest book, but Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre has assembled a talented cast and creative team that make it an entertaining night of theatre filled with strong performances and crowd-pleasing musical numbers. 

To learn more and get tickets, follow the link below - hurry, the show ends May 16!



Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best New Musical - Top 3
1. The Lost Boys
39.6% of votes
2. Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
25.1% of votes
3. Schmigadoon!
22.2% of votes

Need more Ft. Myers/Naples Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Velvet Curtain the Musical  in Ft. Myers/Naples Velvet Curtain the Musical
Arts Bonita (5/31-5/31)
Same Time, Next Year in Ft. Myers/Naples Same Time, Next Year
Players Circle Theater (5/22-6/07)
Comedian Erica Rhodes Live In Naples, Florida! in Ft. Myers/Naples Comedian Erica Rhodes Live In Naples, Florida!
Off The Hook Comedy Club (5/15-5/17)
Josephine: A Burlesque Cabaret Dream Play in Ft. Myers/Naples Josephine: A Burlesque Cabaret Dream Play
Theatre Conspiracy (5/31-5/31)
Constellations in Ft. Myers/Naples Constellations
The Naples Players (3/31-5/02)
Les Miserables in Ft. Myers/Naples Les Miserables
The Naples Players (7/24-8/26)
Anatomica! A Comedy about Meat, Bones, & The Skin You're In! in Ft. Myers/Naples Anatomica! A Comedy about Meat, Bones, & The Skin You're In!
Theatre Conspiracy (5/29-5/31)
Winnie the Pooh KIDS in Ft. Myers/Naples Winnie the Pooh KIDS
The Belle Theatre (5/15-5/16)
A Young Man Dressed as a Gorilla Dressed As An Old Man Sits Rocking In a Rocking Chair for 56 Minutes and Then Leaves in Ft. Myers/Naples A Young Man Dressed as a Gorilla Dressed As An Old Man Sits Rocking In a Rocking Chair for 56 Minutes and Then Leaves
Theatre Conspiracy (5/30-5/30)
Elektra - Fort Myers Teen Fringe in Ft. Myers/Naples Elektra - Fort Myers Teen Fringe
Theatre Conspiracy (5/30-5/30)