Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Photo Flash: THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG Kicks Off Holiday Season with Pie From Master Baker Ellen Gray

Nationally acclaimed pie maven Ellen Gray knows a thing or two about pies, and she shares that knowledge and expertise from the helm of one of New Jersey's most popular bakeries, while also teaching, blogging and more on "No More Mr. Nice Pie." As someone always seeking to share the comfort of the perfect pie, on Wednesday, November 15, 2017, Ellen delivered an assortment of all the right pies to the cast and crew of Broadway's The Play That Goes Wrong, at the Lyceum Theatre in Manhattan (149 W. 45th St., New York, NY).

"The manager of the Lyceum Theatre, Heidi Giovine, is a friend of mine who is constantly doing kind things for others," comments Ellen Gray. "I wanted to do something to express my thanks, and to show my support for the rigors of helping to stage eight shows a week. Also, this is one of my favorite shows-the perfect cure for whatever ails you. It's not star-driven, it is a true ensemble. How refreshing is that?" To help provide a little sunshine, Ellen offered to bring some pre-Thanksgiving pie cheer between the matinee and evening performance this week, and the answer was a resounding yes!

Ellen then brought an assortment of pies to the cast and crew of The Play That Goes Wrong at the Lyceum Theatre, between the matinee and evening performance on Wednesday. The Play That Goes Wrong was written by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, directed by Mark Bell, and with Original Music by Rob Falconer. Ellen's pie recipients included the show's cast (Ashley Bryant, Clifton Duncan, Mark Evans, Jonathan Fielding, Amelia McClain, Harrison Unger, Akron Watson, Preston Boyd, Ned Noyes, Ashley Reyes, and Katie Sexton), as well as its crew and front of house staff, including Matty DiCarlo (PSM), Mike Taustine (Box), Rhianna Bryceland (Box), Shari Teitlebaum (Box), Mark Diaz (House Carp), Paul Davila (House Elec), and Leah Nelson (House Props).

To treat the whole company and its 45 members, Ellen baked up half a dozen delicious homemade pies. In keeping with the theme of The Play That Goes Wrong, she baked a few mouthwatering traditional Fall seasonal pies (Apple and Tipsy Pumpkin), along with a few other delicate and delicious combinations including Wild Nut and Rhubarb/Cherry. "There's something terribly wrong about rhubarb and cherries in November," admits Ellen. "But there was also something refreshing about a touch of spring in autumn. It also helps that I came across some fresh rhubarb this week at a local farmers market!"

The Play That Goes Wrong was the perfect choice as recipient for Ellen's pie-delivery, since for Ellen, the hilarious comedy perfectly mirrors Thanksgiving week in the bakery! In The Play That Goes Wrong, the 'Cornley Polytechnic Drama Society' struggles amidst a series of near-derailments to present their 1920s murder mystery to an eager audience. Meanwhile, "in the bakery, we are challenged with unforeseen and unplanned obstacles as well, even as we forge ahead to meet our Thanksgiving deadlines!" Ellen points out. "Work in a bakery is often strenuous and extremely deadline-driven. Luckily, The Play That Goes Wrong provides an escape, through laughter, from reality and everyday stress! And, much like the company in The Play That Goes Wrong, we are an ensemble in the kitchen, constantly taking our cues from each other."

Ellen's pie delivery to The Play That Goes Wrong wasn't her first Broadway pie delivery. In 2016, she also provided pies to the cast of Hamilton on March 14, 2016, on "Pi Day" when Lin-Manuel Miranda was still performing with the show. She delivered a baker's dozen of pies to the Hamilton company, in celebration of both Pi Day and the anniversary of March 14, 1776, when Alexander Hamilton was appointed captain of the 1st battalion, 5th Field Artillery Unit of the United States Army. (As a bit of trivia, this unit is the oldest still existing today, and the only one remaining from the Revolution.)

"I have always tried to squeeze in a donation of pies to a food bank or charity during the holiday season," adds Ellen. "It's a tiny gesture but it forces me to stop and think about the world outside the bakery. My passion for pie baking is driven by a passion for sharing. It is incredibly rewarding to reach out, beyond the retail-driven work environment. I always think of pie baking as a relatively humble skill-I'm not doing anything remarkable, but it is extremely gratifying."

For Ellen's next outreach to the Broadway community, she is hoping to make a donation to Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS as well, hopefully during the Christmas season, and is also currently looking for the opportunity to further contribute to a suitable soup kitchen within the arts community, in addition.

About Pie Expert Ellen Gray:

Ellen Gray knows a thing or two about pies, as she commands confectionary perfection from the helm of one of New Jersey's most popular bakeries. Today, even as the holidays approach, Ellen's pies are flying out the door faster than ever before. But she's not just baking. She also teaches baking and pie-making classes, creates new recipes, and continues to post tips, travelogues, recipes, and seasonal Pie-kus on her popular blog, "No More Mr. Nice Pie" (http://www.nomoremrnicepie.com).

Photos courtesy of THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG

high res photos

Photo Flash: THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG Kicks Off Holiday Season with Pie From Master Baker Ellen Gray
Pies for the cast and crew of the show!

Photo Flash: THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG Kicks Off Holiday Season with Pie From Master Baker Ellen Gray
The Pie That Went Right for The Play That Goes Wrong

Photo Flash: THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG Kicks Off Holiday Season with Pie From Master Baker Ellen Gray
ElLen Gray, pie expert; Photo credit: Francesco Sapienza


BroadwayWorld Shop
Shop BroadwayWorld

Shop this season's new musicals! Get dressed up for a night at the theatre, or just a night at home, with merch from some of Broadway's biggest hits including SOME LIKE IT HOT, KIMBERLY AKIMBO, and more!

Start Shopping



Related Stories
Listen: THE BIG ONE-OH! Cast Recording Now Available Digitally Photo
Listen to the Ultimate Cast Recording of The Big One-Oh featuring Christian Borle, Derek Klena and more!

MEAN GIRLS Songs Have Been Reinvented For Movie Musical Photo
Jeff Richmond has given an update on the upcoming film adaption of Mean Girls the musical. Richmond stated that he and his wife, Tina Fey, are working 'day-to-day' on the new movie musical, revealing that the music has been 'reinvented' for the big screen. The film stars Angourie Rice, Auli'i Cravalho, Jaquel Spivey and Reneé Rapp.

Check Out This Weeks Top Stage Mags Photo
Take a look at this week's top Stage Mags including productions from Capital Stage, Gaslight Theatre, and more.

DEAR EVAN HANSEN National Tour to End its Run This Summer Photo
The North American Tour of Dear Evan Hansen, which first launched at the Buell Theatre in Denver, Colorado in October 2018, will end its run on July 2nd, 2023 at the Koger Center in Columbia, South Carolina. See how to purchase tickes!


More Hot Stories For You


Listen: THE BIG ONE-OH! Cast Recording Featuring Christian Borle, Derek Klena & More Now Available DigitallyListen: THE BIG ONE-OH! Cast Recording Featuring Christian Borle, Derek Klena & More Now Available Digitally
January 27, 2023

Listen to the Ultimate Cast Recording of The Big One-Oh featuring Christian Borle, Derek Klena and more!

DEAR EVAN HANSEN National Tour to End its Run This SummerDEAR EVAN HANSEN National Tour to End its Run This Summer
January 27, 2023

The North American Tour of Dear Evan Hansen, which first launched at the Buell Theatre in Denver, Colorado in October 2018, will end its run on July 2nd, 2023 at the Koger Center in Columbia, South Carolina. See how to purchase tickes!

66th Annual Obie Awards to Return Live and in Person in February66th Annual Obie Awards to Return Live and in Person in February
January 27, 2023

The 66th Annual Obie Awards, celebrating and honoring Off- and Off-Off-Broadway will take place on Monday, February 27, 2023 at Terminal 5.

Alyssa Fox to Take Over as Elphaba in WICKED Beginning in MarchAlyssa Fox to Take Over as Elphaba in WICKED Beginning in March
January 27, 2023

Alyssa Fox will take over the role of Elphaba in WICKED at Broadway’s Gershwin Theatre beginning Tuesday, March 7th. See how to purchase tickets!

Alan Cumming Returns OBE, Citing 'Toxicity' in the British EmpireAlan Cumming Returns OBE, Citing 'Toxicity' in the British Empire
January 27, 2023

Alan Cumming has taken to Instagram to reveal that he has returned his OBE, due to his feelings about the 'toxicity' of the British Empire.