"Make Your Own Tony" Cookie Contest - have round sugar cookies with a teal colored icing, and buy black or dark blue mini gel icing tubes and have everyone decorate the cookie to look like the Tony medallion.
This blog post has some pun-filled suggestions, if you're into that kind of thing (although not all of them sound particularly enjoyable and/or practical for a Tonys party).
If anyone ever tells you that you put too much Parmesan cheese on your pasta, stop talking to them. You don't need that kind of negativity in your life.
Whenever I have a party, I always make my own cocktail franks rather than buying them because its cheaper. So for my Tony party this year, I will be baking two hot dogs stuck together by the dough, to emulate the twins from SIDE SHOW (even though its not nominated).
You can do all sorts of stuff from American Psycho: replicate all the ridiculous-sounding dishes from Dorsia; do something with beet juice or blood sausage.
Pies for Waitress, of course.
"Roast chicken and new potatoes" for Spring Awakening. :)
Bonus: Tacos in honor of the Taco Tuesday that doesn't happen in Dear Evan Hansen.
"This thread reads like a series of White House memos." — Mister Matt