How long do you think Book of Mormon is going to run on Broadway? This is going on its 4th year and it's still a major hit. Do you think it will go as long as Wicked or Beauty & the Beast?
Happy to toss into the ring a 10 year plus broadway run prediction for Book of Mormon.
Why?
*Funniest book for a musical ever written IMO *The songs in this show are really really strong and memorable, especially in the first act, and has great showstoppers at end of the first and second act. *It does not need a "star" to carry the show...when you deliver a great funny short fat elder cunningham and a strong singing acting elder price with good chemistry, this show works fantastically (ive seen six different combos of actors, and they were all really great) *It's the most Tony award winning show still on broadway and falls into the must see category for many tourists now and is still a difficult ticket to get unless you plan ahead (running grosses at 115% of revenue capacity) *Its a bit controversial and edgy and will continue to attract teens and young adults who are less religious now than any time in history *Broad appeal to both sexes, all age ranges(above about 11 or 12 unless you were raised in a convert) and very entertaining to both serious musical goers and novices its easily accessible as a musical vs. Les Mis or Rent etc. *It is a great repeat show to see and I know lots of musical fans who go see this over and over with different casts(much like the wicked, phantom, and jersey boy hard core fan bases) *the theatre is relatively small 1102 capacity vs wicked and phantom at 2000 seat capacity * A Romney run in 2016 will fuel more curiousity about mormons for the next three years or longer *its currently running in NY, London and two concurrent national tours, the only musical in the last fifteen years thats demostrated that much consumer demand is Wicked, which as passed the 10 year mark with no sign of slowing here are the shows that have run ten plus years: POTO Chicago Cats Lion king Oh Calcutta Les Mis A Chorus Line Mamma Mia beauty and the beast Rent Wicked Miss Saigon Jersey Boys
I've seen most of these shows multiple times, and book of mormon is one of the few on this list I enjoyed as much the second or third time as the first..
I personally rank it first on this list as the best overall musical, and beleive many others do too if you strip out personal biases. In fairness I never saw the Rent OBC and if I had, might have ranked it first, although rent drags in some places and I dont love all the songs, where mormon really moves along and I either enjoy or love all the songs...
Some of the shows on the list baffle me that they ran/ have run so long, but viva la difference Cats lion king oh calcutta miss saigon
shows that will or COULD do 20 years plus on broadway IMO: POTO-done Chicago-may happen in nov 2016 if they producers want to break the 20 year mark, grosses have been at 44-45% for a while in an 1100 person theatre Lion king- will make it no problem Wicked-will make it no problem Book of mormon-can possibly make it
why? mass appeal timeless nature of the stort and "feel" of shows(none of them seem outdated) doesnt necessarily make them a "great show" just a very profitable one and very unique when you think of all the fantastic musicals that lasted one season to 2 years....
i would still watch and enjoy a new york or london cast of any of these shows except lion king 10 years from now....
Heck, I'wd be surprised if it DIDNT make ten years.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
I want to say it would have run similar to the producers or avenue q.
In our millions, in our billions, we are most powerful when we stand together. TW4C unwaveringly joins the worldwide masses, for we know our liberation is inseparably bound.
Signed,
Theater Workers for a Ceasefire
https://theaterworkersforaceasefire.com/statement
It is interesting that the biggest, most profitable shows have no stars in them: Mormon, Wicked, Lion King, Phantom, Chicago (ok, current stars, heh), etc.
hey there-nice to see some interest in this topic of book of mormon run and the broader question: I mean why do some shows run 10 or 20 years???
to answer one poster, I did see a proshot film of the oh calcutta broadway cast, its always hard to put yourself back in the period something was popular....all i can say is as someone whos seen 100+ musicals live, 100 or so more on film, and own and listened to a few hundred soundtracks, oh calcutta didnt have much of a story and the songs were not memorable. A test of this is how many times has it been revived on broadway..none since the 70s revival...so it seems it was a period piece oddity of a bunch of people running around on stage naked simulating sex acts...
I was amazed by Lion King the first time i saw it on broadway in 1998 and anyone who loves musicals should see it at least once just for the incredibly imaginative costumes and a few standout songs...subsequent viewings it just didnt hold up for me.
Cats I loved Memory and enjoyed one or two other songs, the chopped together mini stories just didnt connect or hold my interest. I have friends I respect that LOVE this show ...maybe im just more of a dog person
Miss Saigon I really tried hard to love and also have friends that LOVE this show...didnt see the obc which is almost always the best and most invigorated cast, but just couldnt fall in love with most of the songs... Yes its my opinion,, and yes there is also a lot of support from a lot of respected critics that the shows above were overrated...how many musical experts or critics list cats, lion king oh calcutta or miss saigon in their top 10 favorite musicals?? -none ive ever seen....
Coming back to Book of Mormon, it's about as close as you can get to a perfect musical in the 21st century where there are so many other options to be entertained...
I'll go see it in san francisco in April for my 7th time, enjoy the nuances each different actor brings to the role, and delight in all my favorite songs: Hello Two By Two You and Me Hasa Dega Ebawai turn it off sal tay ka siti Man up I believe I am africa making things up again spooky mormon tomorrow is a latter day
I mean how many musicals do you get to see where you have twelve favorite songs??????
thank you thank you thank you to Matt, Trey and Robert Lopez...... may Book of Mormon have a happy 10th birthday in 2021!
Add me to the list of people who are utterly baffled.
It's an ok show. But not earth shattering by any means. South Park BLU was a brilliant movie musical. The songs in it are very strong. I don't think the score of BOM is close to being as good. No real memorable songs.
I saw it in May of 2011 with the original cast too. Alls I can do is shrug on this one.