My Current Broadway Ratings...Please Post Yours (Updated)- Page 3

[Call_me_jorge]

Posted: 3/19/17 at 3:11pm

My ratings are based mostly on tours and out of town tryouts in Chicago.

Beautiful- C+

Hamilton- A+(especially the first time I saw it with Joshua and Joseph in the leading roles)

Kinky Boots- C

The Book of Mormon- A(especially with Ben Platt)

The Lion King- B

The Phantom of the Opera- C(Based on the reimagined tour)

War Paint- C

Wicked- B

[muscle23ftl]

Posted: 3/19/17 at 11:58pm

I'm not trash...have you ever seen these shows you are talking about? I can give you more details, but you wanna know what's trashy? Name-calling on a website...that's trashy :)

Updated On: 3/20/17 at 11:58 PM

Posted: 3/20/17 at 12:08am

Aladdin - C+

Beautiful - B-

Chicago - C-

Hamilton - A

Kinky Boots - B-

Great Comet - A-

On Your Feet - B

School of Rock - B

Sunday in the Park with George - A-

The Book of Mormon - B+

Waitress - B+

War Paint - C for the show, A for the stars

Wicked - B

[yankeefan7]

Posted: 3/20/17 at 9:26am

-Aladdin B

-Beautiful B-

-Book of Mormon A

-Cats A (original)

-Chicago A- (original)

--Kinky Boots B+

-Lion King B+

-Miss Saigon A (original)
 
-Phantom of the Opera A

-School of Rock B

-Wicked A-

Updated On: 3/20/17 at 09:26 AM

[Jimmyb1969]

Posted: 3/20/17 at 12:34pm

--Dear Evan Hansen A+

--Hamilton A+

--Miss Saigon A

--The Play that Goes Wrong C-/D+

--War Paint C-

--Hello Dolly A

--Aladdin B+ 

--Beautiful B

--Cats  B+

--Chicago  B+ (A when it opened)

--Kinky Boots C 

--Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet  C for the show  (A for the set design)

--School of Rock  A

--Sunday in the Park with George  B

--Sunset Boulevard A+

--Waitress B

--The Present C

--Wicked A

 

[muscle23ftl]

Posted: 3/22/17 at 12:26am

Guys, don't miss Sunset BLVD.

[After Eight]

Posted: 3/22/17 at 12:37am

I've seen a few more, so I've added them to my list.


-Aladdin B-

-Amélie D-

-Beautiful C

-Book of Mormon F

-Bronx Tale C-

-Cats B

-Chicago A-

-Come From Away D-

-Dear Evan Hansen C-

-Groundhog Day F

-Hamilton F

-Hello, Dolly! A

-In Transit C-

-Kinky Boots C

-Lion King B

-Miss Saigon C-

-Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet D

-On Your Feet C-

-Paramour B-

-Phantom of the Opera B-

-School of Rock D-

-Sunday in the Park with George F

-Sunset Boulevard B-

-Waitress F

- War Paint B+

-Wicked D-

[muscle23ftl]

Posted: 3/22/17 at 12:46pm

You're even tougher than me! Haha.

[muscle23ftl]

Posted: 3/22/17 at 9:57pm

I'm adding Bronx Tale...zzzzzzzzzzzz

[ACL2006]

Posted: 3/22/17 at 10:06pm

Aladdin: B

Bandstand: D (Papermill production)

Beautiful: A-

The Book of Mormon(5 times): A+

Cats: D

Chicago(5 times): varies: B+ to a D

Come From Away(twice): A+

Kinky Boots: A-

The Lion King: A

The Great Comet: B-

On Your Feet: D

Phantom(twice): C+

Wicked: A-

[green waver]

Posted: 3/24/17 at 8:29am

You've gotta love a thread where Book of Mormon gets an F and an A+ on consecutive posts.

[muscle23ftl]

Posted: 3/26/17 at 11:30am

I would have to say that if The New Yorkers were a Broadway show I'd give it a B+

[broadwaygirl10]

Posted: 3/26/17 at 11:57am

Aladdin B+
Beautiful A-
Cats C+
Chicago A

Hamilton B-
Kinky Boots A-
-Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet A++
On Your Feet A- 
-School of Rock B
-Sunday in the Park with George A+
Sunset Boulevard A-
Waitress A- (A+ for jessie tho) 
Wicked A-

[TerrenceIsTheMann]

Posted: 3/26/17 at 8:59pm

Aladdin D-

-Amélie F

-Beautiful D+

-Book of Mormon C

-Bronx Tale F

-Cats C

-Chicago C

-Come From Away B+

-Dear Evan Hansen A+

-The Glass Menagerie- C

-Groundhog Day D

-Hamilton A+

-Hello, Dolly! A

-In Transit D-

-Kinky Boots C

-Lion King B+

-Miss Saigon B

-Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet A

-On Your Feet D-

-Paramour D

-Phantom of the Opera C+

-School of Rock D-

-Sunday in the Park with George A-

-Sunset Boulevard B+

-Waitress B


- War Paint D-

-Wicked B-

Updated On: 3/26/17 at 08:59 PM

[TheSassySam]

Posted: 3/26/17 at 9:34pm

Woohoo! I get to add the 12 shows I saw this past week and a half. Thank you all for your suggestions. I visited with my seat neighbors before the show and I couldn't help but think I may have spoken to a few of you! It was great to indulge in an art we all appreciate. 

 

Anastasia - C-

Beautiful - B- 

Cats - C

Chicago - B

Come From Away - A

Dear Evan Hansen - A+

Groundhog Day - D+

Hamilton - A

Hello Dolly - A+

Kinky Boots - B-

Miss Saigon - B+

Great Comet - B
 
On Your Feet - C-

Oslo - B-

School of Rock - B

Sunday in the Park with George - A-

Sunset Boulevard - A

The Book of Mormon - A

The Glass Menagerie - B+

The Lion King - B

The Phantom of the Opera - C+

Waitress - C-

War Paint - B-

Wicked - B

Updated On: 3/26/17 at 09:34 PM

[muscle23ftl]

Posted: 3/28/17 at 3:43am

TheSassySam said: "Woohoo! I get to add the 12 shows I saw this past week and a half. Thank you all for your suggestions. I visited with my seat neighbors before the show and I couldn't help but think I may have spoken to a few of you! It was great to indulge in an art we all appreciate. 

 

Anastasia - C-

Beautiful - B- 

Cats - C

Chicago - B

Come From Away - A

Dear Evan Hansen - A+

Groundhog Day - D+

Hamilton - A

Hello Dolly - A+

Kinky Boots - B-

Miss Saigon - B+

Great Comet - B
 
On Your Feet - C-

Oslo - B-

School of Rock - B

Sunday in the Park with George - A-

Sunset Boulevard - A

The Book of Mormon - A

The Glass Menagerie - B+

The Lion King - B

The Phantom of the Opera - C+

Waitress - C-

War Paint - B-

Wicked - B

 

12 shows in a week and a half?! Wow...that's great. Were you visiting?

 

[The Other One]

Posted: 4/14/17 at 6:07pm

Wicked: B

The Price: B

The Phantom of the Opera: B

The Book of Mormon: A

Sunday In The Park With George: A

Oslo: A-

Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812: B+

Kinky Boots: B

Hamilton: A++

A Doll's House Part 2: A

Sweat: A

Indecent: B

Present Laughter: A

 

Updated On: 7/16/17 at 06:07 PM

[akmiller_98]

Posted: 4/14/17 at 6:35pm

Hamilton A+

Dear Evan Hansen A+

Waitress A

Book of Mormon A

Significant Other A

Beautiful A

Sweat B

On Your Feet B-

Hello Dolly B-

kinky Boots B-

Chicago C

Lion King C

In Transit C-

Cats D

Sunset Blvd D

Present Laughter F

 

Updated On: 4/14/17 at 06:35 PM

[ZellMorrowsPledge]

Posted: 4/14/17 at 6:53pm

Aladdin C+

Cats C

Groundhog Day A-

Kinky Boots B+

The Lion King A-

Phantom Of The Opera A-

School Of Rock B-

Waitress C+

Wicked A+

 

 

[Mike66]

Posted: 4/14/17 at 7:22pm

just the ones I've seen...

-Book of Mormon A, but with original cast

-Chicago A, but years ago, with original revival cast
 

-Kinky Boots B

-Lion King A, but years ago, with original cast

-Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet F

-On Your Feet D

-Phantom of the Opera A, with original cast

-Sunday in the Park with George A, with original cast

-Sunset Boulevard A

-Waitress B+

-Wicked A, with original cast

 

----

The New Yorkers (Encores) B+

 

"

 

[mmFan]

Posted: 4/14/17 at 8:08pm

Can only respond to some in the list, but fun thread...


- Book of Mormon A  (saw OBC)

- Cats C+ (not on Broadway)

- Chicago B

- Lion King B (not on Broadway)

- Phantom of the Opera B+ (not on Broadway)

- Waitress B+ (saw OBC)

- Wicked A+

[muscle23ftl]

Posted: 4/14/17 at 10:45pm

Mike66 said: "just the ones I've seen...

-Book of Mormon A, but with original cast

-Chicago A, but years ago, with original revival cast
 

-Kinky Boots B

-Lion King A, but years ago, with original cast

-Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet F

-On Your Feet D

-Phantom of the Opera A, with original cast

-Sunday in the Park with George A, with original cast

-Sunset Boulevard A

-Waitress B+

-Wicked A, with original cast

 

----

The New Yorkers (Encores) B+

 

Nice!!!
 

 

"

 

[uncageg]

Posted: 4/15/17 at 1:18am

Come From Away - A

Miss Saigon - B

A Doll's House Part 2 - A+

War Paint - A-

Sweat - B

I would love to see a thread for off-Broadway shows. A lot out there. Two I liked this season were GENTLY DOWN THE STREAM and Church & State.

Seeing Bandstand next week.

 

[The Other One]

Posted: 4/15/17 at 5:51am

"I would love to see a thread for off-Broadway shows. A lot out there. Two I liked this season were GENTLY DOWN THE STREAM and Church & State."

Church & State is a solid B+.  For some reason, NY critics don't even seem to have reviewed it.

[bwayphreak234]

Posted: 4/15/17 at 10:10am

Reposting my list with new shows added... 

Aladdin C

Amelie D

Anastasia D

Bandstand C-

Beautiful D+

The Book of Mormon A-

A Bronx Tale D

Cats D

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory F

Chicago A

Come From Away B

Dear Evan Hansen A

The Glass Menagerie B+

Groundhog Day B

Hamilton A

Hello, Dolly! A+

In Transit F

Kinky Boots C+

The Lion King D

Miss Saigon B+

Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812 A+

On Your Feet! C

Oslo A

Phantom A-

School of Rock B

Significant Other A

Sunset Boulevard B-

Waitress C

War Paint B+

Wicked B+