
Review: AMERICA'S SEXIEST COUPLE at Best Medicine Rep
This production runs until January 29, 2023.
The 90's was one of the golden ages for sitcoms, dramas and comedies wrapped up into bit-size 30 minutes (including commercials). In America's Sexiest Couple, written by Ken Levine of Cheers fame, TV has changed, and so have Craig McAllister (John Morogiello) and Susan White (Kari Luther), who respectively played Jeff and Jill, a.k.a America's Sexiest Couple, on the dramedy Residents. After Residents, Susan and Craig go their separate ways, but they meet again in Syracuse, New York to attend the funeral of a castmate. Sparks fly as the two on-screen lovers reflect back on their careers and lives after their fame sizzled out. Best Medicine Rep's production of America's Sexiest Couple, directed by Kathleen Barth, explores the relationship between Susan and Craig, and how Residents impacted their lives.
Morgoiello and Luther definitely have on-stage chemistry. Craig and Susan argue, joke, and tease each other like they have known each other for years, which makes sense as they both have collaborated together on many projects together in real life. The tension is especially high when they discuss their former relationships with their spouses, and the ups and downs of acting.
Yes, there is sex in this play, and it is done rom-com style. Craig and Susan bumbling around in the dark together is funny. Kudos to the play's intimacy director, Emily Sucher, for the playful choreography and movement of this intimate and hilarious scene.

If two is a crowd, then three's company. Enter The Bellboy (Fletcher Love), a Millennial who doesn't know anything about The Residents. It's hilarious to watch Craig and Susan try to convince (and bribe) him to watch the show. Generational misunderstandings and "clashes" can make for good laughs, if done right, and the dynamic between this Millennial and two Boomers creates a great atmosphere for joke delivery.
In sitcoms, there are often episodes dedicated to serious topics, and America's Sexiest Couple brings up an extremely traumatic event, which impacts Susan's life significantly. However, the script doesn't treat Susan's trauma respectfully, and it becomes dismissive of her experience.
Despite the script's shortcomings, Best Medicine Rep's production of America's Sexiest Couple is a well-acted play.
Running Time: 1 hour and 30 minutes without an intermission
Photo credit & caption: Craig (John Morogiello) comforts Susan (Kari Luther) in Best Medicine Rep's production of America's Sexiest Couple. Photo by Mia Amado.
Trigger Warning: This production contains mature themes, including references to sexual violence.
America's Sexiest Couple runs until January 29, 2023 at the Lakeforest Mall in Gaithersburg, Maryland. Tickets are on sale here.
From This Author - Hannah Wing
Hannah Wing has an extensive background in editing and publishing. She has held positions ranging from literary magazine editor to web content manager. She has always had a soft spot for theatre an... (read more about this author)

March 3, 2023
STC's King Lear is fresh and breathtaking, and even funny. Yes, there is even humor in the tragedy.

February 27, 2023
If you're looking for a night of light-hearted comedy disguised as a noir, this is the show for you.

February 12, 2023
What did our critic think of SEVEN METHODS OF KILLING KYLIE JENNER at Woolly Mammoth Theatre?

January 18, 2023
So, should you attend the Jellicle Ball? Absolutely. Cats is one of those musicals that will stay with you, whether you see it for the first time or twentieth time. think of CATS at National Theatre?

January 17, 2023
Best Medicine Rep's production of America's Sexiest Couple, directed by Kathleen Barth, explores the relationship between Susan and Craig, and how Residents impacted their lives.