My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses

Matt Windman

418 reviews on BroadwayWorld  •  Average score: 6.76/10 Thumbs Sideways

Reviews by Matt Windman

7
Thumbs Sideways

‘John Lithgow: Stories By Heart’ review: The star’s solo Broadway show is a bit of a snooze

From: amNY  |  Date: 1/11/2018

As much as one can appreciate Lithgow's elated and elastic theatricality, generous and open spirit and passionate advocacy for the arts, it is not easy to fall in love with the show - or even sit through it without zoning out. Sitting to my right was a young girl who spent most of the show with her head down and eyes closed.

8
Thumbs Up

‘Farinelli and the King’ review: A ‘bromance’ tribute to power of music

From: amNY  |  Date: 12/17/2017

It may contain arias from obscure Baroque operas and candlelit chandeliers, but the play is, at heart, a straightforward and sentimental 'bromance,' one in which Farinelli is willing to give up adoring audiences all over Europe to serve at the king's command. It is also a celebration of the power of music to overcome emotional and mental instability. Rylance, who excels at playing sad and strange characters, gives a full-bodied and endearing performance that combines volatile behavior and over-the-top comedy with gentle contemplation. As it turns out, van Kampen, who also did the musical arrangements, and Rylance are married, so it's no wonder that 'Farinelli and the King' is so specifically suited to their talents.

The Children Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘The Children’ review: An absorbing, thought-provoking play from Lucy Kirkwood

From: amNY  |  Date: 12/12/2017

Black humor occasionally pops up, as do secrets from the past. At one point, the characters listen to James Brown's 'Ain't It Funky Now' and recreate a choreographed dance routine from 40 years earlier. But first and foremost, 'The Children' is a social drama that is disturbing and thought-provoking.

8
Thumbs Up

‘SpongeBob SquarePants’ review: Energetic cast brings party vibes to Broadway

From: amNY  |  Date: 12/4/2017

Despite some weak spots, the new Broadway musical adaptation of the Nickelodeon cartoon 'SpongeBob SquarePants' works well enough as a lively, silly, trippy show appealing to kids, Millennials and anyone who has watched the TV show since it premiered in 1999.

10
Thumbs Up

‘Once On This Island’ review: Gritty realism, superb cast captivate in fairy-tale musical’s revival

From: amNY  |  Date: 12/3/2017

There has probably never been a production quite like the stunning new Broadway revival at Circle in the Square. Emphasizing the musical's themes of natural disaster and economic inequality, director Michael Arden brings an unexpected dose of gritty realism, while also honoring its gorgeous score of dynamic group numbers and tender ballads. Vocal fireworks and full-bodied dance choreography imbue spirituality and joyful theatricality.

5
Thumbs Sideways

‘The Parisian Woman’ review: Uma Thurman is disappointing in Broadway debut

From: amNY  |  Date: 11/30/2017

Although the play revolves around heavy-handed plot machinations, it still manages to feel slight and slow. The characters are initially interesting but prove to be one-dimensional. The direction (by Pam MacKinnon) does little to pep up the production. One gets the sense that 'The Parisian Woman' was built specifically as a star vehicle to showcase the actress playing Chloe, to make her alluring and dominant while not demanding much in terms of acting.

Meteor Shower Broadway
3
Thumbs Down

‘Meteor Shower’ review: Amy Schumer and starry cast wasted on substandard script

From: amNY  |  Date: 11/29/2017

Unfortunately, 'Meteor Shower' (as directed by Jerry Zaks, who recently staged the 'Hello, Dolly!' revival) turned out to be a nonsensical and tedious skit that is simultaneously starry and substandard, flimsy and overstuffed. I'm even tempted to call it a 'trainwreck' (in a nod to Schumer's hit 2015 film).

6
Thumbs Sideways

‘Latin History for Morons’ review: John Leguizamo offers an impassioned but disjointed show

From: amNY  |  Date: 11/15/2017

The show (which runs about two hours without an intermission) is a tall order for Leguizamo to fill on his own, with overlapping tracks that include a slow and sentimental multicharacter family drama, stand-up comedy, personal confessions, history, political criticism and even an elaborate dance break. Although one can appreciate the sincerity behind Leguizamo's emphasis on his family, his long-winded attempt to dramatize conversations with his son, wife and daughter falls flat and weighs down the rest of the show, in which he interacts directly with the audience with flare, fervor and ease.

The Band's Visit Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

‘The Band’s Visit’ review: New musical based on Israeli film is a must-see on Broadway

From: amNY  |  Date: 11/9/2017

While there is little plot or character development, one by one the players open up in song and dialogue, revealing that they are suffering from emotional paralysis and the monotony of everyday life. The integration of David Cromer's intimate and sensitive direction; David Yazbek's Middle-Eastern flavored score, much of which is performed onstage by cast members; and Itamar Moses' book, which hews closely to the original screenplay, is so seamless that it is virtually impossible to pick apart. They have turned a slight, short, quiet tale into an urgent, realistic and relatable portrait of vulnerable individuals from different cultures who are able to make an unexpected human connection, often just through a shared appreciation for music.

Junk Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

‘Junk’ review: Solid cast, gripping story sell Ayad Akhtar’s latest at Lincoln Center Theater

From: amNY  |  Date: 11/2/2017

'Junk' marks a critical departure point for Akhtar, a Pakistani-American writer whose prior dramas involved Pakistani-Americans (the Pulitzer Prize-winning 'Disgraced,' 'The Who & The What') and an American kidnapped by a Pakistani terrorist ('The Invisible Hand'). Even while many of the characters are underdeveloped, the commentary on anti-Semitism feels tacked on and the industry lingo can throw off a layperson, 'Junk' is engrossing from start to finish and Doug Hughes' sleek, high-powered and fluid production (staged around a two-story set of empty squares and shining surfaces) never lags in momentum.

M. Butterfly Broadway
3
Thumbs Down

‘M. Butterfly’ review: A disastrous Broadway revival

From: amNY  |  Date: 10/26/2017

Hwang's 1988 Tony-winning play is a critical-minded drama dissecting race relations, gender roles and international affairs - and also a gripping thriller full of sex, spying and disguises. Its seriously misguided and marred Broadway revival contains direction by Taymor, lead performances from English actor Clive Owen ('Closer') and Jin Ha (Chicago cast of 'Hamilton') and extensive, unnecessary and mostly detrimental rewrites.

5
Thumbs Sideways

‘Time and the Conways’ review: ‘Downton Abbey’ cast member can’t save this dull production

From: amNY  |  Date: 10/10/2017

Except for a handful of striking moments, the play comes off as a boring mishmash of Chekhov's 'The Cherry Orchard,' Sondheim's 'Merrily We Roll Along' and, of course, 'Downton Abbey.' Perhaps it would work better with an all-English cast that possesses ensemble unity. Here, the performances are uneven - and so are the accents.

8
Thumbs Up

‘Prince of Broadway’ review: Lavish revue of Hal Prince is enjoyable, but how about something new?

From: amNY  |  Date: 8/24/2017

'Prince of Broadway,' the lavish, unwieldy, mostly enjoyable revue celebrating Prince's long and unparalleled career of presenting daring new musicals (usually based on difficult subject matter and incorporating strong visual concepts), has finally opened on Broadway after many stops and starts, and I'm 'sorry-grateful' to see it there.

8
Thumbs Up

‘Terms of My Surrender’ review: Michael Moore's Trump-targeted play offers freewheeling night of theater

From: amNY  |  Date: 8/10/2017

In any event, the show (which runs just under two hours, without intermission) is a fun and freewheeling night of theater for Moore's fans and anyone else who wants to attend.

Marvin's Room Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

‘Marvin’s Room’ review: Lili Taylor, Janeane Garofalo in emotional, funny but uneven premiere

From: Newsday  |  Date: 6/29/2017

A cute sense of humor pops up throughout the play, such as when Ruth dresses up for a special episode of her favorite television soap opera, Lee shamelessly dumps a tray of candy into her purse while touring a nursing home and Bessie is rescued at Disney World by a costumed cartoon character. Staging the play is deceptively difficult, as its slow pace and confessional mini-monologues can easily become tedious, and that is often the case with this production (directed by Anne Kauffman, who has extensive Off-Broadway credits). Laura Jellinek's misconceived set design is overly expansive (with the actors frequently far away from each other) and elaborate (requiring the assistance of visible stagehands) and yet still incomplete (with a backyard scene performed around the kitchen).

1984 Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

‘1984’ review: Olivia Wilde and Tom Sturridge shine in exciting, unpredictable dystopian play

From: amNY  |  Date: 6/22/2017

Running about 101 minutes (in a nod to 'room 101,' the novel's chamber of horrors), this visceral and unpredictable staging is more exciting and effective than this summer's other politically-oriented productions (including Robert Schenkkan's prison drama 'Building the Wall' and The Public Theater's uneasily Trump-infused 'Julius Caesar').

7
Thumbs Sideways

‘A Doll’s House, Part 2’ review: Skip unless you’re an Ibsen fan

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/27/2017

It's apparently never too late to create a sequel - even to a Norwegian domestic drama written more than a century ago. Lucas Hnath, who had two of his plays ('The Christians,' 'Red Speedo') produced last year by major off-Broadway companies to great acclaim, now makes his Broadway debut with the lightweight but feisty comedy 'A Doll's House, Part 2.' This marks the play's New York debut following a world premiere just last month on the West Coast.

Bandstand Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

‘Bandstand’ review: A superb new Broadway musical from ‘Hamilton’ choreographer

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/26/2017

It would have been easy to simply plug in 1940s pop standards. But instead Richard Oberacker and Robert Taylor created a swinging original score that not only captures the period style but also digs deep into the characters. The music is so tightly integrated into the script that 'Bandstand' becomes unusually powerful musical theater. Its reinterpretation of the traditional 11 o'clock number is both smart and electrifying. Andy Blankenbuehler, who rose to prominence as the choreographer of 'In the Heights' and then 'Hamilton,' does a stunning job as both director and choreographer.

9
Thumbs Up

‘Six Degrees of Separation’ review: Solid cast shines in terrific Broadway revival

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/25/2017

Any doubt that John Guare's 1990 sharp-edged comedic drama 'Six Degrees of Separation' is one of the finest contemporary American plays should be put to rest by the terrific new Broadway revival starring Allison Janney ('The West Wing'), John Benjamin Hickey ('The Normal Heart') and Corey Hawkins ('Straight Outta Compton'). The play (which was adapted into a 1993 film with Will Smith) popularized the idea that everyone in the world is connected by just a handful of people (i.e. 'Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon'). But it also displays a class-based society, where an Upper East Side penthouse is a world away from a homeless youth sleeping in Central Park - though not necessarily impenetrable.

Anastasia Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘Anastasia’ review: Christy Altomare is smashing in Broadway’s musical adaptation

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/24/2017

Combine early 20th-century Russian history with bits and pieces of 'Les Miz,' 'My Fair Lady' and 'Newsies,' and you've got 'Anastasia,' the uneven but well-meaning and mostly pleasant new Broadway musical based on the 1997 animated film of the same title from 20th Century Fox.

Thumbs Down

‘Charlie and the Chocolate Factory’ review: A fudged disaster of a musical

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/23/2017

Pity the poor Oompa Loompas that get assigned by Willy Wonka with the impossible task of cleaning up the disastrous and distasteful Broadway musical adaptation of 'Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.' No amount of 'Pure Imagination' can save this train wreck.

Hello, Dolly! Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

‘Hello, Dolly!’ review: Bette Midler shines in this glorious Broadway revival

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/20/2017

With her broad and brassy comic personality, star presence and underlying tenderness, Midler is ideal to inherit the sacred mantle of Dolly Gallagher Levi from actress Carol Channing, who starred in the original 1964 production and played the role for decades...The production (directed by Jerry Zaks and choreographed by Warren Carlyle) lovingly recreates the look and feel of Gower Champion's iconic 1964 production, bursting at the seams with old-fashioned showmanship, hyperkinetic energy and stylized movement.

The Little Foxes Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘The Little Foxes’ review: Cynthia Nixon and Laura Linney shine in unapologetic melodrama

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/19/2017

You can learn the dates that Linney and Nixon will be playing each role in advance. Linney and Nixon are better suited to playing Regina and Birdie, respectively, but the show is fine either way, and checking out both casting arrangements makes you appreciate their versatility. The fullest performance actually comes from Thomas as Regina's sick and wheelchair-bound husband, who switches off between gentility and heated fervor as he attempts to outsmart his wife. Meanwhile, McKean and Goldstein play it up as Regina's similarly aggressive and greedy brothers.

Oslo Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘Oslo’ review: Diplomacy takes center stage in J.T. Rogers’ well-crafted play

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/13/2017

International diplomacy isn't easy - especially when it involves getting two warring populations to make hard concessions - and neither is 'Oslo,' J.T. Rogers' three-hour ensemble drama depicting the back-and-forth backroom negotiations leading up to the 1993 Oslo Peace Accords between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization. The play is long and talky and jam-packed with names, dates and historical exposition, but also well-crafted and nuanced, with interesting characters and even humor every now and then. The subject matter is also increasingly vital at this time of heightened instability throughout the Middle East. Under the direction of Bartlett Sher, it is presented with as much clarity and personality as possible.

War Paint Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘War Paint’ review: LuPone and Ebersole shine in smart, rousing musical

From: amNY  |  Date: 4/6/2017

'War Paint' still has a lot going for it, including self-empowered protagonists, high-powered performances, well-crafted period-style songs, the classy aura of old-school New York and the smooth direction of Michael Greif (who staged 'Dear Evan Hansen' earlier this season). It ought to be a hit with Broadway's primary ticket-buying demographic: women from the tristate area who use cosmetic products, are familiar with Rubinstein and Arden's important legacies and know that LuPone and Ebersole are musical theater artists of the highest caliber.

Videos