Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Johnny Oleksinski — Theater Critic

New York Post, The New York Post, NY Post

Reviews on BroadwayWorld
106
Average score
6.47 / 10
Most recent review
8/25/2026
Thumbs Sideways

Reviews by Johnny Oleksinski

Six Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘Six’ finally opens on Broadway — and it’s a royal good time

From: New York Post  |  Date: 10/3/2021

'Six' is more of a concert than a traditional book musical, though, with nine numbers and a megamix crammed into a quick 80 minutes. The songs here, by Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss, are all whip-smart and catchy. With jukebox shows proliferating like rabbits, audiences are getting used to hearing modern music onstage, but 'Six' is one of the few original musicals in memory whose score is radio-ready.

Six Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘Six’ finally opens on Broadway — and it’s a royal good time

From: New York Post  |  Date: 10/3/2021

'Six' is more of a concert than a traditional book musical, though, with nine numbers and a megamix crammed into a quick 80 minutes. The songs here, by Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss, are all whip-smart and catchy. With jukebox shows proliferating like rabbits, audiences are getting used to hearing modern music onstage, but 'Six' is one of the few original musicals in memory whose score is radio-ready.

Pass Over Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

‘Pass Over’ Broadway review: An enticing, uneven play

From: New York Post  |  Date: 8/22/2021

Hill and Smallwood have a lively rapport that makes us believe they really have been with each other constantly for a thousand years. Hill, in particular, reveals both sweetness and immense passion. The dance-like movement director Dayna Taymor gives the pair perfectly suits Nwandu's musical text.

9
Thumbs Up

Bruce Springsteen reopens Broadway — and opens up about his DWI

From: New York Post  |  Date: 6/27/2021

For a consummate performer like Springsteen, the deeply personal show was routine, but damn was it inspiring for me and the rest of the audience. On Saturday, we learned that tourists are back. Everytime Springsteen mentioned a town - San Francisco, Phoenix, Asbury Park - there were loud cheers from people who live there. He had to tell the out-of-towners to 'shut the f-k up.'

9
Thumbs Up

Bruce Springsteen reopens Broadway — and opens up about his DWI

From: New York Post  |  Date: 6/27/2021

For a consummate performer like Springsteen, the deeply personal show was routine, but damn was it inspiring for me and the rest of the audience. On Saturday, we learned that tourists are back. Everytime Springsteen mentioned a town - San Francisco, Phoenix, Asbury Park - there were loud cheers from people who live there. He had to tell the out-of-towners to 'shut the f-k up.'

5
Thumbs Sideways

‘Girl From the North Country’ review: Bob Dylan on Broadway is a dud

From: New York Post  |  Date: 3/5/2020

A series of unfortunate events has come to Broadway. No, not the Lemony Snicket novels, but 'Girl From the North Country,' a mashup of Bob Dylan songs and abject misery. The show, which opened Thursday night, is little more than a stack of vaguely depressed persons who take breaks from sad scenes to sing anguished and questionably relevant songs.

West Side Story Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

‘West Side Story’ Broadway review: Radical revival is a triumph

From: New York Post  |  Date: 2/20/2020

By pushing back against what we remember from the Oscar-winning 1961 film, a musical that many can recite line-by-line becomes newly suspenseful and gripping. It's still the 'Romeo and Juliet'-inspired story of Tony (Isaac Powell) of the Jets gang, and Maria (Shereen Pimentel), the sister of the rival Sharks gang leader, Bernardo (Amar Ramasar). The couple meets during a dance at the gym and, at great risk to themselves, fall in love. But every step in this well-worn plot comes as a startling surprise, starting with the gangs themselves. As we watch during Leonard Bernstein's booming 'Prologue,' when a camera pans across the cast's faces, the racially specific animus (Puerto Ricans versus the Polish and Irish) is largely gone. It's still there in Arthur Laurents' book and Stephen Sondheim's lyrics, but in an effort to reflect modern-day New York and its evolving conflicts, the casting is totally diverse - and devastatingly young.

7
Thumbs Sideways

Laura Linney shines in Broadway’s blah ‘My Name Is Lucy Barton’

From: New York Post  |  Date: 1/15/2020

That's Laura Linney, the venerable actress, who stars in the one-woman play, adapted from Elizabeth Strout's novel, that opened on Broadway Wednesday night. It's a skilled performance that employs the actress's signature move: commanding the stage while remaining genteel and dignified.

5
Thumbs Sideways

‘Jagged Little Pill’ Broadway review: An uneven Alanis Morissette show

From: New York Post  |  Date: 12/5/2019

More social issues are addressed in 'Jagged Little Pill' than at a Democratic presidential debate. Opioid addiction, race, bisexuality, sexual assault - the Alanis Morissette musical, which opened Thursday night on Broadway, has got 'em all. But, like trying to shove Elizabeth Warren's entire platform into a single evening, nearly every topic gets short shrift.

The Inheritance Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

‘The Inheritance’ is a touching call to action on Broadway

From: New York Post  |  Date: 11/17/2019

The first part takes a while to click in. The use of author E.M. Forster as a narrator, the ensemble chirpily finishing each others' sentences and the abundance of graphic sex-talk can grow cloying. The play finds its soul near the end of the first portion, which is a well-earned tearjerker. To reveal much of Part 2 would rob the drama of its suspense. As the story moves forward, the 15 actors embody a clown car of different characters. The most heart-wrenching are Adam, an actor Toby falls in love with, and Leo, a male escort who's a dead ringer for Adam. Both men are played by Samuel Levine, who, as Leo, gives a moving and truthful performance of someone in immense pain.

8
Thumbs Up

‘Tina Turner Musical’ review: A towering Broadway performance

From: New York Post  |  Date: 11/7/2019

But let's be real: You come to 'Tina' for the songs. Director Phyllida Lloyd ('Mamma Mia!') stages them smoothly, with vibrant pops of color that ripple off the shimmering fringe of Mark Thompson's costumes. And all of them - including 'I Can't Stand the Rain,' 'Private Dancer' and 'We Don't Need Another Hero' - sound glorious. During the exuberant final concert, Warren isn't just rolling on the river: She's stampeding through Broadway.

8
Thumbs Up

‘Tina Turner Musical’ review: A towering Broadway performance

From: New York Post  |  Date: 11/7/2019

But let's be real: You come to 'Tina' for the songs. Director Phyllida Lloyd ('Mamma Mia!') stages them smoothly, with vibrant pops of color that ripple off the shimmering fringe of Mark Thompson's costumes. And all of them - including 'I Can't Stand the Rain,' 'Private Dancer' and 'We Don't Need Another Hero' - sound glorious. During the exuberant final concert, Warren isn't just rolling on the river: She's stampeding through Broadway.

Slave Play Broadway
5
Thumbs Sideways

‘Slave Play’ review: Broadway’s most thoughtful mess

From: New York Post  |  Date: 10/6/2019

With all that time for development, most of the characters, such as they are, remain vague and archetypal. There's little change from start to finish, and therefore no investment from us. For better or worse, 'Slave Play' is the sort of show you see to say you've seen it.

Betrayal Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

A sexy Tom Hiddleston leads Broadway’s ‘Betrayal’

From: New York Post  |  Date: 9/5/2019

But your eyes are glued to the actors, who fill their Pinter pauses with fierce desire and longing - especially when standing several feet apart. Hiddleston supplies most of the play's danger with his forceful presence, while its heart comes from a deep-feeling Ashton. Meanwhile, Cox is a guy plenty of audience members would gladly leave their husbands for.

Moulin Rouge! Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

‘Moulin Rouge!’ review: NYC’s hottest nightclub is on Broadway

From: New York Post  |  Date: 7/25/2019

Director Alex Timbers' smartest move is not trying to replicate Luhrmann's quick-cut sense of humor, which would crash and burn onstage. Instead, he focuses on grandiose emotions, sensuality and the storybook sensation of first love, for which Tveit's puppy-dog innocence is ideal.

Moulin Rouge! Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

‘Moulin Rouge!’ review: NYC’s hottest nightclub is on Broadway

From: New York Post  |  Date: 7/25/2019

Director Alex Timbers' smartest move is not trying to replicate Luhrmann's quick-cut sense of humor, which would crash and burn onstage. Instead, he focuses on grandiose emotions, sensuality and the storybook sensation of first love, for which Tveit's puppy-dog innocence is ideal.

Moulin Rouge! Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

‘Moulin Rouge!’ review: NYC’s hottest nightclub is on Broadway

From: New York Post  |  Date: 7/25/2019

Director Alex Timbers' smartest move is not trying to replicate Luhrmann's quick-cut sense of humor, which would crash and burn onstage. Instead, he focuses on grandiose emotions, sensuality and the storybook sensation of first love, for which Tveit's puppy-dog innocence is ideal.

Beetlejuice Broadway
2
Thumbs Down

‘Beetlejuice’ review: Musical is a coke-snorting, F-bombing disaster

From: New York Post  |  Date: 4/25/2019

Most of the cast overplays (Butler, Kritzer) or underplays (McClure, Dannheisser), but the talented Caruso, with a Cyndi Lauper-like voice, strikes the right balance. This is a challenge for all involved, especially in the second half of Scott Brown and Anthony King's jumbled book. Indeed, if the actors took their scripts, threw them into the air, picked up the pages and performed them in their new order, Act 2 would be about the same. Director Alex Timbers' hyperactive staging and David Korins' huge-but-ugly set don't help matters much.

Ink Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

‘Ink’ review: Broadway’s latest is a scrappy, seductive tabloid tale

From: New York Post  |  Date: 4/24/2019

And so is the exciting new play about it, 'Ink,' which opened on Broadway Wednesday night after its West End run. James Graham's down-and-dirty dramedy tells the story of the 1969 purchase of the struggling paper by a scrappy Australian named Rupert Murdoch.

Tootsie Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

‘Tootsie’ review: New musical is no drag; it’s funnier than the film

From: New York Post  |  Date: 4/23/2019

While Yazbek's jazzy score doesn't reach the heights of his work in 'The Band's Visit,' there are a few really terrific numbers. You won't leave 'Tootsie' humming, but you will leave laughing - which is even better.

Hadestown Broadway
5
Thumbs Sideways

‘Hadestown’ review: Broadway douses the fires of hell with folk music

From: New York Post  |  Date: 4/17/2019

Yes, composer Anaïs Mitchell's musical retelling of the Orpheus and Eurydice myth, which opened Wednesday on Broadway, sounds pleasant and looks more expensive than it did in 2016 at New York Theatre Workshop. But this classic tale of love - he looks back, she gets trapped in the underworld for all eternity - is still too slick and sterile for us to give a damn about her damnation.

Oklahoma! Broadway
2
Thumbs Down

‘Oklahoma!’ review: Anti-gun revival of classic shot to hell

From: New York Post  |  Date: 4/7/2019

Some of Fish's ideas are fun. The chili and cornbread doled out to the audience at intermission is tasty, and the women snapping ears of corn during 'Many A New Day' gives the scene rebellious energy. But in putting his actors in modern dress, making guns his wallpaper and forcing every moment that a gun is brandished or even mentioned to have bombastic significance, Fish clearly is saying he's not a great fan of the culture of the Great Plains - of yesteryear or yesterday. In a preposterously heavy-handed sequence, he even has Jud present Curly with a pistol, rather than the usual knife, which leads to a shocking but inane conclusion. All this, in a hokey old show that includes the lyric, 'Gonna give ya barley, carrots and potaters.' Listening to the New York audience applauding their own virtuosity makes a guy want to put this 'Oklahoma!' out to pasture.

Oklahoma! Broadway
2
Thumbs Down

‘Oklahoma!’ review: Anti-gun revival of classic shot to hell

From: New York Post  |  Date: 4/7/2019

Some of Fish's ideas are fun. The chili and cornbread doled out to the audience at intermission is tasty, and the women snapping ears of corn during 'Many A New Day' gives the scene rebellious energy. But in putting his actors in modern dress, making guns his wallpaper and forcing every moment that a gun is brandished or even mentioned to have bombastic significance, Fish clearly is saying he's not a great fan of the culture of the Great Plains - of yesteryear or yesterday. In a preposterously heavy-handed sequence, he even has Jud present Curly with a pistol, rather than the usual knife, which leads to a shocking but inane conclusion. All this, in a hokey old show that includes the lyric, 'Gonna give ya barley, carrots and potaters.' Listening to the New York audience applauding their own virtuosity makes a guy want to put this 'Oklahoma!' out to pasture.

Hello, Dolly! Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

‘Hello, Dolly!’ proves Bette Midler’s genius

From: NY Post  |  Date: 4/20/2017

We must, of course, credit the actress' brilliance as a performer. Her iconic comic chops - honed in Upper West Side gay bathhouses, Upper East Side divorcée-revenge capers and Las Vegas concerts - are on delicious display as Dolly the meddling matchmaker, especially next to David Hyde Pierce as her cheerfully crotchety leading man. And there is nothing more invigorating than Midler crooning Jerry Herman's sensational standards. But the actress' nonstop hustle during her 50-year career is every bit as ingenious as her art.

Hello, Dolly! Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

‘Hello, Dolly!’ proves Bette Midler’s genius

From: NY Post  |  Date: 4/20/2017

We must, of course, credit the actress' brilliance as a performer. Her iconic comic chops - honed in Upper West Side gay bathhouses, Upper East Side divorcée-revenge capers and Las Vegas concerts - are on delicious display as Dolly the meddling matchmaker, especially next to David Hyde Pierce as her cheerfully crotchety leading man. And there is nothing more invigorating than Midler crooning Jerry Herman's sensational standards. But the actress' nonstop hustle during her 50-year career is every bit as ingenious as her art.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $106
Hot Show
Tickets From $133