Cagney The Musical traces the life and career of James Cagney, one of Hollywood's most iconic performers, blending tap dance, storytelling, and a dynamic score to capture his journey from the streets of New York to stardom. The production features music and lyrics by Robert Creighton and Christopher McGovern, with a book by Peter Colley. Grammy Award-winning singer, songwriter, and actress Melissa Manchester joins the cast as Ma Cagney, bringing decades of experience across music, film, and stage to the role. The production is directed by Will Pomerantz and runs June 30 through July 26, 2026, at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor.
Cast and Creative Team for Cagney The Musical at Bay Street Theater
Cast
Melissa Manchester
Ma Cagney
Creative Team
Peter Colley
Book Writer
Christopher McGovern
Composer
Robert Creighton
Composer
Riki Kane Larimer
Producer
Will Pomerantz
Director
News About Cagney The Musical at Bay Street Theater
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
Bay Street Theater Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
Mister Halston (6/2/26-6/21/26)
Cagney - The Musical (6/30/26-7/26/26)
Dear Evan Hansen (8/4/26-8/29/26)
Bonkers in the Boroughs (9/1/26-9/6/26)
Dazed & Confused: A Tribute to Led Zeppelin (2/28/26-2/28/26)
Ha Ha Hamptons Comedy Tour = Valentine's Edition (2/14/26-2/14/26)
That Motown Band (2/8/26-2/8/26)
Radio Alanis (2/7/26-2/7/26)
Radio Alanis (2/7/26-2/7/26)
Nancy Atlas with Randi Fishenfeld - Fireside Sessions (1/31/26-1/24/26)
Fireside Sessions: Nancy Atlas with Jonny Rosch (1/31/26-1/31/26)
Nancy Atlas with Brian Mitchell - Fireside Sessions (1/17/26-1/17/26)
Fireside Sessions with Nancy Atlas (1/10/26-1/31/26)
Nancy Atlas with Gene Casey and Eugene Chrysler A Country and Rockabilly Revue (1/10/26-1/10/26)
More Long Island Coverage
Videos