Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Photos: The Randy Andys' SPRING SWING at Don't Tell Mama

Monica Blume, Alison Mahoney, and Catie Pires-Fernandes starred alongside guest stars Ellie Wyman and Joe Montoya.

By:

The Randy Andys performed a sold-out evening at Don’t Tell Mama with their “Spring Swing” cabaret, reimagining pop icons and dance-floor anthems through a vintage lens. See photos!

Featuring crowd favorites like “Material Girl,” “Fantasy,” “Thriller,” “Woman,” and “Thank You for Being a Friend,” The Randy Andys–Monica Blume (Dear Evan Hansen), Alison Mahoney (The Food Network, Ragtime), and Catie Pires-Fernandes (Waitress)--thrilled audiences alongside the Matthew Everingham Duo with lush harmonies, sharp choreography, and their signature blend of glamour, comedy, and nostalgic flair.

The Randy Andys were joined by special guest star Ellie Wyman (SIX, Frozen) for spirited renditions of “Single Ladies” and “Juice,” then bringing the house down with a show-stopping performance of “I Will Survive.”

Adding even more excitement to the evening, guest star Joe Montoya (Our Own Odyssey) wowed audiences with standout performances of “Thriller,” “That’s What Makes You Beautiful,” and a moving rendition of “Spring Can Really Hang You Up the Most.”

Podcast host and singer Jayson Kerr praised the performance on social media, saying: “It was packed at Don’t Tell Mama — you actually couldn’t get a seat because it was so packed. … Let’s talk about the arrangements. Matthew Everingham always puts his foot in these arrangements. … If you happen to see The Randy Andys around town, go ahead and buy a ticket to their concert. You probably won’t be able to get one for long, especially considering how packed it was last night. You won’t be disappointed!”

The creative team was led by Antoinette DiPietropolo (Director), Matthew Everingham (Music Supervisor), Gina Daugherty (Choreographer), with Lauren C. Taylor (Swing).

Spring Swing was conceived and produced by Alison Mahoney, with executive producer Gabrielle Ruiz, co-producer Jocelyn Lonquist Klein, and associate producer Luke Gilmore.

Photo credit: Jay Bassin

More on Don't Tell Mama
Upcoming Shows
Love or Death?
Love or Death?
4/19 - 10/10/2026
Project 2026: Blue Tsunami!
Project 2026: Blue Tsunami!
9/1 - 9/1/2026
Recent Articles
Wendy Scherl to Bring THE BEAT GOES ON to Don't Tell Mama
Wendy Scherl to Bring THE BEAT GOES ON to Don't Tell Mama
8/26/2026
Review: Therese Lee Mines Gold With PENNIES FROM HEAVEN at Don't Tell Mama
Review: Therese Lee Mines Gold With PENNIES FROM HEAVEN at Don't Tell Mama
8/26/2026
Need more Cabaret Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


My Body, My Cabaret in Cabaret My Body, My Cabaret
The Green Room 42 (8/29-8/29)
The Bryce Edwards Frivolity Hour in Cabaret The Bryce Edwards Frivolity Hour
BIRDLAND (9/14-9/14)
Will Kelley: For the Record in Cabaret Will Kelley: For the Record
Laurie Beechman Theatre (8/29-8/29) PHOTOS VIDEOS
Lucibela presented in partnership with WMI in Cabaret Lucibela presented in partnership with WMI
Joe's Pub (10/22-10/22)
Sarah Kang w/ Takahiro Izumikawa in Cabaret Sarah Kang w/ Takahiro Izumikawa
Joe's Pub (9/29-9/29)
Lea Salonga in Cabaret Lea Salonga
54 Below (12/02-12/02)
Lyric Theatre of Oklahoma on Broadway in Cabaret Lyric Theatre of Oklahoma on Broadway
54 Below (10/18-10/18)
Basement After Dark: The Music of RAYE in Cabaret Basement After Dark: The Music of RAYE
54 Below (8/31-8/31)
Paul Beaubrun: VERTIÈRES Album release in Cabaret Paul Beaubrun: VERTIÈRES Album release
Joe's Pub (11/14-11/14)
Seth Sikes with Tedd Firth: Together at Last! Feat. Marilyn Maye in Cabaret Seth Sikes with Tedd Firth: Together at Last! Feat. Marilyn Maye
54 Below (9/22-9/22)