Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: Mamma Mia at Providence Performing Arts Center

By:

Until last evening, I was a Mamma Mia virgin (No show, No movie, and No soundtrack).

To be clear, ABBA and I had been hooking up regularly for the past 30 years or so, but I had never succumbed to the wiles of the Broadway musical based on ABBA's songs.  This is, in part, because I am not very keen on Juke-Box musicals.  It was also because I have such great personal memories of listening to ABBA's music that I was afraid that those memories would be ruined, or at the very least, tainted.

I had nothing to worry about.

Mamma Mia is a charming Greek fable that tells the story of a young woman, Sophie (Rose Sezniak), who is about to get married to Eddie (Bradley Whitfield, in this performance). Sophie, in the search for the identity of her father, has read her mother Donna's (Susie McMonagle) 21-year-old journals and has secretly sent wedding invitations to three men, Harry Bright (Michael Aaron Linder), Bill Austin (Martin Kildare), and Sam Carmichael (John Hemphill), who might be her dad.

Donna is less than 100% behind her 20-year-old daughter's wedding. She has invited two of her old friends, and former band-mates Tanya (Michelle Dawson) and Rosie (Kittra Wynn Coomer) to the wedding, for moral support.

The production is filled with top-notch performers and performances.  The chemistry between Sophie and her bridesmaids Ali (Monette McKay) and Lisa (Nicole Laurenzi), as the play opens, was surprisingly real.  There are certainly moments of high camp, but it is done better and with more restraint than I expected.

Under Phyllida Lloyd's direction, each number is acted, as opposed to sung, which I appreciate. The music and story have been massaged to fit together seamlessly. 

The band swings under Susan Draus' musical direction. The musical numbers range from small introspective guitar solo laments to big Labelle-style production numbers.  The huge wall of sound that ABBA is known for is created on stage, not by mixing and remixing the audio, but by a large and capable ensemble.  Susie McMonagle can really belt out a tune, which I love.

All of your favorite ABBA songs make an appearance in Mamma Mia, along with a few lesser-known songs.  Each of the songs in the show works to further the narrative. The show is nearly a disco opera, as there is so much music that dialogue is thin.  That is not to say that the book, by Catherine Johnson, is lacking.  It isn't.  Johnson had to good sense to get the dialogue out of the way of the musical numbers.  

Because of Benny Andersson and Bjorn Ulvaeus's beautiful music, Mamma Mia is a trans-generational musical theater event.  The audience was filled with grandparents with their children and grandchildren; all having a great time.

Mamma Mia plays at the Providence Performing Arts Center (PPAC) through January 4th.  Tickets range from $44-$71 and can be purchased by calling the PPAC Box office at (401) 421-ARTS or online at www.ppacri.org.  The Box office is located at 220 Weybosset St., Providence, RI and has extended holiday hours.

Reader Reviews

Need more Boston Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
The Norwegians in Boston The Norwegians
Elayne P. Bernstein Theatre (9/04-10/04)
The Barber of Seville by G. Rossini with Boston Summer Opera & Horizon Ensemble in Boston The Barber of Seville by G. Rossini with Boston Summer Opera & Horizon Ensemble
Boston Synagogue (8/23-8/23)
Buena Vista Orchestra in Boston Buena Vista Orchestra
Emerson Colonial Theatre (10/08-10/08)
THT Rep presents Romeo & Juliet in Boston THT Rep presents Romeo & Juliet
The Hanover Theatre and Conservatory for the Performing Arts (9/23-10/11)
THT Rep presents the 6th Annual Edgar Allan Poe Double Header in Boston THT Rep presents the 6th Annual Edgar Allan Poe Double Header
The Hanover Theatre and Conservatory for the Performing Arts (10/28-11/01)
A Christmas Carol in Boston A Christmas Carol
North Shore Music Theatre (12/03-12/23)
School of Rock in Boston School of Rock
Firehouse Center for the Arts (8/21-9/06)
The Nutcracker in Boston The Nutcracker
The Hanover Theatre and Conservatory for the Performing Arts (11/27-11/29)
Koe Wetzel & Shane Smith and The Saints in Boston Koe Wetzel & Shane Smith and The Saints
Leader Bank Pavilion (8/19-8/19)
Meet the Cartozians in Boston Meet the Cartozians
Boston Center for the Arts (2/18-3/21)

BroadwayWorld TV