The Crucifer of Blood has received several awards for its outstanding production. These include the Drama Desk Awards for Outstanding Lighting Design, which was awarded to Roger Morgan, and Outstanding Set Design, which was awarded to John Wulp. The show also won the Olivier Award for Play of the Year, with Arthur Conan Doyle being recognized for his exceptional work. Additionally, John Wulp received the Best Set Design award at the Outer Critics Circle Awards for his contribution to the production.