icecreambenjamin said: "I just pre ordered this and it's now coming out on February 5th, but I noticed that the description said that Christian Borle is featured on it. I'm pretty sure that he wasn't in the Encores! production. Does anyone know if he replaced Fogler on the recording? "
Hm, that's very strange. It does seem like Christian Borle will be playing Mr. Bungee on the recording (simply based on Dan Fogler's absence from the list). I didn't see the production, sadly, but I feel like I heard mixed opinions on Fogler's performance.
"Contentment, it seems, simply happens. It appears accompanied by no bravos and no tears."
Just listened to it after purchasing from iTunes and I love the new recording. Love the inclusion of all the material missing from the original, really like most of the changes, and a few of these versions will easily replace the originals in the rotation (particularly Ana Gasteyer's numbers - Music Still Plays On alone is worth the purchase).
Only complaint - the seemingly unnecessary track splicing! Much of what I would consider "Heart and Music" (and is by the original sheet music) is contained in the previous track. And, likewise, it seems unnecessary to separate Time from Time and Music.
I'm enjoying the recording very much, as well- aside from Borle, actually, whose choice of using a grand thespian voice for Bungee seems totally inexplicable. Perhaps I'm just used to Zien's smarmy New Yorker schtick.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
I'm not a huge fan of William Finn and I've only listened to the original album once quite a while ago but I'm really enjoying this new recording with Groff. I love pretty much everything PS Classics does. Their passion for the shows they choose to preserve is evident in just about every album they release and it's hard not to revel in it.
I actually like Finn's work on a broader scale, but think that New Brain is one of his superior works. So I enjoy this recording quite a lot, especially for the two above and Groff!
I'm German. Get used to the weird wording, spelling and/or grammar.
kidmanboy said: "Only complaint - the seemingly unnecessary track splicing! Much of what I would consider "Heart and Music" (and is by the original sheet music) is contained in the previous track. And, likewise, it seems unnecessary to separate Time from Time and Music."
"Time" and "Time and Music" are two different songs is probably why they're separated into two tracks.
I've finally listened to this album, I really enjoyed it (Rema and Ana probably being my favorites). I think I prefer the original recording though. I like Groff (and normally love him) but he actually didn't leave much of an impact for me on first listen. Maybe on repeats he'll grow on me.
"Contentment, it seems, simply happens. It appears accompanied by no bravos and no tears."
I accept that the original cast recording is probably engraved on my heart and brain, so differences are bound to be jarring, but to me the production of this album is too often harsh, forced and uncomfortable.
That said, Ana Gasteyer sings beautifully.
This one is for the shelf. The original is for listening to.
"And They're Off" is one of my favorite William Finn songs, and I think that Jason Robert Brown's arrangement is phenomenal. The original cast recording of that song is one of my all-time favorites. This new one just doesn't do it for me, though. Maybe the cast didn't have enough time to rehearse and really get those harmonies right. But it does sound kind of ragged.