Skip to main content Skip to footer site map


Christopher Hayden's production feels too much like hard work


Review: THE CAUCASIAN CHALK CIRCLE, Rose Theatre The story of a land dispute between two rival groups in Eastern Europe, a 'special military operation' and a refugee crisis. No, not the current news headlines, but the contents of Bertolt Brecht's 1948 play The Caucasian Chalk Circle, revived by a major London theatre for the first time in twenty five years. Unfortunately, Christopher Hayden's re-imagined production feels too much like hard work.

Set in the middle of a revolution, we follow the story of a poor servant girl, Grusha, who risks her life to save the baby of a noble family, enduring a loveless marriage and a battle with the self-serving mother of the baby, to keep the child safe.

At its heart the play is a parable, concerning the struggle of two women over the custody of a child. Unlike many of his plays, The Caucasian Chalk Circle has a relatively happy ending.

Carrie Hope Fletcher is a canny bit of casting who will draw in audiences who would otherwise never go to see a Brecht play. Her vocal abilities are never in doubt, but she is also a convincing and charismatic Grusha.

Jonathan Singer is the standout, bringing a welcome comedic slant as a suitably self-serving Azdak. He has impeccable timing and a droll, sneering delivery that really engages the drooping audience after the interval. Nickcolia King-N'Da is naturally likable as Simon, Zoe West is engaging, but overworked as The Singer.

Songs are intrinsic to Brecht's original play and composer Michael Henry has created some interesting interpretations. The whole cast provides the background percussion, with just an occasional guitar to accompany the singing. The effect is impressively performed, but is also very repetitive at times. Fletcher is, unsurprisingly, the standout, but her impressive voice is not used as much as it could be.

By definition, Brecht's epic theatre is not meant to do something as frivolous as entertain. He uses drama as a social and ideological forum for left-leaning causes; an inspiration to action, highlighting the individual's greater responsibility to the collective good, and making audiences think. His plays are an active, rather than passive experience.

Director Christopher Haydon has made the decision to actively ignore these theories, at least in the first half of the production. Bringing the prologue into a modern day refugee camp is a very relevant idea and works well. A singer, brought in to the provide entertainment, sets up the refugees to act out the play-within-a-play and so the story begins. He also ramps up the stories with slapstick and villains that are almost pantomime-esque.

After the interval, the fourth wall is finally broken and the audience is invited to think about what is happening, rather than just watching it. At three hours, the production becomes a slog as hard as Grusha's trek through the mountains and a judicious amount of trimming would be welcome.

This is a busy production, with lots often happening at once. The cast is deft and precise, but there are some strange staging decisions such as an odd ice-skating motion used to illustrate walking and running. There are also too many accents used to count. Many fall into the usual cliché of RP being used by the snobbish and morally questionable, to regional yokel accents used by those who live in the countryside. It seems a lazy trope to use.

Brecht is often a hard writer to enjoy, but this energetic cast give a huge amount to the production. However, for this reviewer, there are too many things that don't quite work, although I'm sure that Carrie Hope Fletcher's legions of fans won't even notice.

The Caucasian Chalk Circle is at the Rose Theatre until 22 October

Photo Credit: Iona Firouzabadi

Full Cast Announced For GUYS & DOLLS at the Bridge Theatre Photo
Casting has been announced for Guys & Dolls, coming to the Bridge Theatre in March 2023.

Listen: Marisha Wallace Releases Hopelessly Devoted to You in Honor of Olivia Newton-John Photo
Broadway and West End superstar Marisha Wallace has released a rendition of Hopelessly Devoted To You, the iconic Oscar-nominated track from the 1978 classic ‘Grease’, in honour of the late Olivia Newton-John.

JERSEY BOYS Extends Booking at Londons Trafalgar Theatre to 1 October 2023 Photo
Jersey Boys has announced that its run at London's Trafalgar Theatre has been extended, and is now booking until 1st October 2023. This musical extravaganza goes behind the music and inside the story of Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons in the multi award-winning, true-life phenomenon, Jersey Boys.

Disneys NEWSIES Extends Booking to 16 April 2023 Photo
​​​​​​​NEWSIES has announced a new booking period at London's Troubadour Wembley Park Theatre due to overwhelming demand and sold-out previews. NEWSIES will now run through to Sunday 16 April 2023.

From This Author - Aliya Al-Hassan

Aliya Al-Hassan is UK Managing Editor of BroadwayWorld. A London-based theatre critic and journalist, she has a life-long passion for the arts, with a focus on theatre and opera. She is a... (read more about this author)

Interview: Neil Bartlett on the Writing Process, Gender Identity and Adapting ORLANDO for the StageInterview: Neil Bartlett on the Writing Process, Gender Identity and Adapting ORLANDO for the Stage
November 25, 2022

Adapted by Neil Bartlett, starring Golden Globe winner Emma Corrin and directed by Tony and Olivier winner Michael Grandage, the early-awaited stage version of Orlando is about to start previews. BroadwayWorld caught up with Neil ahead of opening night on 5 December to talk about the writing process, gender identity and the magic of language.

Guildhall School of Music & Drama Announces Spring 2023 Events
November 25, 2022

This spring, Guildhall School of Music & Drama presents a varied programme of events for the public to enjoy, including concerts, drama productions, opera and jazz.

Black Friday: Save up to 38% on THE WIFE OF WILLESDENBlack Friday: Save up to 38% on THE WIFE OF WILLESDEN
November 25, 2022

Save up to 38% on The Wife Of Willesden. After a sold-out, critically acclaimed run in 2021, Alvita, The Wife of Willesden returns for one more round at the bar. 

THE MOUSETRAP Will Open on Broadway in 2023THE MOUSETRAP Will Open on Broadway in 2023
November 25, 2022

Agatha Christie’s iconic thriller, The Mousetrap, the longest running play in the world, marks its 70th anniversary today (25 November) by announcing that the show will make its Broadway premiere next year.

Photos: First Look at MOTHER GOOSE at Hackney EmpirePhotos: First Look at MOTHER GOOSE at Hackney Empire
November 24, 2022

Hackney Empire has released production images for its 23rd Christmas pantomime Mother Goose which began previews on 19 November. The production runs until 31 December with press night on 1 December.