Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL, The Old Vic

A Christmas CarolPanto might be the stalwart annual theatre trip at Christmas (yes, I know, "oh no it isn't"...), but the Old Vic's production of A Christmas Carol, now in its third year, is fast catching up as one of the most joyous experiences of the festive season.

A Christmas CarolAdapted by Jack Thorne and directed by Matthew Warchus, A Christmas Carol, for those few who do not know, tells of the near-mythical metamorphosis of Ebenezer Scrooge from penny-pinching miser to kindly benefactor when he is visited by three ghosts. Reliving Christmases past, present and future in one evening, Scrooge learns the mistakes he has made and the potential he has to alter what is to be.

With the hanging lamps above the stage providing a pulsing energy throughout, Rob Howell's design gives a new meaning to the idea of a swinging Christmas. Hugh Vanstone's lighting also adds a stark realism, which can be at times generally felt wanting in this show given the source material's context.

The Ghosts of Scrooges past now haunt this show, leading to comparisons between Paterson Joseph and his predecessors, Stephen Tomkinson and Rhys Ifans. Where Tomkinson ably showed Scrooge's transition from a bah-humbug to a generous soul, Joseph's performance doesn't quite manage to capture the change. There's a flickering warmth and moral tiredness to this Scrooge that's set against the traditionally austere miser, but his arc is not quite as successful as might be hoped.

Nevertheless, there's plenty to feast upon in this A Christmas Carol. Thorne's adaptation moves at a brisk pace and the gentle bell-ringing chorus by the cast, with musical direction by Oli Jackson and composition by Christopher Nightingale, is beautiful.

Amidst an excellent cast, on my good list this year are Melissa Allan, Gloria Onitiri, Myra McFadyen, Fred Haig and Rebecca Trehearn for their performances, and it's impossible not to love Lara Mehmet as Tiny Tim. Being welcomed into the theatre auditorium by a mince pie for those naughty or a satsuma for those nice sets the mood perfectly for the coming two hours, and the end of this production is as glorious and magical as you're going to find anywhere in London.

"Marley was dead, to begin with." Dickens's opening line is astounding for its balance, offering both the natural and supernatural and the potential for a story to begin. This Old Vic production continues to show that the spirit of the Dickensian classic is alive and kicking, and if we ever needed to harken to its messages of spreading love and caring for others, now is the time.

A Christmas Carol is at the Old Vic until 18 January, 2020.

Photograph credit: Manuel Harlan.



Related Stories
A CHRISTMAS CAROL Plays Final Broadway Performance Today Photo
The holiday season is officially over, and so is A Christmas Carol. The play concludes its limited Broadway run at the Lyceum Theatre today, January 5, following 12 previews and 58 regular performances.

A CHRISTMAS CAROL Breaks Box Office Record For The Third Week In A Row Photo
A Christmas Carol, which opened on Broadway November 20, 2019, has just broken another box office record at the Lyceum Theatre. Adapted by Jack Thorne and directed by Matthew Warchus, A Christmas Carol grossed $954,054.40 over nine performances for the week ending December 29. It tops the house record previously held by Oh, Hello, the Nick Kroll and John Mulaney comedy that grossed $911,602 for the week ending January 1, 2017.

A CHRISTMAS CAROL Sets New House Box Office Record at the Lyceum Theatre Photo
The holiday masterpiece, A Christmas Carol, which opened on Broadway to rave reviews on November 20, 2019, has just broken the box office record at the Lyceum Theatre. Adapted by Jack Thorne and directed by Matthew Warchus, A Christmas Carol grossed $823,011 over eight performances for the week ending December 15. It tops the house record previously held by Oh, Hello, the Nick Kroll and John Mulaney comedy that grossed $804,513 for the week ending January 22, 2017.

VIDEO: Jai Srinivasan and Sebastian Ortiz of A CHRISTMAS CAROL Discuss What it Means to Pl Photo
Two boys share the role of Tiny Tim in Broadway's new production of A Christmas Carol. But that's not all they share.


From This Author - Anthony Walker-Cook

Anthony is a PhD candidate at UCL but aspires to work in the arts industry when he finishes studying. He's probably somewhere in a theatre not working on his PhD. @AntWalker_Cook

... (read more about this author)

Interview: Liam Brennan Talks About Returning to the Role of Inspector Goole in AN INSPECTOR CALLSInterview: Liam Brennan Talks About Returning to the Role of Inspector Goole in AN INSPECTOR CALLS
October 10, 2022

Liam Brennan has played the role of Inspector Goole in the West End and on Broadway - he returns to the role this year as part of the touring 30 year anniversary of the National Theatre's production. He speaks to BroadwayWorld about returning to the role.

BWW Interview: Nancy Carroll Talks MANOR at the National TheatreBWW Interview: Nancy Carroll Talks MANOR at the National Theatre
December 1, 2021

Nancy Carroll's credits include seven previous productions at the National Theatre and, recently, The Crown on Netflix. She is currently starring in the National Theatre's production of Manor, a new play by Moira Buffini.

BWW Review: WHAT A CARVE UP!, OnlineBWW Review: WHAT A CARVE UP!, Online
November 2, 2020

At a time when live theatre has again been yanked from our grasp, the joint efforts of The Barn Theatre, The New Wolsey Theatre and The Lawrence Batley theatre to produce an adaptation of Jonathan Coe’s What a Carve Up! is a welcome tonic amidst such ever-darkening days.

The Shows That Made Us: FOLLIESThe Shows That Made Us: FOLLIES
September 23, 2020

I owe a lot to Follies - friendships with fans and actors and occasional pieces of journalism have resulted from the show - but it made me realise how transformative live theatre can be. Thinking about it, it's ironic that a show signalling the death of old Broadway should ignite such a passion, but isn't that the point of Follies?

BWW Review: TONIGHT AT THE LONDON COLISEUM: SHARON D. CLARKE, London ColiseumBWW Review: TONIGHT AT THE LONDON COLISEUM: SHARON D. CLARKE, London Coliseum
September 18, 2020

FFew performers in the industry are on top of their game like Sharon D Clarke right now. After storming performances in Caroline, or Change and Blues in the Night in London, Clarke was in rehearsals for the former show on Broadway when COVID-19 hit. From the London Coliseum, she now begins a series of online cabarets, Tonight at the London Coliseum, with brio and passion.