Reviews by Mike Davis
5
Review: ‘Elf the Musical’ falls short of capturing the magic of the movie
From: WBEZ Chicago | Date: 12/10/2025
The musical follows the same beats as the film, which doesn’t leave room for the plot itself to be the primary driver of capturing the audience’s attention. Under direction by Philip Wm. McKinley (restaged for tour by Dave Solomon) the jokes are plentiful, but they don’t land firmly enough in the hands of Ducat, who doesn’t have the comedic timing or pleasantly off-kilter stage presence of the role’s originator.
Videos