Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Elysa Gardner — Theater Critic

USA Today, New York Stage Review, New York Sun

Reviews on BroadwayWorld
303
Average score
7.69 / 10
Most recent review
7/24/2026
Thumbs Sideways

Reviews by Elysa Gardner

5
Thumbs Sideways

Sentimentality, effects lift 'Ghost: The Musical'

From: USA Today  |  Date: 4/23/2012

If you haven't seen Ghost on screen, there's a bittersweet ending. For the musical's producers, the future looks brighter: A third production is set to open in Melbourne next year. Apparently, sentimentality and special effects are draws — even if the latter can play tricks on you occasionally.

Evita Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Don't cry for this graceful 'Evita' revival

From: USA Today  |  Date: 4/5/2012

Though Rogers' voice isn't strong, her singing has a raw ache and folky authenticity. She also moves like a gazelle, reinforcing Eva's beguiling sensuality and adding further sparkle to Ashford's earthy, vibrant dance numbers. The narrator, Che, isn't presented as the flamboyant revolutionary (based on Che Guevera) he became under Harold Prince's original direction. A charming Ricky Martin plays the character more as an amused, sometimes sympathetic spectator; though critical of Eva, as Rice's lyrics demand, he also conveys a certain tenderness.

9
Thumbs Up

With this revival, 'The Best Man' does win

From: USA Today  |  Date: 4/1/2012

As drama, The Best Man is both soapy and self-righteous; fortunately, director Michael Wilson has assembled a cast of seasoned pros who manage a winningly dry, light touch. John Larroquette brings a mix of gravitas and ruefulness to Russell, whose only apparent shortcoming is trouble remaining faithful to his wife. ... But the biggest, warmest laughs are provided by another venerable octogenarian: James Earl Jones, who clearly has a field day as jocular former president Artie Hockstader. Though a fundamentally decent fellow, Hockstader has no problem enjoying some of the tawdrier elements of the political game as a spectator. Thanks to the sterling company here, neither will you.

8
Thumbs Up

Disney's 'Newsies' won't break news but it still delivers

From: USA Today  |  Date: 3/29/2012

Newsies' contrivances are served with a light, knowing touch, and made even more palatable by the easy infectiousness of Alan Menken and Jack Feldman's songs and the youthful exuberance of the cast, under Jeff Calhoun's sprightly direction.

8
Thumbs Up

Disney's 'Newsies' won't break news but it still delivers

From: USA Today  |  Date: 3/29/2012

Newsies' contrivances are served with a light, knowing touch, and made even more palatable by the easy infectiousness of Alan Menken and Jack Feldman's songs and the youthful exuberance of the cast, under Jeff Calhoun's sprightly direction.

6
Thumbs Sideways

'Once' has one edge on 'Jesus Christ': It's quieter

From: USA Today  |  Date: 3/22/2012

Rather than try to cut through the rock-operatic bombast of Andrew Lloyd Webber's music and Tim Rice's lyrics, director Des McAnuff revels in it. Though intermittently moving and seldom dull, this account of Jesus' final days on Earth isn't recommended to anyone with a low tolerance for pomp. Or a headache, for that matter.

8
Thumbs Up

It's very easy to buy into new 'Death of a Salesman' revival

From: USA Today  |  Date: 3/15/2012

Garfield vividly traces Biff's evolution from a confident, charismatic teenager to a man crippled by his father's expectations and mistakes. The U.K.-bred actor's body language, spry and vigorous in youthful scenes, slackens; even his canny New York accent sharpens, as a local's might, in excitement or under duress. ... All the performances are at once authentic and timeless, much like Jo Mielziner's abstract set design and Alex North's haunting incidental music, both restored from 1949's original staging.

Wit Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

'Wit' benefits from Cynthia Nixon's wisdom

From: USA Today  |  Date: 1/26/2012

No doubt Vivian's struggle to soften her perspective while retaining her dignity will still resonate with many women. But the severity of her isolation and her steady (if rocky) path to enlightenment seem a little contrived. Other characters, too, can come across less as real human beings than as vehicles for Edson's message...It may not be Nixon's finest hour (and 40 minutes) on the New York stage, but it's a joy to have her back.

9
Thumbs Up

We loves you, new 'Porgy and Bess'

From: USA Today  |  Date: 1/12/2012

The show proves an especially winning vehicle for leading lady Audra McDonald. Where her dramatic soprano has seemed a little heavy or stiff in other musical-theater roles, she invests Bess' songs with both technical authority and a fluid, full-bodied sense of character that extends to her spoken lines. Tracing the drug-addled Bess' attempt to turn her life around under Porgy's loving guidance, McDonald is by turns tender and crass, droll and desperate, and always wrenchingly human. As Porgy, the less-celebrated Norm Lewis is a revelation. That the character walks with a cane here, rather than using the traditional goat cart, only emphasizes the contrast between his lame body and his bursting heart. Hobbling toward McDonald or carefully leaning in to embrace her, Lewis' eyes burn with a soulful urgency that matches his robust baritone.

9
Thumbs Up

We loves you, new 'Porgy and Bess'

From: USA Today  |  Date: 1/12/2012

The show proves an especially winning vehicle for leading lady Audra McDonald. Where her dramatic soprano has seemed a little heavy or stiff in other musical-theater roles, she invests Bess' songs with both technical authority and a fluid, full-bodied sense of character that extends to her spoken lines. Tracing the drug-addled Bess' attempt to turn her life around under Porgy's loving guidance, McDonald is by turns tender and crass, droll and desperate, and always wrenchingly human. As Porgy, the less-celebrated Norm Lewis is a revelation. That the character walks with a cane here, rather than using the traditional goat cart, only emphasizes the contrast between his lame body and his bursting heart. Hobbling toward McDonald or carefully leaning in to embrace her, Lewis' eyes burn with a soulful urgency that matches his robust baritone.

8
Thumbs Up

Plot is a bit cloudy, but 'Clear Day' musical still shines

From: USA Today  |  Date: 12/11/2011

The muddled but appealing production that opened Sunday at the St. James Theatre shares the title with and features characters and songs from the show and movie. But as reconceived by director Michael Mayer, with a new libretto by Peter Parnell, this On a Clear Day (* * * out of four) challenges our ability to suspend disbelief in even more dizzying ways.

Bonnie & Clyde Broadway
6
Thumbs Sideways

Musical 'Bonnie & Clyde' aims high and low, misses the mark

From: USA Today  |  Date: 12/1/2011

But even as played by a pair of appealing, charismatic young actors, these two never emerge as the populist anti-heroes that the writers clearly had in mind. Laura Osnes' fresh beauty and understated sauciness can mitigate this Bonnie's moony, moody antics only so much, while Jeremy Jordan's robust singing and graceful swagger just make the hollowness of Clyde's narcissism — and of the generic vocal showcases that Black and Wildhorn provide him — more obvious.

Seminar Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Alan Rickman is head of a talented class in 'Seminar'

From: USA Today  |  Date: 11/20/2011

Thanks to these performances, Seminar proves an enriching study.

Private Lives Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

Kim Cattrall outgrows Samantha in 'Private Lives'

From: USA Today  |  Date: 11/17/2011

It helps that esteemed director Richard Eyre applies a light, sure hand, and the actors show a similar ease and dexterity. Cattrall's Amanda is adorably feminine, with a breezy, un-self-conscious energy that mitigates the character's narcissism. As the equally narcissistic Elyot, Canadian actor Paul Gross is less endearing but just as entertaining.

8
Thumbs Up

Hugh Jackman retracts claws, revisits stage roots

From: USA Today  |  Date: 11/10/2011

3 out of four. There are endearing twists, as well - an aboriginal-themed Over the Rainbow, a reworking of a rhythmic spoken-word sequence from The Music Man as a campy hip-hop number. If Jackman knows how to please a crowd, he can also take it in unexpected directions, with seductive enthusiasm.

8
Thumbs Up

Hugh Jackman retracts claws, revisits stage roots

From: USA Today  |  Date: 11/10/2011

3 out of four. There are endearing twists, as well - an aboriginal-themed Over the Rainbow, a reworking of a rhythmic spoken-word sequence from The Music Man as a campy hip-hop number. If Jackman knows how to please a crowd, he can also take it in unexpected directions, with seductive enthusiasm.

10
Thumbs Up

New play 'Other Desert Cities' is oasis of humor, poignance

From: USA Today  |  Date: 11/3/2011

The expert cast, under Joe Mantello's thoughtful direction, mines the resulting conflicts for all their hilarity and poignance. After Brooke pours her heart out defending her book, Thomas Sadoski's witty Trip offers an equally passionate (and entertaining) summation of the selfishness in her suffering and healing. And when Channing's pitch-perfect Polly clashes with her sister - a recovering alcoholic, played by Judith Light, who suggests what Brooke might become if she fully disappeared up her own navel - neither is victorious or vanquished.

5
Thumbs Sideways

A mixed bag on Broadway

From: USA Today  |  Date: 10/20/2011

This collection of short plays, which opened Thursday at Broadway's Brooks Atkinson Theatre, proves that similar extremes can apply to theater. For these accounts of homegrown neuroses — by veteran wits Elaine May, Ethan Coen and Woody Allen— offer both disarming highs and disappointing lows.

Man and Boy Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

Frank Langella is the 'Man,' and it shows

From: USA Today  |  Date: 10/9/2011

It's ultimately Langella's show, though. His Gregor comes on as icy-smooth as Dracula. But as his fortunes threaten to crumble, the actor lets that fa?ade dissolve, subtly and masterfully. This mogul is a complicated man who never appears entirely defeated. 'Never, in the future, let the truth make you cry,' Gregor tells Basil in a particularly dark moment. It's a bit of practical advice that seems as timely as ever at this juncture.

Master Class Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

Stalwart Tyne Daly leads bravura 'Master Class'

From: USA Today  |  Date: 7/10/2011

McNally's love song to Callas may be, like his heroine, a more florid and flawed piece of work. Still, Daly and her fellow performers make this Master Class well worth attending.

8
Thumbs Up

'Spider-Man' (finally) soars onstage

From: USA Today  |  Date: 6/14/2011

Essential elements of that production remain, along with the flying feats and other high-tech visuals. But the new Spider-Man is cuter and more cautious than its predecessor, more in line with the winking musical adaptations of famous films and brands that have lined the theater district in recent years. Clearly, producers heeded the critics and fans who hoped to see the title character represented more as he'd been in comic books and movies. Specifically, that meant streamlining the story to eliminate a love triangle involving the spider-woman Arachne, who in 1.0 emerged as both protector and nemesis to Spider-Man/Peter Parker and rival to Mary Jane, Peter's girlfriend. The Arachne of 2.0 is a simpler, sweeter creature; the antagonist is now scientist Norm Osborn's deranged alter ego, the Green Goblin, who views Peter/Spidey as his wayward son.

Sister Act Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

'Sister Act': Most entertaining nuns, bar none

From: USA Today  |  Date: 4/20/2011

The latest entry, Sister Act: A Divine Musical Comedy (***½out of four), may be less giddily profane, and thought-provoking, than The Book of Mormon, but it has its own distinct and surprising charms. Composer Alan Menken and lyricist Glenn Slater provide original tunes that nod cheekily, but with genuine affection, to that pop era while also propelling the story with a style and exuberance specific to well-crafted musical theater.

War Horse Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

Puppetry, music bring 'War Horse' to vivid life

From: USA Today  |  Date: 4/17/2011

Little wonder that Steven Spielberg is bringing War Horse to the big screen in December — with real horses. But anyone who can should see this marvelous, life-affirming play first. You'll leave the theater emotionally spent but exhilarated.

9
Thumbs Up

'Mother------ With the Hat': Fittingly great

From: USA Today  |  Date: 4/11/2011

Rock proves both a bold and canny choice for Ralph, a less sympathetic figure. More likable and less palpably ego-driven than many comedians of his generation, Rock doesn't exude the kind of crass narcissism that the sponsor eventually reveals...By not putting characters or their dilemmas in neat boxes, Guirgis gives us, in Hat, a slice of hard life that's as provocative as it is absorbing.

9
Thumbs Up

'Mother------ With the Hat': Fittingly great

From: USA Today  |  Date: 4/11/2011

Rock proves both a bold and canny choice for Ralph, a less sympathetic figure. More likable and less palpably ego-driven than many comedians of his generation, Rock doesn't exude the kind of crass narcissism that the sponsor eventually reveals...By not putting characters or their dilemmas in neat boxes, Guirgis gives us, in Hat, a slice of hard life that's as provocative as it is absorbing.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $106
Hot Show
Tickets From $170