Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre Kicks Off 40th Season With ARSENIC & OLD LACE, Now thru 2/3

By:

Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre opens its 2013 season a few days early with the famous killer comedy, ARSENIC & OLD LACE! The classic comedy kicks off the theatre's year-long 40th Anniversary celebration, and is on stage tonight, December 28th through February 3rd.

Brewster sisters Martha and Abby are charming and innocent ladies who have taken it upon themselves to help lonely men. With a little arsenic, strychnine and just a pinch of cyanide in a glass of homemade elderberry wine, their guests are unburdened of their unhappy lives. Quietly the bodies of these socially and religiously "acceptable" roomers begin to populate their cellar, with the unwitting assistance of their loony brother Teddy, who thinks he is Theodore Roosevelt digging locks for the Panama Canal.

Their charity continues smoothly until being discovered by their nephew, Mortimer. A theatre critic who is preparing to marry, Mortimer is shocked to learn the truth - and he only becomes more frantic when his maniacal uncle Jonathan makes a surprise visit!

Made popular by the 1941 Frank Capra film starring Cary Grant, ARSENIC & OLD LACE proves things are not always what they seem.

David Schmittou, last seen at Beef & Boards as Cornelius Hackl in Hello, Dolly!, returns in the role of Mortimer. Karen Pappas, popular with Beef & Boards audiences from her portrayal of the hilarious Mavis in the Church Basement Ladies series, plays Abby Brewster, while newcomer Gerri Weagraff plays her sister, Martha. Several more Beef & Boards favorites round out the cast with Douglas E. Stark in the role of loony Teddy Brewster, Jeff Stockberger as the sinister Jonathan Brewster and Eddie Curry as Jonathan's sidekick, Dr. Einstein. Another newcomer, Lisa Ermel plays the role of Mortimer's fiancée, Elaine Harper.

Looking for a killer night out for New Year's Eve? Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre presents a special performance of ARSENIC & OLD LACE, complete with party favors and more! Enjoy dinner and the show, followed by dancing to the Blue Bus band before ringing in the New Year with a balloon drop and champagne toast. Then enjoy Chef Odell Ward's breakfast buffet, served after midnight! All seats for this special evening are $75.

There are 37 performances of ARSENIC & OLD LACE scheduled in the intimate setting provided by Beef & Boards. Tickets range from $37.50 to $62.50 ($75 for the New Year's Eve celebration) and include Chef Odell Ward's dinner buffet, fruit & salad bar, and select beverages. Discounts are available for children and groups of 20 or more. Parking is free. For reservations call the box office at 317-872-9664. Hours are 10 am to 7 pm Tuesday through Sunday, and 10 am to 5 pm on Mondays. For complete show schedule, visit www.beefandboards.com.

Don't Miss a Indianapolis News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Memphis The Musical in Indianapolis Memphis The Musical
Marian Theatre (9/19-9/26) PHOTOS
Summer Stock Stage: Dear Evan Hansen in Indianapolis Summer Stock Stage: Dear Evan Hansen
Howard L. Schrott Center for the Arts (8/05-8/09)
Matt Rife in Indianapolis Matt Rife
Gainbridge Fieldhouse (11/08-11/08)
The Rocky Horror Spooktacular Tour with Barry Bostwick in Indianapolis The Rocky Horror Spooktacular Tour with Barry Bostwick
Old National Centre (10/21-10/21)
The Space Left Behind in Indianapolis The Space Left Behind
Ruth N. Halls Theatre (12/11-12/12)
Summer Stock Stage: Dear Evan Hansen ASL- Interpreted Performance in Indianapolis Summer Stock Stage: Dear Evan Hansen ASL- Interpreted Performance
Howard L. Schrott Center for the Arts (8/08-8/08)
Busy Dying in Indianapolis Busy Dying
Wells-Metz Theatre (1/21-1/23)
The Del Mccoury Band in Indianapolis The Del Mccoury Band
Honeywell Center (11/14-11/14)
Jonathan Van Ness: Hot & Healed Comedy Tour 2026 (18+) in Indianapolis Jonathan Van Ness: Hot & Healed Comedy Tour 2026 (18+)
Old National Centre (9/13-9/13)
Dancing in the Aisles: The Ultimate Motown Experience in Indianapolis in Indianapolis Dancing in the Aisles: The Ultimate Motown Experience in Indianapolis
Basile Theatre at the Historic Athenaeum (7/26-7/26)