Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: CCT's Summer Youth Conservatory's ONCE ON THIS ISLAND JR. - A Touching Story of Eternal Love in a Land Divided

Sara Tuohy
Photo Credit: David Heasley

Columbus Children's Theatre's (CCT) international award-winning Summer Youth Performance Conservatory presents ONCE ON THIS ISLAND JR., directed by Ryan Scarlata, opening today, July 27, and running thru August 7 at the Park Street Theatre. Featuring a talented troupe of 30 ranging from ages 10-15, these kids have worked diligently for most of the summer to tell the story of forbidden love on an island divided by social prejudice.

Based on Rosa Guy's 1985 'My Love, My Love,' which is also inspired by 'The Little Mermaid,' ONCE ON THIS ISLAND JR, although possessing elements of a 'Romeo and Juliet' tragedy, is also infused with hope and reassurance, together with colorful costumes and beautiful music by Stephen Flaherty.

The story follows Ti Moune (Sara Tuohy), a young peasant girl who is rescued from a tree and raised by poor couple, Mama Euralie and Tonton Julian (Megan Masciola and Kyle Channell, respectively), on an island in the French Antilles. When Ti Moune grows up, she prays to the Gods to let her know her purpose and she is granted the gift of love. Her love is tested when the Gods arrange for the car of wealthy boy Daniel Beauxhomme (Kyle Swearingen) to crash so that Ti Moune can restore him back to health.

Amirah Lomax and Company
Photo Credit: David Heasley

While at his side day in and day out, Ti Moune falls in love with the ailing Daniel and dreams of a future with him. The Demon of Death, Papa Ge (David Rausch), appears to take Daniel's life, but Ti Moune begs him to take her own life in exchange for the boy. This scene is obviously reminiscent of Ursula taking Ariel's voice in THE LITTLE MERMAID.

Tonton then travels to the other side of the island to seek Daniel's family and let them know of his whereabouts. When Daniel's people take him back home, a tearful Ti Moune vows that her purpose is to go after him to marry him. With determination and a heart full of love, Ti Moune sets off on a quest that will test the strength of her love against the powerful forces of prejudice, hatred, and even death.

The entire cast and ensemble give a spectacular performance in each of their roles. However, the star of the show, Sara Tuohy, truly shines as Ti Moune, a naive but courageous peasant girl motivated by curiosity and love. She evokes sympathy with her emotional plea to the Gods in "Waiting for Life" and balances her strong vocals with tender cries and great acting skills.

Kyle Channell plays a strong and supportive Tonton, and Megan Masciola is loving and nurturing as Mama Euralie. She gives a tear-jerking and passionate performance of "A Part of Us" as she holds Ti Moune in a loving, tearful embrace.

The Company
Photo Credit: David Heasley

Amirah Lomax gives a stand-out performance as Asaka the Goddess of the Earth. She is confident and sassy, and shows vocal maturity beyond her years, especially in the song "Mama Will Provide." Katie Wager as Erzulie the Goddess of Love gives a touching performance in "The Human Heart," Mitchell Kallner as Agwe the God of Water captures the audience's attention with "Rain," and David Rausch leaves us with chills as the evil Papa Ge, Demon of Death. He is especially frightening in "Forever Yours" and "Promises."

Other cast members deserve recognition, including Kyle Swearingen (Daniel), Maria Dalanno (Andrea), Amelia Cameron (Little Ti Moune), and Avery Bank, Toby Hattemer, Kate Mason and Gabe Woerner as the storytellers.

The costumes by Dayton Willison and choreography by Megan Shepston Overly add color and brightness to the show, and Freddie G. Award-winning Director Ryan Scarlata moves the show along at a swift pace without losing its heartfelt tone.

It is a story of love and forgiveness and believing our lives are a story to share. Come see CCT's Summer Youth Performance Conservatory of ONCE ON THIS ISLAND JR., now playing thru August 7th before they head off to Atlanta to compete in the annual Junior Theatre Festival on a national level. Although the story is somewhat mature, young ones will appreciate the colorful costumes, fun choreography, and fairy-tale story. And at only 60 minutes, even the youngest will be entranced.

Performances run Wednesdays thru Fridays at 10am, Fridays at 7:30pm, and Saturdays and Sundays at 1pm and 3pm. For tickets, visit:, call CAPA: 614-469-0939 or the CCT box office: 614-224-6672.

Review: SLAVE PLAY at Short North Stage Photo
What did our critic think of SLAVE PLAY at Short North Stage? People always ask critics two questions: “did you like it?” and “is it worth seeing?” When it comes time to discuss SLAVE PLAY, these two questions are going to be tough to answer. Did I like it? From a theatrical rubric, it checks off the boxes of fantastic acting and wonderful direction, and powerful message. However, is it enjoyable? At times yes … and sometimes it felt like a punch to the stomach.  

Photos: First look at The Alcove Dinner Theatre and Bruce Jacklin & Companys STEEL MAG Photo
Don't miss this hilarious and touching comedy about friendship through the good times and the bad. Join us at Truvy's beauty salon, where all the ladies who are 'anybody' come to have their hair done. By Robert Harling, Directed by Bruce Jacklin, performed by Bruce Jacklin & Company, the Cast includes: Courtney Decosky, Megan Bell, Kelly Lauth, Sage Szucs, CateBlair-Wilhelm, Jackie Bates Performances are Feb.3 - Mar. 4 , 2023, at The Alcove Dinner Theatre, 116 South Main St., Mount Vernon, OH 43050. For tickets or more information, visit:

Photos: First look at Gallery Players INTIMATE APPAREL Photo
The time is 1905, the place the Lower East Side. Sewing beautiful lingerie gives Esther, an African American seamstress, an intimate look at the love lives of her diverse clientele, but she yearns for a romance of her own. She finds herself in an epistolary courtship with a mysterious Caribbean man, though her heart secretly belongs to the Orthodox Jewish fabric merchant with whom she can never share a touch. Written by two-time Pulitzer Prize-winner and MacArthur “Genius Grant” Awardee Lynn Nottage (Sweat, Ruined), this moving portrait of love, resilience, and the triumph of the human spirit has become one of the most beloved plays of our time. By Lynn Nottage, Directed by Julie Whitney Scott Cast: Esther - Latifat Sulaimon, George - El-Ryck Kendrick, Mayme - Brooklyn Smith, Mr. Marks - Jacob Erney, Mrs. Dickson - Cathy Bean, Mrs. Van Buren - Ella Palardi, Piano Player - Kelton D Waller. Performances run Feb. 4 - 12, 2023. Gallery Players, 1125 College Ave., Columbus, Ohio 43209. Please visit to get specific showtimes and purchase tickets.

Photos: First Look At Imagine Productions 35MM: A MUSICAL EXHIBITION Photo
A picture is worth 1,000 words — what about a song? Can a picture inspire a song or fifteen? In 35mm, each photo creates a unique song, moments frozen in time; a glimmer of a life unfolding, a glimpse of something happening. A stunning new multimedia musical which explores a groundbreaking new concept in musical theatre... This intricately woven collection of stories told through song reimagines what the modern American musical can be.

From This Author - Christina Mancuso

Christina Mancuso, a mother of 3, has traveled to well over 70 cities on various Broadway National Tours.  She is now residing in her hometown of Columbus, Ohio after spending a year in NYC to... (read more about this author)

BWW Review: HAIRSPRAY at Ohio Theatre - An Inspiring Musical with Blazing EnergyBWW Review: HAIRSPRAY at Ohio Theatre - An Inspiring Musical with Blazing Energy
November 9, 2022

The audience was thrilled to welcome home Columbus’s own sextuple superstar, Andrew Levitt aka Nina West, who has successfully conquered the entertainment genres of TV, film, theatre, music, web series, and most recently as an author of children’s book, “The You Kind of Kind.”  His role as Edna Turnblad is just icing on the cake.

BWW Review: Transcendence Theatre's 'Let's Dance' Celebrates Diversity Through DanceBWW Review: Transcendence Theatre's 'Let's Dance' Celebrates Diversity Through Dance
June 20, 2022

California Wine Country's award-winning Transcendence Theatre Company returned once again to the incomparable Jack London State Historic Park to celebrate its 11th season. And what better way to celebrate than through dance. Directed by acclaimed international director and choreographer Luis Salgado, 'Let's Dance' features a cast and creative team of international talent from all across the country and beyond, including Puerto Rico, Colombia and Spain. Salgado's vision was to 'bring the flavor of Latin culture to Broadway classics and present a show that is bold, high-energy, and embraced by all.' And that is exactly what he did.

BWW Review: WICKED Flies High at the Ohio TheatreBWW Review: WICKED Flies High at the Ohio Theatre
May 20, 2022

Winning more than 100 international awards including three Tony Awards and a Grammy Award, WICKED has managed to cast its spell on more than 60 million people across the globe for nearly two decades, and is still going strong today. Read our critic's review.

BWW Review: PRETTY WOMAN at the Ohio Theatre - Powerful Vocals Despite Dated MaterialBWW Review: PRETTY WOMAN at the Ohio Theatre - Powerful Vocals Despite Dated Material
March 30, 2022

An illustrious creative team is at the helm of PRETTY WOMAN: THE MUSICAL, with direction and choreography by two-time Tony Award®-winner Jerry Mitchell, music and lyrics by Grammy®-winner Bryan Adams and Jim Vallance, and book by the movie's legendary director Garry Marshall and screenwriter J. F. Lawton.  But is that enough to make this stage adaptation successful?  That depends.

BWW Review: COME FROM AWAY Lands at the Ohio Theatre - Celebrating the Power of HumanityBWW Review: COME FROM AWAY Lands at the Ohio Theatre - Celebrating the Power of Humanity
February 9, 2022

Nominated for seven Tony awards in 2017 and winning Best Direction in a Musical under Christopher Ashley’s extraordinary direction, COME FROM AWAY landed in Columbus at the Ohio Theatre on Tuesday night to a welcoming and lively audience.