My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: OKLAHOMA! at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre

Dutch Apple production is much more than OK!

By:
Review: OKLAHOMA! at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre

Click here for video preview of the production!

Giddy-up! Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre brings the Rogers and Hammerstein classic, Oklahoma to the Lancaster stage. This landmark show is often considered the granddaddy of the modern musical, and with good reason.  It is one of the first (and best) shows to cohesively blend song, story, and dance to advance the plot.

Connor Raposa is well-cast as Curly the rugged cowboy with a soft heart. Raposa has a friendly disposition and plays his character as confident, yet approachable.  Jenna Willet starts as Laurey, the playful young miss, who enjoys the attention of the men folk, but sometimes gets in over her head.  Willet did a fine job of alternating between portraying the character’s sassy, confident exterior, and a reluctant, fearful interior.

Cody Howard plays villain, Jud Fry with maximum creepiness.  His hesitant movement, slouched posture and lack of eye contact causes audience distrust and caution towards him, without leaning into a bad guy caricature.

Oklahoma is an especially strong show for supporting characters and Dutch Apple’s production is no exception.  Caroline Bowers is delightful as the quirky, opinionated Ado Annie. She brings great humor and attitude to the part. 

Speaking of humor, Zach Ryan’s portrayal as Ali Hakim was an absolute riot.  He has excellent comic timing, and his portrayal shows great depth.  He totally sidesteps any and all potential Middle Eastern stereotypes.  Instead (in my opinion), he is simply a local con man trying to seem more exotic and mysterious than he actually is.

Finally, Tricia Corcoran is a lot of fun as Aunt Eller. She reflects great wisdom and strength in her portrayal.  In fact, I find it interesting and under-appreciated how bold, smart and confident all of the females are portrayed in a show that is over 80 years old.  It reflects the sense of independence and ruggedness required of Midwesterners of that era.

Ford Hauser serves as both director and choreographer and does a fine job with both.  His interpretation of the classic dream ballet was well-done. For whatever reason, I do feel that the stage looked cramped at times, especially during numbers involving the entire cast.  This is ironic, since Oklahoma! deals with themes of freedom, exploration, and expansion.

As usual, A. Scott Williams does a great job as conductor of the show’s five-piece orchestra.  It’s a shame the off-stage musicians do not always get the recognition or appreciation that they deserve.

Oklahoma! is an iconic musical that still holds up pretty well today.  It does run a little on the long side, especially considering that the plot conflicts are relatively low-stakes.  However, those factors do not detract from the audience’s appreciation of the extremely catchy melodies, festive dance numbers, and genuinely funny dialogue.  Saddle up and go see this classic show.



Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Direction of a Play - Top 3
1. Joe Mantello - Death of a Salesman
20.7% of votes
2. Duncan MacMillan, Jeremy Herrin - Every Brilliant Thing
15.5% of votes
3. Whitney White - Liberation
9.2% of votes

Need more Central Pennsylvania Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


A Night with Janis Joplin in Central Pennsylvania A Night with Janis Joplin
Gretna Theatre (6/18-6/21)
Always... Patsy Cline in Central Pennsylvania Always... Patsy Cline
Gretna Theatre (6/04-6/07)
Meredith Willson's The Music Man in Central Pennsylvania Meredith Willson's The Music Man
Appell Center for the Performing Arts (6/09-6/09)
Bat Out Of Hell 50th Anniversary Tour - Venue Premium Tickets in Central Pennsylvania Bat Out Of Hell 50th Anniversary Tour - Venue Premium Tickets
York Barbican (4/30-4/30)
Trainspotting The Musical in Central Pennsylvania Trainspotting The Musical
Grand Opera House, York (11/09-11/14)
Count Arthur Strong - Venue Premium Tickets in Central Pennsylvania Count Arthur Strong - Venue Premium Tickets
York Barbican (5/08-5/08)
West Side Story in Central Pennsylvania West Side Story
Fulton Theatre (6/12-7/12)
Murder Trial Tonight V - Death in the Family - Venue Premium Tickets in Central Pennsylvania Murder Trial Tonight V - Death in the Family - Venue Premium Tickets
York Barbican (4/04-4/04)
Hadestown Teen Edition in Central Pennsylvania Hadestown Teen Edition
DreamWrights Center for Community Arts (6/05-6/14)
Clybourne Park in Central Pennsylvania Clybourne Park
DreamWrights Center for Community Arts (10/16-10/24)