| Awards | Category | Nominee | Show |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Edith Oliver Service to Off-Broadway Award | Harold Wolpert | Harold Wolpert |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Lifetime Achievement Award | William Ivey Long | William Ivey Long |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Choreographer | David Neumann | Hadestown |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Choreographer | David Dorfman | Indecent |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Choreographer | Georgina Lamb | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Choreographer | Joshua Bergasse | Sweet Charity |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Choreographer | David Neumann | The Total Bent |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Costume Design | Emily Rebholz | Indecent |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Costume Design | Susan Hilferty | Love, Love, Love |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Costume Design | Sarah Laux | The Band's Visit |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Costume Design | Montana Blanco | The Death of the Last Black Man in the Whole Entire World AKA the Negro Book of the Dead |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Costume Design | Tilly Grimes | Underground Railroad Game |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Director | Anne Kauffman | A Life |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Director | Rebecca Taichman | Indecent |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Director | Will Davis | Men On Boats |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Director | Bartlett Sher | Oslo |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Director | Lila Neugebauer | The Wolves |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Chris Sullivan | Hadestown |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Gus Halper | Ride the Cyclone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Joel Perez | Sweet Charity |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Ari'el Stachel | The Band's Visit |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Nathan Lee Graham | The View UpStairs |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Charlie Cox | Incognito |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Michael Aronov | Oslo |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Matthew Maher | Othello |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Paco Tolson | Vietgone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Justice Smith | YEN |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Rachel Bay Jones | Dear Evan Hansen |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Karen Ziemba | Kid Victory |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Emily Rohm | Ride the Cyclone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Betsy Morgan | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Asmeret Ghebremichael | Sweet Charity |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Jocelyn Bioh | Everybody |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Nana Mensah | Man From Nebraska |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Randy Graff | The Babylon Line |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Hannah Cabell | The Moors |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Ari Graynor | YEN |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical | Ben Platt | Dear Evan Hansen |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical | Patrick Page | Hadestown |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical | Jeremy Secomb | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical | Shuler Hensley | Sweet Charity |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical | Ato Blankson-Wood | The Total Bent |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play | David Hyde Pierce | A Life |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play | Reed Birney | Man From Nebraska |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play | Joe Morton | Turn Me Loose |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play | Michael Emerson | Wakey, Wakey |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play | Lucas Hedges | YEN |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical | Amber Gray | Hadestown |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical | Jo Lampert | Joan of Arc: Into the Fire |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical | Siobhan McCarthy | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical | Sutton Foster | Sweet Charity |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical | Katrina Lenk | The Band's Visit |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play | Kecia Lewis | Marie and Rosetta |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play | Jennifer Ehle | Oslo |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play | Johanna Day | Sweat |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play | Jennifer Kidwell | Underground Railroad Game |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play | Maryann Plunkett | Women of a Certain Age |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lighting Design | Jane Cox | Othello |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lighting Design | Greg Hofmann | Ride the Cyclone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lighting Design | Mark Barton | Signature Plays: Edward Albee's The Sandbox, María Irene Fornés' Drowning, and Adrienne Kennedy's Funnyhouse of a Negro |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lighting Design | Amy Mae | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Lighting Design | Ben Stanton | YEN |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Musical | Dear Evan Hansen | Dear Evan Hansen |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Musical | Hadestown | Hadestown |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Musical | Ride the Cyclone | Ride the Cyclone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Musical | The Band's Visit | The Band's Visit |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Musical | The Total Bent | The Total Bent |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Play | Paula Vogel | Indecent |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Play | J.T. Rogers | Oslo |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Play | Sarah DeLappe | The Wolves |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Play | Jennifer Kidwell | Underground Railroad Game |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Play | Qui Nguyen | Vietgone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Projection Design | Peter Nigrini | Dear Evan Hansen |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Projection Design | Elaine McCarthy | Notes From The Field |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Projection Design | Duncan McLean | Privacy |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Projection Design | Jared Mezzochi | Vietgone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Projection Design | Peter Nigrini | Wakey, Wakey |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Revival | Othello | Othello |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Revival | Signature Plays: Edward Albee's The Sandbox, María Irene Fornés' Drowning, and Adrienne Kennedy's Funnyhouse of a Negro | Signature Plays: Edward Albee's The Sandbox, María Irene Fornés' Drowning, and Adrienne Kennedy's Funnyhouse of a Negro |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Revival | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Revival | Sweet Charity | Sweet Charity |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Revival | The Death of the Last Black Man in the Whole Entire World AKA the Negro Book of the Dead | The Death of the Last Black Man in the Whole Entire World AKA the Negro Book of the Dead |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Scenic Design | Laura Jellinek | A Life |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Scenic Design | Rachel Hauck | Hadestown |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Scenic Design | Scott Davis | Ride the Cyclone |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Scenic Design | Mimi Lien | Signature Plays: Edward Albee's The Sandbox, María Irene Fornés' Drowning, and Adrienne Kennedy's Funnyhouse of a Negro |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Scenic Design | Jason Sherwood | The View UpStairs |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Solo Show | Chris Gethard | Chris Gethard: Career Suicide |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Solo Show | John Leguizamo | Latin History for Morons |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Solo Show | Anna Deavere Smith | Notes From The Field |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Solo Show | Sarah Jones | Sell/Buy/Date |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Solo Show | Ethan Lipton | The Outer Space |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Sound Design | Mikhail Fiksel | A Life |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Sound Design | Robert Kaplowitz | Hadestown |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Sound Design | Stowe Nelson | Small Mouth Sounds |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Sound Design | Matt Stine | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Outstanding Sound Design | Nevin Steinberg | Wakey, Wakey |
| Lucille Lortel Awards | Playwrights' Sidewalk Inductee | Lynn Nottage | Lynn Nottage |
