EDINBURGH 2026: Review: MUSE: THE SHAKESPEARE MAYHEM MUSICAL, Underbelly Cowbarn
William Shakespeare’s greatest creations collide in a pop-infused battle for top billing at Underbelly's Cowbarn.
The premise of Muse: The Shakespeare Mayhem Musical is an undeniably playful hook for any theatre lover: gather William Shakespeare’s iconic characters under one roof to battle out who deserves top billing in his sole published folio. Taking a cue from SIX (which famously began its journey right here at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe) the influence is clear, but this new musical struggles to find a cohesive rhythm.
Rather than feeling like a fully integrated piece, the narrative often plays out like an acting-school showcase where performers step forward to deliver Shakespearean monologues. The energy stays afloat thanks to two standout songs: "Romeo's Dead" and a show-stopping plea for mercy from Portia, whose grounded, magnetic performance provides a much-needed emotional highlight for the show.
Outside of these musical high points, the script choices grow murky. Anne Hathaway’s subplot, casting her as a conspiring assassin scheming alongside the Macbeths, feels wildly misplaced leaving her without a clear dramatic purpose. Furthermore, a nod to theatre superstition stumbles on its own lore: claiming "Macbeth" cannot be spoken in a theatre confuses the play's title with the character's name, diluting a fun Scottish stage joke.
The cast possesses genuine isolated talent, but the ensemble work needs tightening to nail the fast-paced comedic beat-awareness this premise demands. Ending on a dream-sequence resolution, the climax feels unearned compared to the sharp thematic message of SIX. It remains a cute, promising concept, but one that needs significant revision to become a standout.
Muse: The Shakespeare Mayhem Musical plays at Underbelly’s Cowbarn until August 31, 2026
Get Broadway News on WhatsApp
Receive the latest updates, breaking news, and exclusive coverage from Broadway directly in WhatsApp.
Love Theater in Ireland? Join The Community!
Whether you've got past experience writing about theater or just starting, the BroadwayWorld Community offers a unique opportunity to become a champion for your local arts community, helping raise awareness of local offerings and adding another local voice to the conversation at a time arts coverage is shrinking in the press across the continent. Join us and become a pivotal part of the movement that celebrates and promotes the arts in the digital age.
Learn More
|
Dracula Gaiety Theatre (11/03-11/07) |
|
Steve Steinman''s Fuel Injected Magic: 50th Anniversary Concert 3Olympia Theatre (10/20-10/20) |
|
Failure Confetti The New Theatre (9/16-9/19) |
|
David Nihill: Taking Tangents The Everyman (10/03-10/03) |
|
Disney Princess: the Concert 3Olympia Theatre (4/21-4/22) |
|
|
Steve Steinman''s Bat! Bat Out of Hell 50th Anniversary Tour 3Olympia Theatre (10/20-10/20) |
|
Stories from the Sea The Everyman (9/26-9/26) |
|
|
Give My Head Peace Vicar Street (4/04-4/04) |
|
Cana Talks: Optimal Horizons Opium (10/08-10/08) |
|
|
Murder Trial Tonight V - Death in the Family 3Olympia Theatre (3/08-3/08) |
Reader Reviews
To post a comment, you must register and login.