Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE LAST FIVE YEARS at Taganka Theatre

Review: THE LAST FIVE YEARS at Taganka Theatre

18 years ago a love story by Jason Robert Brown premiered in Chicago. Today, it is translated into several languages and was shown in Stockholm, Basel, Belfast, Paris, London, etc. Now, it's coming to Moscow.

A musical directed by Alexey Frandetti tells a story about the relationship between Jamie and Cathy within five years. It's simple as that: a Jewish aspiring writer meets an aspiring actress, they fall in love, get married, Jamie becomes a successful novelist, Cathy is struggling with her career, Jamie cheats on her and they split up. To me, this is hardly interesting but the format of leading the show simultaneously backwards and forwards (when Cathy is at the end of their relationship and Jamie is at the beginning) is rather fascinating.

However, while it can be amusing, it gets boring by the middle of the show ("The Next Ten Minutes" - a proposal/wedding scene) because decorations are unable to compensate for the insufficient story. "The Next Ten Minutes" musical number lacks on-stage action (the wedding happens on the screen) and lasts for more than 7 minutes which makes it almost unbearable to watch.

Review: THE LAST FIVE YEARS at Taganka Theatre

The show is visually appealing: big windows with views of New York; colourful set and props, beautiful actors, but it cannot offset such ordinary story which definitely needs some more metaphors (apart from time in terms of structure and symbols) and unique approaches.

Speaking of actors, the small-scale musical demands only two of them, hence everyone has to be perfect. Cathy is played by Marfa Coltsova, who possesses wonderful comedic talent. A role of Jamie is performed by Pavel Levkin who, as it seems, now switched from parts of various princes and silly lovers (he was the Beast in "Beauty and the Beast", Prince in "Cinderella", Antony in "Sweeney Todd") to playing New Yorkers in love stories: Sam in "Ghost", Jamie here and Aaron in the upcoming production of "First Date". Marfa and Pavel form a good cast, being able to make the audience laugh and empathize, but they still need a bit more time to work some things out.

Review: THE LAST FIVE YEARS at Taganka Theatre

Jokes were not lost in translation, though they sometimes seemed childish and awkward (maybe it's just me). The music is nice but kind of repetitive and too uniform. I like that it's set on the Small stage of the theatre: sometimes the show is performed on larger scenes and the amount of space could be unnecessary (but also could be a metaphor for how characters are away from each other). I can assess a musical by my wish to rewatch it. To see "The Last Five Years" again - I think I'll pass.

Photo Credit: Yury Bogomaz

BroadwayWorld Shop
Shop BroadwayWorld

Shop this season's new musicals! Get dressed up for a night at the theatre, or just a night at home, with merch from some of Broadway's biggest hits including SOME LIKE IT HOT, KIMBERLY AKIMBO, and more!

Start Shopping

Related Stories
Exclusive: See A Preview of the 2023 Kleban Prize Ceremony, Streaming On Broadway On Deman Photo
Starting Friday, February 10 at 8PM, the 2023 Kleban Prize for Musical Theatre ceremony will stream, for free, on the Broadway On Demand SmartTV channel. 

Audra McDonald & Myles Frost Join Ava DuVernays CASTE Film Photo
Audra McDonald and Myles Frost have joined the cast of Ava DuVernay’s upcoming film Caste: The Origins of our Discontents. The pair will join the previously announced Jasmine Cephas-Jones, Aunjanue Ellis, Niecy Nash, Vera Farmiga, Nick Offerman, Connie Nielsen, and Jon Bernthal.

Video: Watch Anthony Rapp & John Rubinstein in Twisted Musical Sequel, TROUBLE Photo
Watch Jacob Chase's TROUBLE starring Anthony Rapp and Tony Award Winner John Rubinstein.

Jamie Brewer to Lead AMY & THE ORPHANS Film Adaptation Photo
Jamie Brewer will reprise her role in the film adaptation of the 2018 Off-Broadway play Amy & The Orphans. Lindsey Ferrentino will adapt the play for the big screen, also making her directorial debut with the film. Edward Barbanell will also star in the film as a new role written for the screen.

From This Author - Daria Vorobyeva

Musical theatre lover since 2009. Daria Vorobyeva has studied Journalism and took several courses on Cultural and Theatre Studies. She also writes about films (BLICKK, Geeks Empire).

... (read more about this author)