BWW Reviews: FROM HERE TO ETERNITY: THE MUSICAL, Cinema Release, July 3 2014

BWW Reviews: FROM HERE TO ETERNITY: THE MUSICAL, Cinema Release, July 3 2014

It's no secret that I was a big fan of From Here To Eternity: The Musical.

More than that, perhaps, the hour I spent chatting to composer Stuart Brayson was perhaps one of the most enjoyable interviews I've ever done (although it was tough to write it up - the soundbites were many and varied, as were the hilarious not-safe-for-work bons mots).

So I was absolutely delighted when the film release was finally confirmed: it's a movie version of the stage performance, and I was so pleased that the show might finally reach a bigger audience.

I'm thrilled that the touching performances of Robert Lonsdale and Siubhan Harrison as Prewitt and Lorene will get a wider viewing; and it is still a mystery to me why neither got nominated for an Olivier Award this year. You won't find a more moving masterclass of musical theatre acting than this pair; and if you can avoid beaming while you're watching their duet 'Love Me Forever Today', then you have a harder heart than me.

Darius Campbell's voice - speaking and singing - is beautifully resonant throughout, and the cameras pick up more of the connection between him and Rebecca Thornhill as Karen Holmes.

The close-ups offer the viewer a greater understanding of the emotion playing out; and if that sometimes negates the ability to see some of Javier De Frutos's sweeping military choreography, then perhaps it's a trade-off worth making.

I thought the show closed much too soon, but when I wrote my reflection I noted that the changes on the final night were still noticeable to anyone who'd seen it previously during the run.

I felt that way about the film version, if I'm honest. Maybe I am too emotionally attached to the show I saw develop and progress in the theatre, but every time I saw a change or a cut, I winced; my mind was screaming things like 'I want Maggio standing on a table and singing with the four romantic leads in five-part counterpoint, dammit!' I am having to remind myself that it's being used as a showcase for an American audience rather than a carbon copy for the hardy folk who were committed fans of the West End production - and if that's the aim, it succeeds.

Those new to the show won't notice the cuts, but they might notice what was, at least in my screening, a very peculiar dip in footage quality towards the end of the second act (yes, there's an intermission, just like in the old days).

However, that doesn't detract from the movie overall. Fans will just be pleased the show lives on; newcomers get to see a musical whose stage life was cut too short; and everyone can admire what I maintain is an exceptional piece of theatrical scoring. Now, for the CD...

More UK / West End!
Go to the Homepage

Comment & Share

About Author

Subscribe to Author Alerts
Carrie Dunn Carrie is the UK editor-in-chief for BroadwayWorld. After spending her formative years reading books and ending up with a Masters degree in English literature from King's College London, it was inevitable that Carrie should be a journalist. Her pure and simple delight in the art-form of musical theatre led to the Guardian asking her to be their West End Girl. Since then, she's picked up a PhD, and also written for many other UK publications, including the Times and the Independent. She has many eclectic loves, including sport, karaoke, reality television, MMORPGs, three-volume Victorian novels, the British seaside, embroidery and Veronica Mars.